20 ms·
Apple could, for example, switch out the version of an app on my phone with a backdoored version of the same app. The backdoored version could upload a copy of
by josephg 7y ago
Apple could, for example, switch out the version of an app on my phone with a backdoored version of the same app. The backdoored version could upload a copy of every message I send to law enforcement. It wouldn’t even be difficult - just a keylogger would do the trick, or the OS could periodically take screenshots of the app while it is open and send them somewhere nefarious. Those latter techniques would also work with web apps. If this sort of thing was done selectively, I doubt anyone would notice.
If the government passes laws requiring backdoors in WhatsApp, terrorists can use another app. If the government passes laws requiring Apple and google to add backdoors to their phones, it will be almost impossible to avoid government surveillance. (And if the approach of the Australian government is anything to go by, we won’t even be able to tell this has happened. Instead they’ll pass a law demanding backdoors on request, then legally forbid Apple et al from making any of the details public.)
This is one of the reasons I buy phones from Apple. Unlike Google, Samsung, Huawei, etc they have at least made their opposition to government meddling very clear. And as this article points out in detail, they have put their money where their mouth is. If some of the sales price of my iPhone pays for Apple lawyers to fight for my digital rights, that is a tax I pay willingly.
- raxxorrax 7y agoIronically, using a corporate store for app deployment could become less safe than downloading something through your browser at that point. I give Apple the benefit of the doubt and appreciate their stance, but with a legislative basis they too would have to comply. I also think that professional criminals wouldn't use their phones in the first place if it is tied to their ID in any way. Sure, you might catch some of the riff-raff, but I think strong encryption is more beneficial for any form of security in the broader picture.
- chacham15 7y agoI dont quite buy the "switch the app" argument as code signing easily fixes that. Intercepting at a higher level such as a keylogger or screenshotter would work, but then you'd apply the same argument: the terrorists would just go one level higher. In fact they could go all the way to open source processors running their own code doing all the same things. Yes, it would delay them a few years to get there, but once there there would be little the US could do to stop it. At the network level, we simply dont sign hardware, so without some major refactoring to the core system, theres little to do there. Still though, at every level of this back and forth, consumers have to give up more and more privacy to allow the government to step in and get the same level of information they had before about terrorists until the terrorists will eventually win (or we completely lose privacy and trillions of dollars in infrastructure). So why play the game?
- unionpivo 7y ago> In fact they could go all the way to open source processors running their own code doing all the same things. Yes, it would delay them a few years to get there, but once there there would be little the US could do to stop it. well as long as you can't easily build private fab out there capable of building such processors, good luck with that. There are not that many fabs out there. Fpga's aren't any better, since most of them you can't even make work without large quantities of proprietary blobs.