5 ms·
ISPs are dying to find some sort of "value add" to get more revenue, but it's just not there. ISPs need to realize that they are strictly a utility now. All t
by jrockway 7y ago
ISPs are dying to find some sort of "value add" to get more revenue, but it's just not there. ISPs need to realize that they are strictly a utility now. All the value that they could possibly add can be obtained from any other company now. They used to provide TV service, but nobody wants linear TV and can just send their money directly to the company that produces the TV content and have it delivered over IP. They used to provide phone service, but nobody wants phone service; they have a cell phone and can get a fake landline from any number of companies for almost no money. They used to provide a DNS resolver, but they used the DNS resolver to inject fake addresses, so the power has been moved away from them. They used to provide Usenet, but their "content partners" didn't like that, so now you get Usenet from a third-party provider.
IP is just too versatile. All customers want from their ISP is the dumbest possible pipe, because they can get all other services over that pipe and pick the best deals. If you aren't interested in infrastructure, then you shouldn't be an ISP.
(That said, I don't see why companies like Comcast aren't pursuing things like becoming Cloudflare or AWS. "Click here to host your docker container 1ms away from 87% of the US population," seems like a service that could make a lot of money.)
- snagglegaggle 7y agoUnless something drastic happens ISPs are going to win. They're increasingly charging per bit for wire data (where there is no inherent scarcity), lobbying to prevent competitors, and have taken public funds and failed to reinvest in their infrastructure.
- andrei_says_ 7y agoLobbying and changing laws to apply reality distortion fields on all their customers and the competition is cheaper than investing into R&D or infrastructure and provide a better service or innovate and compete. If it’s true for ISPs, it’s true for other big players and is a symptom of a failing system.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoWell, there definitely is bandwidth scarcity. Also, unmetered bandwidth is just one major reason botnets are so trivial. Nobody knows or even has incentive to know that their smart toaster is involved in DDoS attacks so now we're all centralizing behind Cloudflare to mitigate this reality. Now, I'd like to see a fair price per bit, but I'm not convinced the world is better without it.
- crooked-v 7y agoISPs are increasingly charging for total throughput on top of point-in-time bandwidth, though. For example, to get actually-unlimited throughput with Comcast you have to pay an additional $50/month: https://www.xfinity.com/support/articles/exp-unlimited-limit https://www.xfinity.com/support/articles/exp-unlimited-limit
- jrockway 7y agoYeah, there are always going to be pricing shenanigans because people are not willing to pay the actual costs. The actual costs of an ISP are the $1MM one time cost to dig up the streets in your neighborhood, and an ongoing cost of electricity for their datacenter, Juniper licenses, peering, customer support, etc. The problems the ISPs have is that no customer is going to pay that one time cost, so they have to figure out some way to make you pay it without that $1MM bill the first month. I have worked for two ISPs and the internal debate is always around figuring out how to do this. At the last place I worked, our install costs were relatively low; the city already built tunnels under the streets for fiber, so it is financially viable for someone to just pay the ISP to run the fiber, and then pay the incremental costs. It is certainly not free (everyone wants their cut, including the building that you're already paying rent to), but is the kind of money that a medium-sized business or a condo co-op could find if they were so inclined. Individuals have no chance of finding the money, though, so something has to give. (Where I'm going with this, is that paying per bit does seem reasonable to me. It's what AWS does; if you want to lower your bill, send fewer bits. But it's still a bit of a hack, not reflective of the actual costs. The first bit you send over your line costs a million dollars, but the rest are practically free. You're just paying to keep some routers powered on, and for them to be upgraded when other customers want to send more bits.) Being able to sell your browsing history is one way to cover the infrastructure costs, but it's unfortunately not a workable idea because as we've seen, companies like Google and Cloudflare can just obscure that data from the ISP. I hate to be all pro-government, but can you imagine how inefficient it would be if UPS, Fedex, and the USPS all had to build nationwide road networks in order to be able to deliver packages to your house? Instead, the government built the roads, and it made the economy stronger. Being able to drive to work or have someone send you a package from across the country is quite valuable. I don't see any reason why the last-mile Internet shouldn't be built that way; the city can get traffic to a peering point, and from there, you can pick what ISP you want to connect you to the actual Internet. But unfortunately, we half-assed that, instead paying private companies to built the last mile, and now they want to milk their nearly-free infrastructure. The idea of Internet to the home is a mature one, and the reality of a mature business is that it becomes a commodity, and that is going to drive profits down. Comcast, Spectrum, etc. should all be finding new ways to make money, and the easy one, "spy on our customers", is not viable. Sorry, investors. Too bad for you.
