7 ms·
The IRS Targets Income Tricks
- joe_bleau 16y agoSee, this points out something I've never understood. If you own an s-corp, you have to be careful about paying yourself too little and taking out too much profit, presumably due to the reduction in FICA withholdings. So how does someone like Steve Jobs get away with making a $1 annual salary without being charged with tax evasion? It seems like he's found a way to avoid paying into the social security and workmen's comp system. What am I missing? Is it only legal to dodge withholdings in a c-corp?
- ayb 16y agoA S-corp owner must take what the IRS deems to be a "reasonable salary" based on the overall profit of the company, and must pay self employment taxes (FICA, Medicare, etc.) on that amount. The IRS does not give out much guidance on the definition of "reasonable salary" but has provided guidance on what is /not/ reasonable. In this case the IRS evaluated the company's return and decided that his salary was less that reasonable and as such they went after him and got him to pay more tax. This rule does not apply to C Corporations.
- tptacek 16y agoTo be clear: the rule doesn't apply to C Corporations because they are taxed differently; it's not an oversight. It's the pass-through taxation structure of S Corporations that make this an issue.
- wglb 16y agoIf you are a C corporation, you get no pass-through. My consulting business is set up as a C corp, and my accountant makes sure that it earns no profit each year. This is mostly done by paying any excess as salary bonus. Corporate tax rate is too high to leave money there. The C corp cost me a little more in terms of the deductions, but was a big win because when I set it up many years ago I put in the bylaws a medical provision such that any full-time employee would have health coverage (up to a limit) including health insurance premiums. This, due to the very high cost of health insurance, was a big win, as these are a business expense. Were I to do it again, I would probably do LLC with the new way that health care is taken care of. Thus, there is no issue like there is with the S-corp, because any money taken out of the corporation is done through payroll.
- usaar333 16y agoYou really can't "cheat" with a C-corp. Your company's income is going to first be subject to corporate income taxes (30 to 35%). Then if you pay dividends, that is also taxed. In other words, trying to skirt payroll taxes with a C-corp is going to end up with you paying more taxes than doing no hack. Hence, why the IRS rule only applies to S-corps which pass on their income and are not subject to corporate taxes. Steve jobs effectively pays a 45% federal tax rate on income (35% corp on apple's income and then 15% long term cap gains on any shares he sells) -- so the IRS really doesn't care.
- diziet 16y agoWell, apple ends up paying about 24% in corporate taxes, even though the corp tax rate is 35.
- usaar333 16y agoThat's probably effective after all deductions, etc. 35% should be their marginal rate. So if the last $500k of income was converted into Steve's Salary their taxes should be dropping by 0.35*500k
- zdw 16y agoSocial Security/Medicare/Workers comp get no money on passthrough from a c-corp either - c-corps pay taxes on profit, whereas s-corps pass any profit through to be taxed on individual returns of shareholders. What would bother the IRS is that capital gains distributions are taxed at a different, lower rate than standard income, so taking distributions instead of income could reduce the total amount owed to the IRS. (I'm not an accountant - if someone could verify or refute this, that would be nice)
- cd34 16y agoThere is some confusion there. His $1 salary is exactly that. A token amount paid by Apple for his work. It cannot be $0, otherwise he wouldn't be considered an employee and wouldn't be entitled to bonuses, stock options, insurance, etc. The fact that he is taking a $1 and tying all of his income to options, bonuses, perks means that he firmly believes his impact to the company will be rewarded - and it has, rightfully so. By taking a $1 salary, you are saying to the shareholders (world) that you believe so firmly in the company, that, you'll earn your income the same way a shareholder would - through the growth in stock price, etc. He does have to pay taxes on personal use of the corporate jets, and other benefits. I can't really imagine his situation being so dire that any social security income he could get would have any material impact on his life. We also don't know what the nature of his contributions were years ago. Paying too little and taking out too much profit is actually tied to a separate issue. If one runs an S-Corp and is in the typical feast and famine cycle, i.e lots of work, bill lots of money, work slows down, time for lots of sales because there is no work, here comes work again, then, the IRS could say that you took $x+y during the time when you were cash-flush, and $x when you were in your income slump, making $y a dividend and taxed as such. In many cases, dividend income is taxed at a higher rate than personal income until you hit a certain income (I believe $373k/year or so and in 2013, $171k or so). If you earn less than those amounts, dividends are taxed more heavily than normal income. A C-corp is its own financial entity. It pays its own taxes, has a separate tax structure. If you wanted to pay yourself a $1 salary, you could. Then, any money you take out of the company could be taxed as a dividend, you would have to assume 100% control of your retirement, probably wouldn't be eligible for Medicare after you retire, but, there isn't anything illegal there.
