4 ms·
Couldn't you do other types of storage rather than batteries? Pumped storage can do very fast spin-up because gravity doesn't take any time to warm up, nothing
by tialaramex 7y ago
Couldn't you do other types of storage rather than batteries? Pumped storage can do very fast spin-up because gravity doesn't take any time to warm up, nothing to 1.8GW in a few seconds at Dinorwig (in Wales), if you own half a dozen of those then 11GW in 3 hours feels like child's play.
Not everywhere has the geography for building power stations inside mountains (which is the only way to do pumped storage that isn't horribly ugly), but the US is huge and seems like there are mountains everywhere you look in some parts, surely some of them are suitable for hiding a pumped storage facility?
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThere were two or three backup sites within 15 miles of Dinorwig that were being evaluated prior to it being built. There in case the main site proved impractical or too expensive for some reason. I'd posit there are ample disused quarry sites that could serve a similar purpose scattered around the UK, US and much of the developed world.
- diafygi 7y agoHmmmm, yes, probably. However the reasons for deploying millions of lithium batteries instead of a few dozen pumped hydro stations are likely more political and business reasons than technical reasons. First, it's way easier and faster to just park containers full of batteries wherever you need to shift the energy than to find and build new pumped hydro location then build/upgrade the transmission to the locations where the load shifting is needed. And when you need the load shifting ASAP, you're probably going to opt for the solution that can deployed now, especially when the regulatory reaction to this problem is to adjust prices ("time of use" rates) to discourage people from using power during the slope. Second, battery installers are able to sell directly to consumers, which means they can bypass utility bureaucracy. Many utilities are very slow to adopt "non-wires alternatives" because their business model doesn't incentivize them to building out a distributed, flexible grid, and they are increasingly becoming worried about their generation assets being financially stranded. This means that it's often easier to sell thousands of energy storage units to thousands of homes and businesses, than it is to sell that same thousand units directly to the utility. With pumped hydro, there's no distributed option, so you end up being at the mercy of the utility wanting your product. So yes, you're probably right that pumped hydro is on paper cheaper for addressing the Duck Curve "neck" problem, but this is a case where the difference between theory and reality is substantial for non-technical reasons.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lazyguy2 7y ago> Couldn't you do other types of storage rather than batteries? Sure. But they all have their own downsides. Pump air into vast underground tunnels. Pump water into towers. Spin up massive drums as flywheels (this one is my favorite. Spinning weights are incredibly power dense). Lift massive weights. It's all been done. There are companies working on making these things more practical. Meanwhile the power companies have instituted new standards in grid-tied inverters for solar panels that have effectively solved the problem for them. It's based on the frequency of the grid. As the grid becomes over powered it's frequency tends to shift a bit higher. As the grid becomes over loaded the frequency tends to shift a bit lower. By responding to these frequency shifts the grid-tied inverters will either allow electricity to be generated when the frequency falls back slightly, throttle electrical generation when the frequency rises slightly, and then shut off completely when the grid goes down. So the effect is that those expensive solar panel arrays in places were they are already popular... are effectively shut off during the peak solar power generation hours. And are turned off completely when the grid itself is shutdown. Lithium batteries represent a unique opportunity for truly distributed power generation. They are just reaching the point, price-wise, were they can be used as a practical way to store energy on a individual small business or household manner. This way individuals themselves can take charge of their own power needs and no longer has to rely on centralized bureaucracies to save the world for them. Unfortunately due to the way grid-tied systems are now required to work it has effectively nullified most of the benefits of having private solar arrays. IF you want to be your own power generator you have to be off-grid to do it. And this the reason this is unfortunate is because almost nobody is building private solar arrays this way. There is a semi-religious belief that grid-tied systems allow a ROI in the form of selling power back to the grid. Also they are built with the assumption that battery backups for the house is too expensive and impractical. All these things are true if you are looking at low-voltage SLA battery arrays and grid-tied standards from 5-10 years ago, but with high voltage lithium power (it's a lot cheaper to convert 300v DC to 240v AC then it is to convert 48v DC to 240v AC), how accounting for energy usage has changed, and how grid-tied systems are being remote controlled by the power company this is not necessarily the truth anymore.
- rory096 7y agoCan you link a cite for those standards for grid-tied inverters? I've never heard of grid-commanded curtailment for home solar — generally those frequency signals are created by the inverter to tell the (AC-coupled) PV to turn off when a house is off-grid and the battery is full.
- rory096 7y agoThe Bath County Pumped Storage Station in Virginia stores 24GWh. It was built between 1977 and 1985 at a nominal cost of $1.6 billion.[0] If we conservatively take those as 1985 dollars, that's equivalent to $3.9 billion in 2019 dollars, or $162.5/kWh. That's comparable to today's price for lithium ion battery storage (~$176/kWh[1]), even before taking into account the massive real increase in cost of large infrastructure projects over the last 35 years. That said, Dominion Energy recently selected a site for a planned second pumped storage facility, conceptually entering operation in 2030.[2] It's a long way off from construction, but they claim that the current budget is $2 billion.[3][4] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Sta... [1] https://about.bnef.com/blog/behind-scenes-take-lithium-ion-battery-prices/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/behind-scenes-take-lithium-ion-b... [2] https://www.roanoke.com/news/local/dominion-narrows-to-tazewell-county-site-for-possible-hydroelectric-facility/article_f8376628-cea2-5cdb-8d4a-7e9b225041da.html https://www.roanoke.com/news/local/dominion-narrows-to-tazew... [3] https://www.dominionenergy.com/company/making-energy/renewable-generation/water/powering-southwest-virginia https://www.dominionenergy.com/company/making-energy/renewab... [4] https://www.nrdc.org/experts/walton-shepherd/dominions-greenwashed-pumped-storage-pipedream-wont-fly https://www.nrdc.org/experts/walton-shepherd/dominions-green...
- phyzome 7y agoPumped hydro needs a pretty specific geographic profile. It's pretty great where it works, but good luck finding good candidate spots. Some people have been working on an approach pulling railcars full of rock up a slope, which should have more location options, but I don't know how the math and economics works out.
- fluffything 7y ago> Some people have been working on an approach pulling railcars full of rock up a slope, which should have more location options, but I don't know how the math and economics works out. Have a link?
- detaro 7y agohttps://www.aresnorthamerica.com/article/8736-america%E2%80%99s-first-commercial-scale-rail-energy-storage-project-receives-blm-approval https://www.aresnorthamerica.com/article/8736-america%E2%80%...
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThere's a similar approach that seems promising - dropping a huge weight down disused mine shafts, and winching it back up at times of low demand. It looks to be a lot simpler than the railway wagon approach. The UK has loads of potential sites, I imagine the US does too. A fairly detailed look: http://euanmearns.com/short-term-energy-storage-with-gravitricity-iron-versus-ion/ http://euanmearns.com/short-term-energy-storage-with-gravitr...
- imtringued 7y agoIt doesn't. The only gravity based storage mechanisms that work out take their materials from the immediate environment like hydraulic hydro storage which scales up to 2 TWh for a large storage plant.