3 ms·
> Natural gas ramps as quickly as it can. But let's assume that's true, that's not a point against me, it's a point against solar because then it means that sol
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Natural gas ramps as quickly as it can. But let's assume that's true, that's not a point against me, it's a point against solar because then it means that solar is completely unworkable.
You're thinking about this wrong. If you want 100% generation from solar then you need a ton of storage, period. But who says it has to be 100% solar or 0?
Take a look at the daily electricity demand curve. Lower at night, higher during the day. The (large) difference between the nighttime demand and the daytime demand? That's what you use solar for. Even if batteries are completely off the table, solar is still useful for that. And in that case your natural gas plants only have to run for a couple of hours between sunset and bedtime instead of all day long.
We don't know if storage technologies are ever going to be cost effective enough to use 100% solar day and night. They're not right now, but they're also declining in price. If they get there, well, that's the end of the matter. If not, you use nuclear at night, supplement it with solar during the day and, in the long term, suffer the high cost of batteries for a couple hours around dusk, which is still a whole lot cheaper than needing enough of them to get you through the whole night.
But you have a significant amount of solar in every case. And it can also take on close to 100% of the new load from charging electric vehicles simply by charging them while the sun is out.
- macspoofing 7y ago>And in that case your natural gas plants only have to run for a couple of hours between sunset and bedtime instead of all day long. Right. So we agree, solar cannot remove carbon emissions. And I thought the entire point is to remove fossil fuels entirely from energy generation, not just reduce it. >you use nuclear at night It doesn't work like that. Nuclear can take days to ramp up and ramp down. Solar does not play well with nuclear. That's one problem. A more major issue is...if you're using nuclear, why the heck do you even need solar? This is the energy mix of my home province[1] - we're essentially fossil fuel-free because our energy mix is nuclear and hydro. There is no point in increasing investment in solar and wind. But we're doing it, not because it's good for reducing carbon emission, but because it's a fad. [1] http://live.gridwatch.ca/home-page.html http://live.gridwatch.ca/home-page.html
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> So we agree, solar cannot remove carbon emissions. Except for all the carbon emissions it does remove while the sun is shining and you didn't have to run that natural gas plant for 14 hours instead of 2. > It doesn't work like that. Nuclear can take days to ramp up and ramp down. Solar does not play well with nuclear. You don't ramp it up and down at all. You have 100GW of demand at night and 200GW during the day, so you have 100GW of nuclear and 100GW of solar. Nuclear generates 100GW night and day and the solar generates an additional 100GW during the day. > A more major issue is...if you're using nuclear, why the heck do you even need solar? Because it's cheaper during the day and there is more demand during the day.
- hansthehorse 7y agoI live in Southeast Florida and worked for Florida Power and Light for over 20 years. They called the 3pm to 11pm shift the peak shift for a reason.