- tptacek 16y agoI upvoted you; you clearly know more about taxes than me. However, let me chime in again here and say that the feast-or-famine thing seems overblown. The IRS isn't dinging you for miscategorizing income; it's dinging you for underpaying taxes. You can make your income as irregular as you'd like, as long as you end up paying what you owe.
- cd34 16y ago
- patio11 16y agoSmall businesses are somewhat notorious for aggressively interpreting the tax code in one's favor, largely because they have a variety of options for doing so not available to the W-2 employee. The game theory sort of incentivizes it, too: heads you save 100% of the taxes at issue, tails you have to pay the taxes at issue and (if you had any sort of a good faith case) only interest at a below-market rate on them... and the coin is known to flip tails only a few percentage points of the time, due to how infrequent audits are. This is complicated by the fact that, if the tax code were a spec, it would have some requirements which were contradictory and very many interactions whose behavior was totally undefined. For example, BCC has a fairly similar issue: if the profits are earned income received for the value of my services as an engineer/etc, then they're subject to a generous exclusion since I was physically in Japan when I earned them (foreign earned income exemption, form 2555). If they're unearned income -- that is, if the business is generating profits above the fair market value of the time I am investing -- then they are not subject to that exclusion and I owe the IRS a few thousand extra. On a separate axis, they may not be attributable to the business at all, but as a result of sale of real property, depending on whether the computer software counts as personal property or not, which apparently turns on the degree of support/customization I offer and the mood of the examining IRS clerk. If they aren't attributable to the business and are a sale of real property, then they are excludable, as long as the transaction is not sourced to the United States. Sales of real property are sourced where the transaction physically takes place... but the IRS literally has no opinion on where that is for sales of downloadable software. (I asked. They said "Write up your reasoning with your tax form. If we don't bill you, you're good.") If they are not real property, they may be a sale of computer licenses, which are arguably a source of royalties, which could be subject to a US/Japan tax treaty provision which overrides some of these rules but not others. The above is not tax advice. Don't even ask about the Japanese side -- I have a few more weeks to figure that mind-meltingness yet.
- rubyrescue 16y agoi just realized the both of us need to start an american-expat-tech-entrepreneur-tax forum. a few other people are in the same boat and email me based on my profile from time to time. I find i know much more about IRS tax code regarding form 2555 than most US accountants because they just don't deal with it much, OR, the ones that have charge way more than I can afford to help me with my questions - but i haven't found a place to discuss these type of issues online. perhaps a google group?
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI hope I don't get slammed for this, but the tax code is a large pile of stinking dung, and good luck trying to do the right thing. S-Corps work under the general premise that it's just like you, if you were a corporation. So if you don't spend all the income in your business in the year, you owe income tax on what remains. If you have plenty of profits, you write yourself a regular W-2 paycheck. At the end of the year, whatever you don't spend as a legitimate business expense -- even if it's exclusively for business purposes -- is taxed at the same rate as if you had spent the money on whiskey and hookers. Case in point: there is a huge difference between a high-income wage earner who uses S-Corp status for maximum flexibility and the local beautician or mechanic who does the same thing. Lots of independents who are S-Corps have highly volatile income: if you get a client that writes you a check for 50K in January that might be the last income those guys see for that year. So those guys have to make a difficult business decision as to what to do with the money, and the most logical thing to do is to pay business expenses as needed and withdraw the rest as cash disbursements only as a last result. Writing yourself a W-2 paycheck when you're not sure of future income is basically taking away spending money from the business for no logical reason. As I understand it, the system is designed this way on purpose: tough times allow S-Corps to ride on profits and re-tool for the good times. Good times S-Corps work just like "regular" businesses. So for small folks with highly-volatile income, being able to move funds around is the only thing sometimes that keeps them afloat. Unfortunately, there are a lot of guys making 400K a year or more who pay themselves a salary of $20K and take the rest as cash disbursements (thereby avoiding paying themselves as W-2 employees mostly altogether) The reason the tax code is such a mess is that folks get mad at one bunch or another that they think are not acting fairly, so they punish them -- usually punishing many more than the original target. Or politicians want extra votes, so they make an exception for certain people -- usually providing exceptions to hidden interests and creating perverse incentives. 60 years of this and you have a complete disaster. So yes, by all means make folks pay their share, just be aware that the guy you read about in the paper isn't necessarily the average guy. It's not an "income trick" if it helps the economy grow.
