8 ms·
Such a strategy failed utterly in Canada. They moved a government department from Ottawa to Miramichi, New Brunswick for similar reasons. All the skilled bur
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
Such a strategy failed utterly in Canada. They moved a government department from Ottawa to Miramichi, New Brunswick for similar reasons. All the skilled bureaucrats used their reputations to get transfers to a different department so they wouldn't have to uproot their family, and the department was rebuilt around a core of incompetents. I'm sure the locals they hired weren't so incompetent, but rot starts from the top. That move caused the failure of the long-gun registry and a waste of $2B. After the long gun registry was cancelled they used the same department to rewrite the pay system (code name Phoenix) and have managed to waste about $5B so far, and growing.
That's about $50 million wasted per job.
- ska 7y agoI'm not sure about the long gun registry, but the core issues around the failure of the Phoenix pay system are much more complicated that the above suggests.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThat's true; but that's where the problems started, IMO. For example, IBM deserves a rich share of the blame, but who hired and oversaw IBM?
- ep103 7y agoAll good plans can be executed badly, the devil is always in the details : D I was not proposing the above example as a foolproof plan applicable to every situation, so much as an example of a type of plan that has worked in some scenarios in the past. I should also point out that part of the plan for the Scandinavian plan wasn't the replacement of government workers with locals, as much as the expectation that by moving so many jobs into such small areas, they were guaranteed to majorly shift the local economies. Numerous jobs opened up overnight supporting all these well paid government employees moving into the area. Nonetheless, I am happy to learn about the counter-example, thank you!
- distances 7y agoIt would be nice if you could name the country and bureaucracy of the success story. I know of one such move; the experts made it known they'd rather resign and find new jobs than move to the periphery with their families. The move was cancelled as it was pointless without the experts.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> It would be nice if you could name the country and bureaucracy of the success story. I know of one such move; the experts made it known they'd rather resign and find new jobs than move to the periphery with their families. The move was cancelled as it was pointless without the experts. It would be nice if you could name the failure you cite, too. Government experts will live in a lot of places. NASA has major operations in a metro area in Alabama with only ~500k people, for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Space_Flight_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Space_Flight_Center. That's more periphery than center, in my mind.
- distances 7y ago> It would be nice if you could name the failure you cite, too. Sorry, should of course named it as that's what I was asking. It was the move of the Finnish Medicines Agency from Helsinki to Kuopio. Checking the latest status, they do now have presence in both cities so it wasn't cancelled in the end; I guess they pushed on but ended keeping the Helsinki office for the experts refusing to relocate. Do you have the name of your example?
- wahern 7y agoFailure has to be an option. Not attempting such things doesn't mean we avoid the risk of such wealth destruction; it just means we have nobody to a point a finger at when it happens. Politically this is easier because of how people think and the dynamics of our social discourse. See Appeal to Nature Fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature). This is especially true the more cynical and ideological we become as we're more likely to pounce on failures of action, but excuse failures of inaction as inevitable natural events or limitations.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoBut when we attempt them we should discard the assumption that people and therefore labor behaves like a fluid. In scales of hundreds of years it does but in scales of decades it behaves like Legos or the ice stuck at the bottom of your glass. All kinds of motivations affect people's stickiness to a place, a lifestyle or a career. It's hard to know what will dislodges them or how far you can tip the glass before they all rush forward at the same time and smack you in the face.
- pnutjam 7y agoMore and more it seems like some sort of UBI or welfare system is the only real option. Give people an income floor and don't worry if they flourish above that, at least to a certain extent.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> More and more it seems like some sort of UBI or welfare system is the only real option. Give people an income floor and don't worry if they flourish above that, at least to a certain extent. Except: 1) UBI is unproven and 2) it strikes me as a bit of a band-aid solution designed mainly to avoid confronting certain ideological assumptions.