- woah 7y agoWhat do you mean there is no inherent scarcity? There is only a certain amount of capacity in any infrastructure. When you pay for a bit on a network with metered bandwidth, you are paying for the fact that you used up that infrastructure for a short amount of time. It’s exactly the same concept as paying more to deliver a larger package. On a network with scarce capacity, flat rate billing (vs metering or caps) means that light users are subsidizing heavy users. A real world illustration of this fact is that ISPs actually prefer flat rate because it is easier to market. On networks with lots of capacity they sell “unlimited”, while on tighter networks (like the cellular networks), they almost always use metered billing. I’m not sure why some people (mostly only on Reddit or HN) are confused about this, but one theory I have is that they don’t understand the oversale of bandwidth. If you want to get a dedicated 1gbps per second of internet bandwidth, that will cost over $2000/month in most areas. So what all ISPs do is to sell that same gigabit to many subscribers. You can get hundreds of subscribers on 1gbps. But they advertise “up to 1gbps speeds” instead of “1gbps with a 100x oversale ratio” because that would confuse people. So maybe people think that means they are actually supposed to be getting a dedicated 1gbps. If that was the case, then it wouldn’t make sense to bill for data. But most people don’t want to pay $2000/month for their internet. The real issue that you are complaining about is that ISPs in many areas are monopolies and feel no need to upgrade infrastructure.
- snagglegaggle 7y agoTo start, realize stating that a dedicated 1gbps link is $2000 may be true but it does not justify the price, which is what I'm speaking to. What observations I had were: 1) the price of dedicated links went up in time disproportionate to their capacity; 2) network operators began moving to a per-bit charging model, forcing users to bid against each other, and; 3) at least here, non-DC dedicated links can be had much more cheaply than a link in a DC. There is scarcity but for practical purposes the scarcity is so far off that I'm not sure it makes sense to consider it. The true scarcity is related to the availability of land and the size of the data links, neither of which are yet very limiting. Regulation related to right of way (or more commonly) city involvement in high level planning could be blamed for creating market failures if these costs really are that high. Otherwise, in regards to #1, we would expect a downward trend of dedicated network link price while capacity goes up, following storage density and transistor density (or more appropriately computational throughput). But we don't see this, even though throughput does increase, and integration costs decrease. For #2, going to a bidding model could imply scarcity, but as there are unjustified monopolies often there is no increase in capacity so it seems prudent to assume this is done solely to increase price. And with #3, well, certain usages are priced higher than others, also implying some kind of bidding. This might reflect space scarcity but seeing as the price tends to not go down even if the customer provides their own network equipment and pays for its space it just seems like a reluctance of the DC operator to perform upgrades. The fairest model I can imagine has users paying the amortized cost of the network equipment and its installation and maintenance.
- tzs 7y agoISPs providing DNS and caching was a key part of the Pai FCC's reclassification of ISPs as an "information service" instead of a "communication service", as part of their repeal of net neutrality. The FCC has a lot of leeway in deciding whether something is an "information service" or a "communication service", but they do have to be able to justify the decision. Pai went with the ISP's providing DNS and caching. I wonder, if most people end up using DNS from third parties, and caching from third party CDNs, it will make it easier for a future FCC to reclassify ISPs as communication services, and put back net neutrality? PS: Pai's approach partially backfired. He also tried to use the FCCs power to preempt state regulation to prohibit states from imposing net neutrality. But reclassification of ISPs as information services meant that the FCC no longer had the power to regulate net neutrality (indeed, that was the point of Pai reclassifing them), and the FCC's power to preempt state regulation only applies to things that the FCC could regulate.
- 3xblah 7y ago"ISPs providing DNS and caching was a key part of the Pai FCC's reclassification of ISPs as an "information service"..." I thought the same thing when I read about that decision. Many try to label DNS as "intrastructure", with the implication that some third party and not the user should have control over it. As an ordinary user, I do not use third party DNS. I will never believe that from a technical standpoint all ordinary users must use third party DNS.
- akira2501 7y agoIs my telephone an "information service" because it has 411?