- matwood 16y agoWell in this case it really is an income trick. I have friends who do S-corps for this reason and the main thing they stress over is paying themselves a fair market salary. The guy in the article was paying himself barely 1/2 what a new grad would make so it's clear that he was well below fair market. If he had just paid himself fair market he would still have come out ahead and not had to deal with the IRS.
- anonymous246 16y agoThis is one of those few instances where I actually support the IRS and also support the law that's being contemplated. S corps (and AFAIK LLCs) are supposed to have "pass through" taxation. I think it's fair that all income (whether salary or profit distributions) from S Corp is treated as regular W-2 income. If you don't care about the simplicity that "pass through" offers, register a C-corp.
- jabits 16y agoSo then as a small Sub-S owner (wife and me), I would have to pay FICA and Medicare on the money spent on health care insurance, disability insurance, etc., which you as a W-2 employee do not pay payroll taxes on. In the end, the payroll tax savings are not that great for a small Sub-S. And as you get older, toward retirement, if you pay yourself too low, you take a big hit on SSA benefit payments (which are based on your latest 40 qtrs). The biggest bang for the PIA effort is if to can write off a vehicle purchase through a Section 179 deduction, and various other hardware purchases.
- tptacek 16y agoThe tax code already goes way, way out of its way to make it easy to pay for health insurance; get a high-deductable plan and build an HSA. It's what you should be doing anyways, even if you don't care about taxes. The fact of the matter is, as a member of the workforce, you owe FICA on your compensation. This isn't a subject of dispute. The IRS says you do, the courts say you do, your accountants will say you do. This issue comes up on HN roughly once a year, and the story has never changed.
- jabits 16y ago"...you owe FICA on your compensation". Exactly. I want to be taxed (and get the same breaks) as my corporate client employees. Business writes off all possibly related equipment, as do I. I try to write off everything a C-corp would for employees, but it is much more difficult for us (and very time-consuming even trying to be IRS-compliant). Again, payroll tax savings (on the income/distribution differential) does not usually add up to that much money.
- ams6110 16y agoThere is so much "waste motion" expended in trying to game the tax code in so many situations... what could creative people achieve in that time if they didn't spend it that way. We need a vastly simplified income tax code... I'm talking throw it all out and start from scratch. Or replace it with a national sales tax, rebating some amount to make it less regressive.
- tptacek 16y agoThis implies that if you simplified the tax code, people would stop gaming it. The opposite is probably true; the simpler you made the tax code, the more accessible tax games would be to average taxpayers.
- piguy314 16y agoHow would you game a 22 percent national sales tax? (Other than buying things on the black market).
- JeffL 16y agoI don't agree. In order to game, there has to be different rules to take advantage of. The fewer and simpler the rules, the less you can manipulate it. Take sales taxes, for example. You can't really game them. You can evade them, but not really game them, although I suppose mail ordering things from another state could qualify, but that's an issue of jurisdiction.
- tbrownaw 16y ago> I suppose mail ordering things from another state could qualify You're supposed to pay "use tax" on those, which for some reason is always equal to the sales tax you think you avoided. So it's still evasion rather than gaming.
- hugh3 16y agoWhich is why you simplify it in such a way as to make tax games impossible. Here's my favoured solution: the US Government spent $3.6 trillion this year. There are 280 million people living there. Therefore, Federal tax should be a flat $12,857 per person. For the average income earner, this is about the same as they're already paying. For those earning more, they find they're incentivised to work harder, since every dollar they earn beyond that point is entirely their own. And for those earning less... well, it's the kick in the butt that they need to start working harder too. Not too easy to game that system, is it?
- johnwatson11218 16y agoCan anyone comment on how personal income tax is handled in other countries? I don't mind paying tax but I hate the fact that I can take my paper work to several different tax preparation services and get different tax bills. In some cases I have heard of people owning the IRS thousands, going somewhere else and claiming a refund. Is the US the only country in the world where 2 to 3 percent of our GDP goes into tax preparation?
