9 ms·
We live in a time where the president of the United States himself questions any law that inconveniences him personally, same goes for any oversight, and he ret
by duxup 7y ago
We live in a time where the president of the United States himself questions any law that inconveniences him personally, same goes for any oversight, and he retains a great deal of support from the population and his own party.
I wonder how / if it is possible to convince the public that laws and oversight are necessary for good government.
- polymatter 7y ago"It is from their foes, not their friends, that cities learn the lesson of building high walls" -Aristophanes The public learns the lesson that X is necessary when they see the consequence of not-X. Hopefully there is a gap between total lawlessness and the public realising that some laws are good and not just "red tape".
- jammygit 7y agoI had hoped that things under trump would have been much worse, so as to shock the public into re-evaluating their civic values.
- ksdale 7y agoI've always been rather suspicious of this way of reasoning. It basically goes, "Things aren't as bad as they need to be for people to change their ways, so hopefully they get worse so people change their ways." And it is implicit in this line of reasoning that there is some terrible and inevitable catastrophe waiting to befall the people who don't change their ways. (Because why would a catastrophe be worth it, unless it prevented another, worse, catastrophe?) An alternate response to "Things aren't bad enough for people to change their ways," is to revise our predictions of the likelihood of catastrophe, and eventually decide that perhaps things aren't quite as doomed as we think. For things like climate change, where we have scientific evidence of the necessity of change, it seems like it needs to get worse before the change will happen, though I still don't hope for things to get worse. But for something as subjective as civic values, it seems especially wrong to me to hope for disaster just for the sake of shaking things up. After all, there's no guarantee that a disaster under Trump would move civic values in the right direction anyway.
- runedog 7y agoThe issue is that those in power can seize power from the people without the people knowing as long as there isn't some huge mistake. Once there's a mistake/catastrophe/whatever, those in power come under scrutiny of the public, and changes get made. So my fear would be that everyone continues on in complacency, and one day we wake up and realize we live in an authoritarian state, where mass catastrophies can occur and no one can do anything about it. I don't want people to get hurt or die, but I also don't want power to be quietly seized by the few.
- keiferski 7y ago”When the president does it, that means that it is not illegal.” - Richard Nixon The attitude is not a new phenomenon at all.
- duxup 7y agoCertainly not new, but it is notably pronounced now.
- dwaltrip 7y agoI don't think we should look to the only president to resign from office for examples of what to expect.
- mywittyname 7y ago“You people with this phony emoluments clause” - DJT
- 0x445442 7y agoWe also live in a time when the CIA and FBI has been trying to remove a duly elected POTUS for the past three years. Why? because they think they know better than the unwashed masses.
- ambicapter 7y ago[Citation needed]
- katmannthree 7y agoHypothetically, suppose you work for an intelligence agency. Suppose that your specific role is to monitor foreign influence in the US. What do you do when in your opinion (possibly supported by classified evidence) that duly elected president is compromised by foreign intelligence? What do you do when the president makes decisions that hurt the US and help countries opposed to us? Suppose there's some irrefutable classified evidence that he's compromised and under foreign control. Do you really sit by and do nothing?
- alfromspace 7y agoSuppose there isn't really any such evidence, your opinion is all there is, your intelligence agency has an awful reputation and is infamous for steering the country into conflicts and crises through falsified evidence and statements, and you work to remove the president.
- jonhohle 7y agoNot throwing support either way, but what is wrong with questioning inconvenient laws? Should laws never be repealed?
- duxup 7y agoI don't want to get in to a line item list but he tweeted that it was inconvenient that the justice department indited two Republicans near election season (ignoring that they actually committed crimes). His recent statements about the emoluments clause. The list goes on. That's not someone looking into strange random laws as part of an effort to improve government, that is questioning things purely to further his personal goals / enrich himself personally.
- crispyambulance 7y agoLaws should be questioned and repealed as needed. The problem here is not that the people in power want to "question" the laws, they're literally ignoring them and breaking them, in secret, without the consent of the people. It's only when this stuff is uncovered that these perpetrators shift to "questioning"-- as though it's a open debate, it's not.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThen you should make an effort to change the law and not just complain and try to get away with breaking the law. Until the law has been changed the president should stay firmly within it.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI do think ignoring the rules is part of his success. If you add the ridiculous stories about Russia, which was one of the worse conspiracy theories, but was mainly driven by the intelligence community, the current political situation isn't a surprise at all. The spying was equally supported by the Democrats as well as Republicans. They further try to restrict freedom on the net by their newest attempt with the CASE law. It is one of the most consistent pattern of established parties. Trump didn't win because it would be helpful for his base. It is to evict people that failed to bring forth sensible policies. It is reactionary, but perfectly understandable. If everyone ignores the rules, we will do that too. I am no American, but that is what it looks like.
- duxup 7y agoI have trouble parsing what you're saying. Honestly, a lot of it seems like empty taglines that don't say anything. >It is to evict people that failed to bring forth sensible policies. What policies? Doesn't every new politician claim exactly that?
- raxxorrax 7y agoEvidently. What is your explanation for the success of Trump? Because he has a pretty clean alibi for not implementing mass surveillance.
- duxup 7y ago>What is your explanation for the success of Trump? I'm not sure why I would have to explain that to understand what you're saying. >Because he has a pretty clean alibi for not implementing mass surveillance. I have no idea what that means in relation to the first sentence. Are you saying he wasn't a part of government during the establishment of some surveillance and that means something now? and/or Do you feel voters cared about that?
- raxxorrax 7y agoYou referenced the current president as an example of someone ignoring the law, while previous administrations were responsible for implementing and extending mass surveillance consistently while ignoring the law. I said that could be part of Trumps success, because his voters had similar ideas. Which laws did Trump break by the way?