5 ms·
Part 3 quotes /u/whiteinge on reddit¹: Let's assume the company is in jeopardy. Let's assume the project is over-promised and will be late and under-deliver. L
by teddyh 7y ago
Part 3 quotes /u/whiteinge on reddit¹:
Let's assume the company is in jeopardy. Let's assume the project is over-promised and will be late and under-deliver. Let's assume the CEO is a fuckup and the Marketing Director is a liar. None of that is as bad as NO smartphone alternative to Google and Apple, let alone an open and privacy-focused alternative. I'm a Linux user and I very much want a Linux phone. And there has been so, so many false starts and near misses over almost a decade. My patience and goodwill for Purism and the Librem 5 is effectively infinite. It's not over until they shutter the doors or can the project. Until that happens I will continue to hope they limp over that finish line no matter what.
1. https://www.reddit.com/r/Purism/comments/dm2smy/is_the_librem_5_being_targeted_in_a_viral_media/f54gaur/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Purism/comments/dm2smy/is_the_libre...
- badrabbit 7y agoWell said,if only someone throwed money at purism like they did with signal.
- akimball 7y agoIndeed, what good is signal on your phone, when your phone is out of your control?
- jdjdjjsjs 7y agoThis doesn't make sense to me. If all those things about the company and its execs are true they are almost certainly not gonna deliver the alternative you are clamoring for. In the meanwhile your money is sitting with them instead of a team that actually might
- robto 7y agoExcept that they are making progress. They've upstreamed some import work to the kernal, they've contributed to phosh and libhandy. They clearly aren't working as fast as they (or many others) would like, but they are working. And not many other people are. I also support hardware projects like ZeroPhone, Pine Phone, and the Dragonbox Pyra and software projects like Plasma Mobile. When I saw Purism articulate a vision for what a phone could be I had to support them too. I wish they collaborated and communicated better, and I wish they had made some different decisions regarding the stack, but at the end of the day they are slowly moving the ball forward. But when I gave them $600 I did it partly because they had a vision that I valued and I wanted to signal to others that it is a vision worth investing in. So I'm disappointed when I hear these reports, but I'm still supporting them because they are part of a very small community doing very important work. And since it's free software, it's not work that's going to waste, it can always be picked up by someone else. That's part of why it's so important.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoSo all someone needs to do to part you from your money is make a claim that they are "trying to make progress". Good to know.
- swiley 7y agoI've seen third party developers demoing the devkit, from my understanding they really just need to stick it in a plastic shell and it's more or less good to go (outside of some bugs with gtk or video playback or whatever, phone calls and the shell works and that's all I want.)
- squarefoot 7y ago"... None of that is as bad as NO smartphone alternative to Google and Apple, let alone an open and privacy-focused alternative. ..." I couldn't agree more. Unfortunately not off the shelf hardware is expensive, software support for it (device drivers) is even more expensive if not plain impossible to obtain from manufacturers in the form of open documentation, and all off the shelf phones prevent any open operating system from running on them by design, therefore making a new platform from scratch is the only viable albeit very expensive solution. I wish Purism, Pine64 and others best luck, however. In the meantime I can only dream of laws that would force hardware manufacturers to release technical data about hardware after either X years or once they declare it obsolete or some time after they stopped selling/supporting it. Just think of the huge decrease in pollution when a startup could take all those Android 2.0+ phones, all those junk iPhone clones from 5-7 years ago, and convert them say into home controllers, portable music players etc. Old phones became junk over time because the manufacturers programmed them to become as such by refusing any kind of repurposing.
- noobermin 7y agoIf I'm not wrong, the fight for the right to repair if it were to succeed would facilitate this.
- zozbot234 7y ago> Just think of the huge decrease in pollution when a startup could take all those Android 2.0+ phones...and convert them say into home controllers, portable music players etc. When it comes to Android 2.0-or-so phones, this is already possible in many cases. Just grab an old CyanogenMod image from the archived version of the site, grab kernel sources from the Lineage OS git repository, and start hacking on support for that phone as part of the postmarketOS project. The real problem is that every single one of those phone models runs on bespoke hardware, there's no standardization like you would find on the PC platform. It's a lot of effort for an unclear gain. A startup is not going to do this, especially when those phones are irredeemably insecure against sophisticated attackers, due to proprietary implementations in the baseband and WiFi/BT radio components.
- 7y ago
- wvh 7y agoMeego, Jolla, Puzzlephone, Firefox phone, Ubuntu phone, Librem, etc... Is there really that little demand that it's a nearly impossible task to get any "alternative" phone going?
- gh02t 7y agoI'm not sure it's demand so much as extremely high barriers to entry. Android and iOS are both mature and have a lot of features, plus manufacturers like Apple and Samsung have a lot invested into the latest and greatest SoCs and other hardware features. Matching all that right out of the gate and building competitive hardware and an OS is hard, making it difficult to make something that the average consumer will notice.
- noobermin 7y agoTbh, I have more hope in the Pinephone because they aren't trying to be too pure in that they're supporting Android to start but hopefully will allow other OS'es as well. Doing the whole nine yards (in addition to trying to make the thing blob free) is going to take more than up front investment that other, already established manufacturers don't have to deal with, which is giving them a handicap in a fight they start behind in.
- unforeseen9991 7y agoThat handicap is also mitigated by a fanatical fanbase who will support a failing company to the end on principle. You can't say that about most current manufacturers
- make3 7y agoplus paying for all the software patents
- noobermin 7y agoMade a comment below to this effect, I don't think it's mere demand, there are possibly bigger hurdles to making an appealing product that can rival cheapo mobile phones.
- theamk 7y agoThe same part then says: > However there are now so many signs that Purism isn't competent enough to be trusted with a phone, much less our privacy, that I cannot in good conscience do business with them. Do you really want a badly executed Linux phone? If it ends up with major security vulnerabilities, vendor spyware and other nasty stuff, it will only harm the idea of Linux phone itself.
- thawaway1837 7y agoI honestly think the LightPhone people have the right idea. They aren’t trying to compete with Google/Apple. They simply made a simple device whose idea is to not be a smartphone at all. It’s basically a feature phone, but far less distracting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tluyben2 7y agoGoing completely open takes a lot of money as you need to do the work yourself. Also it seems [0] that a lot of that work would be illegal in most (all?) countries. Starting to work on opening things up (RiscV cpu + everything that is not illegal/possible to open up, so I guess all but ble+wifi+gsm) opened up and then working with the authorities to open up those would be something I would put money into. Long term all this closed stuff in laptops, phones etc will be bad for many reasons. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/comments/36aqdx/what_do_we_need_for_competitive_opensource_gsm/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/comments/36aqdx/what...