- andrekandre 7y agoalso if it’s a fixed value (say $1000 a month), it 1. doesn’t cover the rising costs of medical care and insurance (in the us at least) 2. won’t keep up with inflation 3. sets up private markets to potentially inflate prices “because people have 1000 dollars extra to spend” UBI in concert with price limits for basic goods and services, insurance reform, and medical costs limits might have a chance.... but then you are now confronted with the potential that it’s now the “rich and large corporations” who are subsidizing everyone, giving them extraordinary political power over the govt/people i’m still skeptical of UBI
- CydeWeys 7y agoI'm skeptical of UBI too, but I think it would work best with the following combination: 1. UBI (including some fractional amount per child) 2. Free universal healthcare (i.e. Medicare is no longer age-limited) 3. Better education & free public universities 4. Some kind of higher tiers of UBI for disabled people who really need it (judged strictly) And then get rid of every single other means-tested benefit (including Social Security), as well as tax-advantaged retirement plans (which overwhelmingly benefit the already well-off), and get rid of the favorable tax on LTCGs and carried interest; everything pays full-freight income tax. After this, benefits are either free to everyone (i.e. healthcare) or you pay full freight out of your UBI. And UBI is not scaled by CoL, because it doesn't make sense to subsidize landlords in expensive cities. And even with all of that, it's not clear that it won't be vastly more expensive than the current system, making it effectively unaffordable. There's also the issue that some people will not spend their money correctly, e.g. they'll fritter it away on drugs/alcohol and not have enough to pay rent or buy food. So you'd need some kind of combination of food stamps and Section 8 housing vouchers, paid out of UBI, for people who need to be forced to allocate their money correctly (as there will no longer be any separate means-tested food stamps or housing assistance). I could see something like this working in smaller, well-connected, yet independent communities, but I'm struggling to see how it could scale up to a country the size of the US. The rich would be paying so much more in taxes to essentially subisidize many people who might choose not to work at all, that I think it's inevitable they'd manage to overthrow it. Like you, I think from a realpolitik view of things (if nothing else), that it can't work.
- BenoitEssiambre 7y agoI don't think the good people of Miramichi are to blame for this. It's the people in Ottawa who wrote a blank check to Oracle/IBM for attempting to migrate a large part of the government software infrastructure to their incompatible system. Somehow, the contract was that billions would be disbursed to IBM/Oracle whether their system worked or not (it didn't). Also I don't think Oracle should be allowed to hide behind the Phoenix name. This was Oracle PeopleSoft. Why would you pay billions for a piece of software when the maker isn't even willing to put it's name on it?
- repolfx 7y agoThe Phoenix failure wasn't really a software failure, if I recall correctly. It was more that when everything moved to Miramichi the people who understood the byzantine government pay systems basically didn't follow and the result was people with no clue of what they wanted or how to do it being heavily involved. No software firm can succeed in those conditions.
- generatorguy 7y agoOracle / IBM had an existing working payroll system to copy. All they had to do was reimplement it in modern hardware and software. Some government employee in Miramichi might not have been happy because oracle didn’t listen to what they thought they wanted but if the contract has been to deliver a system that produced the exact same output as the old one oracle/ibm would have no excuse for not having a successful project. It is astounding nobody was fired for this.
- jeffdavis 7y agoI'm not so sure it's easy to represent the exact behavior of a complex system. What would your estimate be to: "rewrite facebook in language L, with the same behavior, bugs and all".
- pas 7y agoDoing an incremental approximation is very much possible. And it's up to the customer to say when to stop. And also to judge the sufficiency of the speed of convergence.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago>> they expected significant job distortion as a result of free trade. So they literally moved government agencies from their current locations, to locations that they expected would be hardest hit. > Such a strategy failed utterly in Canada. It's possible the strategy is good, they just utterly failed at executing it for other reasons.
- barry-cotter 7y agoThe long gun registry would have failed even if it had been delivered on time and under budget, to spec. They had less than 10% compliance with the law and putting 5-10% of the population in jail was never going to happen. Much like Prohibition in the states banning things that large portions of the population have no problem with doesn’t work, and the Canadian populace is plugged in to the US media enough to know that a gun registry is a prerequisite for any campaign of confiscation.