7 ms·
>Code is written entirely in Arabic, highlighting cultural biases of computer science and challenging the assumptions we make about programming. There are lots
by coldtea 7y ago
>Code is written entirely in Arabic, highlighting cultural biases of computer science and challenging the assumptions we make about programming.
There are lots of "cultural biases in computer science" -- in UI, neural network training, encodings, terms of service, etc.
Of all of them, this is the least helpful, and the least important.
It's like doing math in local notation, or translating latin/greek terms doctors all over the world are trained and understand, with regional varieties.
There's a reason why e.g. air traffic control speaks english no matter the ethnicity (as per the ICAO standard).
(And I don't mean programming language terminology / modifiers has to be english for any special reason. It could just as well have been French or whatever. But it has to be a single one, and english is already used for that purpose).
And I'm no native english speaker, so I don't say this as one.
- danpalmer 7y ago> There's a reason why e.g. air traffic control speaks english no matter the ethnicity (as per the ICAO standard). Yes. The reason is that air traffic control inherently requires people from different regions and languages to communicate quickly in life or death situations. Ease of being an air-traffic controller is not a primary motivating factor, and getting more diverse input isn't really a useful feature. On the other hand, ease of being a developer should be something we strive for. We don't generally deal with fast paced life or death communication, we instead want programming to be accessible, to get a range of people (and their input, experience, opinions) involved, and to break down unnecessary barriers. Programming in a foreign language is a pretty significant barrier.
- johnisgood 7y agoWhat do you mean exactly by "programming in a foreign language is a pretty significant barrier", and why is reducing this barrier to strive for? I believe English as a common language is a good thing for communication, for understanding each other. It could have been any other languages I suppose, but today it is English. It may change. I cannot even talk about programming in my first language because I would not have gotten any use out of it. It would not have been beneficial to me to learn the terminology in my first language. English, however, was pretty much beneficial. I am not sure that division here would be beneficial to the field, but this is just my opinion. Yes, it is a barrier for people who, for some reasons, are not willing to learn the common language which, today, is English. Is it a bad thing? In my opinion, it is not. It could be a way of expressing your dedication and willingness in some cases. I wanted to understand, and I wanted to be understood, and knew that learning English was the way to do it, so I learnt it. Having many different languages would defeat the purpose of what having a common language gives us, which binds us together.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DeusExMachina 7y ago> Programming in a foreign language is a pretty significant barrier. Not really. I learned programming when I was 14, far before learning English. How many English constructs do you have in a programming language? Func, var, for, if, else, import, etc. You can memorize those in no time, especially if you do that as you learn programming. Documentation and textbooks are a different thing, of course. But I learned programming in high school, from teachers speaking my language and with textbook in my language.
- fermuch 7y agoI started programming at age 10, with game maker. I cannot stress how useful having icons for each operation is. I remember not knowing what a loop was (I didn't even understand what a variable was), but having the "steps" icon made it clear to me that it was run on every step the player makes (which is approximate, but IIRC it was simply a while loop)
- Mirioron 7y ago>How many English constructs do you have in a programming language? Func, var, for, if, else, import, etc. Func and var aren't even English words. Even an English speaker would have to at least get confirmation that their guess is right. You could replace them with arbitrary symbols and it wouldn't rally really change anything.
- big_chungus 7y agoSee APL, equally horrendous for everyone: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APL_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APL_(programming_language)
- hhas01 7y agoNot for those who professionally speak Mathematics; which is the audience APL was made to serve, after all. Amusing so many programmers will complain how they feel horribly excluded by APL, but see no issue with every other programming language in existence speaking exclusively ASCII English. At least Math is a true lingua franca, unlike our awful Saxon bodge. I know which I'd be safer speaking when Aliens come to visit. https://youtu.be/t2TDf9XU09k?t=120 https://youtu.be/t2TDf9XU09k?t=120
- missosoup 7y ago> On the other hand, ease of being a developer should be something we strive for. Yeah, no. I want to strive for a field of professionals who know what they're doing instead of every second 'engineer' being a script kiddie with a MOOC or two of Python under their belt and nothing else. The barriers need to come way up from where they are today, not be lowered even further.
- rfhjt 7y agoShould we introduce a license to publish math papers? This should supposedly raise the overall level of mathematicians.
- missosoup 7y agoThere is a license if you want to hit a nonzero audience. It's called peer review. It's merit based. You might have heard about it.
- danpalmer 7y agoI'm not talking about lowering standards, I'm talking about lowering barriers. The difference is that barriers are things that aren't necessary. It is not necessary to be male, white, or English speaking, to be an excellent engineer, and yet those groups are significantly over represented.
- missosoup 7y ago> I'm not talking about lowering standards, I'm talking about lowering barriers. One and the same. Making it easier to join a group necessarily lowers the barrier for joining said group which necessarily lowers the standard of said group. There are entire books written about this problem which leads to it being impossible to build large above-average skilled teams. No need to bring identity politics into engineering practice. They have as much place here as they do in getting a pilot license. There is a minimum bar to pass, and part of that bar is speaking a common parlance with members of your professional body from the rest of the world. I'm sorry you feel upset that English happened to be the language of choice for that, I personally just invested the time to learn it. I get paid more than doctors or pilots with the same amount of experience as me, so I'm not going to start complaining about satisfying the same language requirements that they deal with.
