5 ms·
Sounds too ambitious. There are people working at 900kw chargers at BYD, and they say that cabling for it is already so stiff and heavy that it's bordering on
by baybal2 7y ago
Sounds too ambitious.
There are people working at 900kw chargers at BYD, and they say that cabling for it is already so stiff and heavy that it's bordering on the limit of what is humanly possible to handle.
Under spec electronic components are exploding in split second. Imagine a bank of DC-DC converters operating at 600A, and where few stages go out of sync. 10% of 600A is still 60A that turns into heat, in addition to heat already generated by normal operation.
- tw04 7y agoIn a mining situation, why would you think they’d be handled by humans? I would expect it to be a machine driven coupler. Completely unrealistic in a consumer situation due to potential damage and liability. But in a mine? Nobody is going to care about a scratched body panel.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThey might care about horrific electrical accidents. With High voltage/high Amperage acidents - your lucky if you die on the spot otherwise you last a few days in intensive care with limbs blown off and your internal organs destroyed
- criddell 7y agoMines are such dangerous places that horrific electrical accidents may happen occasionally and it's still an improvement from the current situation.
- ivankolev 7y agoI think the end goal is to not have humans on the field unless something untoward happens.
- donkeyd 7y agoYou can couple mechanically, but get a human to check before actually supplying power. Seems like a simple thing to fix.
- Reason077 7y agoLike EV chargers, the couplers and protocols are designed with safety in mind. It's not like you're plugging in to a giant electrical socket and throwing a switch. The system handshakes, runs tests for current leakage, etc. If anything doesn't check out 100%, it won't energise.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoHave you not heard of murphy's law, or not thought that miners might take shortcuts and bodge a connection.
- Kirby64 7y agoThen where are all the folks dying today from the high power Tesla Supercharger incidents? 2MW or 250kW, either way you'll be dead if that accidentally lights you up. If you set the system up right, you can't do that in a meaningful way, and if you do... well there's 2MW of deterrent. It only takes one workplace incident like that to make sure the bosses put some measures in place to make sure it never happens again. And keep in mind: at that kind of power level, you aren't just zapping one person... it's probably going to destroy a LOT of equipment and infrastructure... so there's a hefty monetary incentive to make sure that never happens.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoConsumer EV charging is basically a cooker circuit. When you go to serious Amperage and High/Medium Voltages its a completely different ball game.
- Kirby64 7y agoSure, the wall chargers you have in your house are. You think the 400V, 625A circuits (250kW chargers) are just dumb circuits though? Fairly certain they have temperature and voltage monitoring on both sides of the cable and both sides of the connector, all to monitor for any issues with either the connector or the cable continuously. Anything goes wrong, gets to hot, etc? It kills power. You're right though. Medium voltage circuits (and above) are going to be much more complex. The fact is, once you start operating at medium voltage and above, stuff that previously was an insulator may not actually be as insulating as you think...
- pi-rat 7y agoThey use these kinds of automatic couplers for the electric ferries here in Norway: https://youtu.be/epOAE8pudsg https://youtu.be/epOAE8pudsg
- Reason077 7y ago> "Sounds too ambitious." Perhaps I'm naive, but I believe ABB know what they're doing when it comes to high power electrical systems. These guys build AC-DC converters in the range of several gigawatts for HVDC links.
- MisterTea 7y agoI used to do some welding with a stick welder with 100 feet of 4/0 gauge copper welding cable. Super heavy to drag around and very difficult to wind up. And that was for a few kW. So these 2MW cables will need mechanical support. You can use parallel cables with fine strands or water cooled cables supported by a balanced or power assisted arm to assist in manipulating those cables. So that's not really a big deal. And 2MW isn't that ambitious considering much larger switched power systems exist like the 70MW 25 cycle static inverters for Amtrak's system in Sunnyside yards. See also large scale PV solar installs.
- londons_explore 7y agoA quick thought experiment... If you wanted to transfer 2MW, you could do it at 200 amps and 10,000 volts. Two 200 amp conductors, 3 meters long, and 10 mm^2 cross sectional area will come out at half a kilogram. 400 watts of heating will happen in the wire, which could be cooled by a 1mm^2 water/steam cooling pipe running at 1 ml/sec. That weighs another 6 grams. Insulating a 10,000 volt supply sounds a lot, but if the wire was insulated with PTFE, with a 10x safety margin, you would only need a thickness of 1mm on each conductor. Total weight 140 grams. So - the total weight of a 2 Megawatt human-safe cable could, with the right engineering, be under a kilogram for 3 meters of cable, plenty to hook up your car or truck.
- baybal2 7y ago10kw? You will either need top tier, liquid cooled IGBTs or magnetics — both are not an option on a car. Maximum what FETs your money can buy can handle is 1500V. It's not them being that heavy, it's them being very stiff.
- MisterTea 7y agoIGCT's can handle a few kV and 1000's of amps. Plus you can setries them and increase the blocking voltage. Same goes for IGBT's, SCR's.
- MisterTea 7y ago
- londons_explore 7y agoDC electrical systems go far bigger than 2MW. The science and engineering is well known. Thats why this is more of a standardisation effort than a research effort. And considering what a massive fuckup CCS made of electric car chargers (there are 5+ incompatible standards!), lets hope they've learned their lessons for trucks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- loufe 7y agoYou bring up a good point. Perhaps the solution is just to eliminate or reduce the human factor. I imagine for anything equipment so large it requires such a setup for charging would probably be worth the investment in an automated, or at least machine-aided, charging cable inserter.