- thayne 7y agoOr is a phone line an "information service" if the company that provides it delivers a phone book to you periodically?
- Skunkleton 7y agoEven worse: unless you are tunneling your DNS traffic past your ISP somehow, even people who think they are using third party DNS likely aren't.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> ISPs are dying to find some sort of "value add" to get more revenue, but it's just not there. Yes it is. It's Google Fi. Comcast could do Google Fi better than Google does, because they could make every Comcast modem an access point for it. Then for a few bucks on top of your cable internet subscription you give people unlimited mobile data on unlimited devices whenever they're connected to a Comcast access point, which is 97% of the time because they're everywhere, and metered data using some deal with Sprint/T-Mobile/whomever the other 3% of the time. How much money is on the table when you allow families to cancel their wireless plans on four, five, six different mobile devices yet still have service everywhere?
- nickjj 7y agoMy ISP has done something similar for years. They give you a router which doubles as a "wifi hotspot", where anyone with a valid ISP login can use that network at no cost beyond their regular internet bill. It just becomes a part of what you get with their service. This doesn't quite work out as well as Google Fi because they don't have the other half of the equation which is to jump to a mobile provider when there's no valid wifi connection. My area has 2 choices for broadband and even with a majority of customers in this area there's still large gaps to the point where if I walk around the neighborhood there's tons upon tons of dead zones.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> This doesn't quite work out as well as Google Fi because they don't have the other half of the equation which is to jump to a mobile provider when there's no valid wifi connection. That's the key though. Even if you have 97% coverage without it, if that other 3% could be when your car breaks down on the side of the road, people aren't going to be willing to switch off their existing wireless service which does work there. But add existing wireless carriers as metered data which costs nothing unless you use it, and you satisfy that blocking factor and get the customer.
- chii 7y ago> much money is on the table when you allow families to cancel their wireless plans and how much money do they stand to lose on those plans that got canceled? Making a service more efficient means they get less money, and without the threat of competition, a business won't do this.
- linuxdude314 7y agoSome are. Verizon bought EdgeCast CDN which has a Cloudflare style WAF. They now operate under the Verizon Digital Media Services monicker, but it’s been a bit of a challenge for them to integrate.
- kitteh 7y agoAnd that's backfired for Verizon a little bit. Think about it this way. Verizon is now a CDN: they have to get as much peering as they want. Verizon (as701) the big eyeball network has no plans to peer openly. It complicates peering negotiations because edgecast (separate asn) can't give up the access that everyone wants to Verizon. Similar happened when tata (old teleglobe) bought bitgravity cdn and constrained their peering relationships.
- jlmorton 7y ago> ISPs need to realize that they are strictly a utility now. They used to provide TV service, but nobody wants linear TV and can just send their money directly to the company that produces the TV content and have it delivered over IP. Right, I think Comcast realized that. That's why they _are_ the company the creates the TV content. They own Universal Studios, NBC, MSNBC, CNBC, USA Network, Syfy, Dreamworks, etc.
- Ericson2314 7y agoSo it's even stupider that they are scrambling in the ISP business. Relax, bean counters, the rest of your mega-holy-shit conglomerate is doing just fine.
- phyzome 7y agoISPs do in fact sometimes colocate with CDNs to provide caches very close to residences.
- big_chungus 7y agoYeah, I believe netflix puts boxes in a huge number of IXPs for just this reason. That said, it's not currently practical without netflix's current scale. The "as-a-service" part provided by an ISP is an actual value-add and could indeed make money.
- kitteh 7y agoMost broadband access providers don't know how to build, operate or scale out compute infrastructure and the systems around it. They've tried, they've failed, they've blown a lot of money in the process. It's not their core competency and most have given up. They've been taken in by vendors (or acquisitions) in the last 10 years selling them solutions "just like the cloud companies" but can't manage to make it work in practice and entice the select set of customers who could take advantage of being in close proximity to users and less network congestion. The conversations I've heard go on with these companies display how they're a cargo cult and they fetishize buying the same hardware that cloud providers use.
- m463 7y ago> ISPs are dying to find some sort of "value add" to get more revenue, but it's just not there. ISPs are some of the most profitable businesses on the planet. If you look at any of the fundamentals for financials of AT&T, Verizon, Comcast, etc their gross profit margins are 60%