3 ms·
According to the U.S. Energy Information administration, nuclear is more expensive than battery storage: https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/assumptions/pdf/table_
by yorwba 7y ago
According to the U.S. Energy Information administration, nuclear is more expensive than battery storage: https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/assumptions/pdf/table_8.2.pdf https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/assumptions/pdf/table_8.2.p...
- acidburnNSA 7y agoNuclear builds in the west right now have been boondoggles; the nuclear industry must regain its ability to build effectively to play a role here. This has been done before through standardization of design and serialization of production. This could conceivably be scaled back up if we were serious about decarbonization, with high likelihood of success given previous successes (e.g. France decarbonized 80% of its electricity grid in 15 years by building 58 standardized nuclear plants). Current prices for variable renewables and batteries are mostly on the current margin. Everyone agrees that costs of variable sources skyrocket as penetration increases due to curtailment and overbuilding. When you get 100% of your electricity on a sunny day (including from storage through the night) from solar, the next solar plant you build will have to be curtailed. Seasonal and crazy-weather variations are much harder and more expensive to fill with variable sources than the daily fluctuations. These lowlow prices we see headlines about today are about building renewables in a world alongside hilariously cheap fracked natural gas plants that can pick up the slack. There's good info along these lines in here: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy16osti/66970.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy16osti/66970.pdf Nuclear is unique in that it's the only low-carbon energy source that can run 24/7 for years at a time (followed by a month outage, then 2 more years, etc.). Hydro can kind of do this in certain geographies, but is very hard to scale to the point we need. Nuclear also uses far less land and raw materials than the variable renewables, especially when chemical battery storage is included. But yeah unless nuclear folks can get costs back down soon, no one is going to be interested. If in the end variable stuff is indeed hard at massive scale (I strongly believe this will be the case), then if we don't have nuclear, fracked and high-carbon natural gas and oil (for transportation) will be around at 50% of our total energy for a long time.
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoInteresting coincidence that France stopped at 80%. That's the same amount that widely touted as being straightforward with current renewable tech. I'd guess it's for the same reason, after that you're dealing with seasonal variations that would leave nuclear or renewables unused for most of the year.
- Reedx 7y agoYet in practice let's take a look at France (nuclear) vs Germany (leading solar/wind): "French electricity costs are just 59% of German electricity prices. As such, according to the prevailing economic wisdom, French electricity should be far more carbon intensive than German's. And yet the opposite is the case. France produces one-tenth the carbon pollution from electricity. Why? Because France generates 72% of its electricity from nuclear, and just 6% from solar and wind." France is cheaper and produces 2x more electricity from clean sources compared to Germany, where costs keep going up.
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoAnd yet both France and Germany plan to move to mostly renewable. Which the French government thinks will save them money. Something that probably wouldn't have been possible without Germany's far sighted leadership on this issue. I wonder how you could attribute the carbon saved by all the people choosing solar and wind as the current cheapest options to the people who put their money where their mouth was when that was just a projection.
- thrower123 7y agoRight. Far sighted leadership of shutting down perfectly good, clean, nuclear power plants, and trying to replace them with intermittent renewables. That need to be backed up by more reliable alternatives, like strip mining old-growth forests for dirty brown coal to burn in steam generators, or importing electricity from France's nuke plants. Just brilliant.
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoYou're thinking too small. Climate change and deforestation are global problems, and Germany has helped fund a global solution. Solar and wind are growing rapidly, they're currently passing the total yearly generation of nuclear but with 30% yearly growth will soon be adding the equivalent of the total nuclear fleet every year. It is actually brilliant. If Germany has sacrificed some of their own woodlands to make that happen then that's just more impressive.
- Gatsky 7y agoI don’t know how they compare these costs, the document doesn’t say. Battery storage doesn’t generate power after all. Nuclear power’s great feature is that all the externalities tend to be included in the price. This is also makes it look more expensive than almost anything else. Do these wind/solar prices include decommissioning and full life cycle maintenance costs?