- konstmonst 7y agoI think if you are programming in a native language programming language, there is a problem, that you can not find enough help and you don't have things like stackoverflow. You don't immediately see useful patterns and answers to questions and the effectiveness of the language and of your understanding is reduced. Unless you have a personal teacher, I think, learning a native programming language is not a good idea, because you will be limiting yourself, you will learn wrong patterns. You will not be standing on the shoulders of (many)others before you and the quality of your understanding will be not as good. I also think a lot of skill comes from cross language disciplines, and limiting yourself to one native langue is not a good idea. Better to invest time and learn english subset used in programming. Then you can read interesting code of others, which was reviewed by more eyes than your native programming language.
- trevordixon 7y ago> Programming in a foreign language is a pretty significant barrier. There are only a handful of English words you have to memorize. Music students have to memorize a handful of Italian words to follow written music. It hasn't been a problem.
- UncleMeat 7y agoStandard libraries are large and named in English. It's a lot more than a few English words.
- rtkwe 7y agoYou don't really have to learn the language to program in it though you can just know "import" means include this library, that's a harder task than just being able to read for sure. I think the biggest issue is when you have to use a different script than your native language (and keyboard). To code in Arabic, Chinese, or Russian I'd have to completely relearn how to type.
- blauditore 7y ago> There's a reason why e.g. air traffic control speaks english no matter the ethnicity (as per the ICAO standard). ...which is not respected at many smaller airports/airfields. If you plan to land your machine at a local French airport, you better be prepared to speak French !
- Tepix 7y agoOthers have already commented that air traffic controllers use the same languages for reasons not applicable to programming. > I'm no native english speaker Does your native language use the latin alphabet? Are you familiar with the arabic alphabet? If not, why do you think you are qualified to judge that "this is the least helpful, and the least important"?
- lallysingh 7y agoThe value of this language is as a tool to expose those biases. Some of them may be stupid and holding us all back. As for the ATC analogy, software normally works by interfacing with systems written in other languages. Python to C-based glibc to the asm trampolines in the kernel.
- currymj 7y agoI am a native English speaker in the US and to me it seems palpably unfair. People much smarter than me have to spend a lot of time struggling with a foreign language, and are still unfairly perceived as less intelligent than native speakers. I could imagine it might be less unfair in a situation, like in much of Europe, where nobody is a native English speaker but many speak it (sort of like Latin at one time). And there are of course huge benefits from a standard language. But it still bugs me.
- mar77i 7y agoWell the question is why you'd want to allow it to become your problem, too, though. Having to debug libraries written in Elder Futhark or, case in point, Arabic, seems much more impossible than it may already seem sometimes, and that's why I'm not going to write a programming language in Swiss German, and keep my comments in English too, for that matter.
- microcolonel 7y agoI think it comes from a good place in the heart, but people really shouldn't look for ways to drag themselves into other people's problems out of "fairness". Many societies have a nominal interest in teaching English to their people, but fail in practice. Fixing English education (or really language teaching in general) is a far more useful thing than torturing yourself with a language not suited to typewriter keyboards, such as APL or Arabic.
- ThinkingGuy 7y ago"There was no Committee," by Geoffrey Pullam really captures my feelings as a mostly monolingual native English speaker: https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/linguafranca/2014/04/30/there-was-no-committee/ https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/linguafranca/2014/04/30/ther...
- msla 7y ago> Code is written entirely in Arabic, highlighting cultural biases of computer science and challenging the assumptions we make about programming. And using the Imperial system of units is highlighting the cultural imperialism of the metric system, the so-called SI ("International" System) and its Modernist desire to fit man to the unit, as opposed to fitting the unit to man. As long as humans walk on feet, and not meters, or metres, we shall persist! Ich kann nicht anders! (... primarily because I lost my metric socket wrenches)
- Geimfari 7y agoAir traffic control at domestic airports in many regions do communicate with pilots in the local language (even if they're are all able to switch to English at a moment's notice). It's all just jargon, for those of us working in the field it's really not difficult to both know the international Latin medical terms and the local terms to use with patients or colleagues.
- gkfasdfasdf 7y agoThis language has the potential to attract native Arabic speakers to programming who may not otherwise take any interest. And who knows what insights or new paradigms they could bring. Lowering the barrier to entry to programming is a good thing.
- egdod 7y agoMany of them might well have wound up programming anyway. And so this language has the potential to shunt them off into a likely dead-end language. Although, yes, it might be a “gateway drug” kind of thing where they wind up learning more mainstream languages as well. I’m just saying it’s not an obvious and unalloyed win.
- gkfasdfasdf 7y agoIs scratch a dead-end language? It's not used for anything production grade, and it can't be modified in vi because it requires a gui of all things! Yet millions of children (and adults) learn about programming through scratch and create amazing things. It is not a dead-end language.
- cicero 7y agoSince air traffic can be global, it makes sense to have global air traffic control conventions. However, not every technology has to be global. If a region wants to develop a technology that is optimized for their region, they trade global access for local optimization. There are cases where this may make sense.
- knolax 7y ago> or translating latin/greek terms doctors all over the world are trained and understand A cursory glance at a glossary of Japanese medical terms suggests otherwise[0]. The thing about biases is that usually you don't notice them. Language is completely othogonal to most tasks. If you live in Japan you would probably prefer your GP focus on studying medicine in school instead of Greek/Latin on the off hand chance a foreigner asks them "why his primaris longus hurts". The same with programming, I'm pretty sure most programmers are interested in computers first and foremost, not learning about English subject verb agreement so they can read documentation. [0] https://www.mlcjapanese.co.jp/n5_04_10.html https://www.mlcjapanese.co.jp/n5_04_10.html
- khaled 7y ago> It's like doing math in local notation Math is taught in Arabic, using Arabic notation and written from right to left in many Arabic countries. That is basically the only form of math I’m personally familiar with.