4 ms·
> A gaming engine just really doesn't seem to fit that mold. if it had been unity or unreal engine, would you have changed your opinion?
by chii 7y ago
> A gaming engine just really doesn't seem to fit that mold.
if it had been unity or unreal engine, would you have changed your opinion?
- gbear605 7y agoAs far as I can tell, throwing 500m at either Unity nor the Unreal Engine wouldn’t be a good allocation of money either, although better than staying in Softbank’s hands.
- foobarian 7y agoAre those profitable to the tune of 500M? Ultimately investors in some of these research projects don't recoup their money. They used to do it because it was the prevailing culture of the day, e.g. see Xerox PARC or Bell Labs. Today it seems they have to get tricked into it.
- zaroth 7y agoIt never ceases to amaze me the depth of the world economy, and how seemingly small niches can add up to billion dollar markets. But $500mm is a tremendous amount of money to raise pre-revenue, which would really only be appropriate in an area with tremendous barriers to entry. Gaming physics, AI, map generation, etc. all seem like exactly the kind of thing that you can break apart into smaller pieces to get to market quickly and iteratively. It's not like a molecule that needs to through Phase 3 trials, or a rocket which needs to make orbit, or something with a huge CapEx component. Even rockets can scale up from computer models, to scale models, to rough prototypes, etc.
- k__ 7y agoIt's that fact that led to FB and Google. IBM didn't see MS coming, MS didn't see Google coming, Google didn't see FB coming, etc. The beauty of this is that things look done and then someone see a new niche and it turns out it wasn't a niche, but something millions of people wanted.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoI wouldn't go as far as to say the Improbable deal made sense, but your analysis here is pretty shallow. SpatialOS isn't really something that can be built as a series of libraries a la carte and individually proven. It's an opinionated and tightly integrated approach to solving a very difficult problem, and the entire point is the turnkey platform. Either it's ready to build notable games on, or it's not. Further, Improbable wants developers to pull the trigger on spending millions or even tens of millions developing titles for the platform. Investing this much in a platform that fails is an existential crisis for a games company. There's no way your half built SpatialOS game can run anywhere else. Therefore, confidence is key, and raising an eye watering amount of money is basically table stakes to be taken seriously. Whether it's worth solving a problem that can't be broken down in viable independent chunks is another matter (I have no interest in that personally). I'm not saying I'd invest at that valuation either. But it's certainly not as straight forward as you seem to be claiming.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 7y agoActually I saw a presentation about pharmacy companies already aquiring startups at Phase 1 or even after pre-clinical trials, so VC money isn't needed post Phase 1 generally.
- munchbunny 7y agoI don’t think so, because game engines shouldn’t need $500 million to prove themselves. If you could make the case that the software was irreducibly complex, then maybe. More generally, just because Unity and Epic are worth more now, doesn’t mean it would have been a good idea to pour money in back then. Hindsight isn’t an actionable heuristic.
- dmix 7y agoSpatialOS isn't building a 'game engine' though, it's something that plugs into Unity/Epic, with a service whose revenue model extends beyond the initial game development to support services for the whole lifespan of the game.
- munchbunny 7y agoI was responding directly to the parent question: "if it had been unity or unreal engine, would you have changed your opinion?" Your point may be true. I don't think it's a $500 million point to prove, but I also haven't looked at SpatialOS enough to take that stand.
- thrower123 7y agoThat's such a crowded market though, with CryEngine, Godot, Lumberyard, and yet more competing for attention.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThose are bad examples because they didn't need huge unprofitable upfront investments. Unreal engine, for example, was a side benefit of creating a game that was itself profitable, and then they realized they could make additional money from licensing the engine, and did so. It simply doesn't take massive upfront independent investment to develop game engines, and the market is already crowded with all sorts of good options some of which are even developed on a volunteer basis (like Minecraft which originally used the open source LWJGL).
- jayparth 7y agoThis comment doesn't really make sense to me. To me, (paraphrasing heavily), the comment two tiers above you is trying to say, "The upside is not high enough as typical moonshot companies to raise as much as they did. Plus, they could have probably broken the problem down further." The guy above you responds: "But these game engines had very high upside." And you respond: "But those game engines didn't need high upfront investment. And none really do, you can make them cheaply." That wasn't the point of the guy above. His point is, "There may be enough upside to building a really good game engine." The hypothesis of this company is by spending a lot of money building a really good game engine, they can get upside like Unreal. Whether or not that hypothesis makes sense is entirely a different discussion than: "Is there enough upside to justify this hypothesis", the question at hand.
- celticmusic 7y agoThat's not what the poster you're responding to said. Ruby on Rails was extracted from the creation of a website, basecamp. Once they were done creating it they realized they could extract a new framework out of it and did so. This has multiple benefits. 1. profitable from the get go 2. design geared towards solving actual problems What the person above you is saying is that the Unreal Engine was created in the same manner, whereas SpatialOS was not. And because of that, the risk was much lower.
- jayparth 7y agoI agree with you, but why was the person above me commenting on risk? While it is true that those things happened with Unreal Engine, it was sideways from the discussion that was occurring, but presented as a refutation. Risk has nothing to do with the comment two tier above me. I'm just pointing that out.