- notauser 16y agoIn the UK personal taxes are generally automatically handled by the employer. You just get the post-tax income transferred into your bank every month, and a payslip showing the deductions that were made. (Outsourced PAYE administration costs about £20 per month for a very small company.) It gets more complicated when you can't do taxes through PAYE for any reason - unearned income, dividends, directorships etc. My own taxes as a director of two firms subject partially to mandatory PAYE on some of my income are a US-level nightmare and once you are out of the 'simple system' getting back into it takes years.
- johnwatson11218 16y agoI read a book by Jim Rogers, I think it was "Investment Biker" and he said that the US is the laughing stock of the developed world because of the way our incomes taxes work. He said that in Australia you have one form the size of a postcard that everybody mails in once a year.
- brc 16y agoWhile I agree with you, it's not entirely true that you have one form that you post in once a year. While your 'group certificate' is postcard size, I think it's somewhat like a W2 (been a while since I received either), you still have to submit a personal tax return. For most people, it's just a case of reporting the information on the Group Certificate(s) (depending on how many jobs you had) and perhaps claiming on some deductions like uniforms or (new) secondary school expenses for dependent children. That said, the government is talking about moving to a model whereby you don't have to submit a return unless you specifically want to claim some deductions. This is more like the UK model. As for the US being the laughing stock - I don't know if I would choose those words, but I do think the IRS needs its wings clipped by foreign governments. The whole W8BEN form thing is ridiculous (so tempted to put F.YOU IRS as my contact details) as is the mind-boggling fact that the only way to not file a return in the USA is to renounce your citizenship (and good luck visiting your relatives after that!). The myriad of local, state and federal taxes, forms, rulings and corporate structures - well, I do wonder how much GDP is lost in paper shuffling. It can't be insignificant. Personally, I would have the tax laws in most countries scrapped and replaced with flat-banded taxes with zero exemptions. The tax rates would be lower to make up for the lost deductions, but in general, if you earnt X, you'd be up for taxes of Y. Corporations would be kept for their original purpose of limited liability rather than taxation structures. As noted above, it's all the special interests that get in, and, well, anyone who was tried to selectively reward children will know the impossobility of 'fair' once selective rewards and exemptions are introduced.
- JeffL 16y agoSeems like if we just had a large sales tax, rather than income taxes, none of these things would be so complicated, and we'd save so much money on the cost of compliance.
- jrockway 16y agoA large sales tax is an unfair tax on the poor. Why should people making $20,000 a year pay the same tax on their groceries as someone making $1,000,000 a year?
- detst 16y agoDon't tax groceries as is already the case in many states.
- jrockway 16y agoSo all poor people are allowed to do is eat? That's worked really so far...
- detst 16y agoI'm not advocating replacement of income tax with higher sales tax; just answering your question. I wouldn't consider myself the most knowledgeable on this issue but I think there's an argument for a system that doesn't tax certain basis necessities and offers compensation to the poor to allow for more than just an existence.
- alanfalcon 16y agoThat's why nobody would set it up that way. The government (in this scenario) could afford to send cash money to all households to cover the tax cost of food and minimal living expenses such that the only taxes paid are for expenses beyond that minimum. A large sales tax would actually work out very well and be rid of the complexities of the IRS completely. I'd encourage anyone curious about how this would work (regardless of your initial reaction to the idea) to check out the reading material on http://www.fairtax.org/ http://www.fairtax.org/ .
- jrockway 16y agoWow, a mandatory minimum wage for professionals. I estimate that this will last for about ten more minutes.
- tptacek 16y agoIt's not a "mandatory minimum wage". Stop trolling. You can pay yourself $0.50/yr if you'd like; you just can't do it will paying yourself tens of thousands in distributions.
- camz 16y agoI'd like to clarify the issue. Personally, I think that the CPA in question in the article is an idiot for a number for reasons. (1) He's an accountant so he should've known that playing this game with the IRS as a CPA is begging the IRS to slam you. (2) Litigating a losing position like this so publicly is going to kill your reputation and put you on the IRS' top 10 favs list for life. This is a very clear issue actually and I'm not sure why there is so much confusion and I'd disagree with calling this tax plan a "trick." It is a legally sound tax plan with a justified theory. You are allowed to exempt a portion of your income from payroll taxes because they are "corporation distributions." Corporate distributions or dividends are not taxed as earned income because they are considered passive investment income. An S-Corp is a corporation that abides under a specific subset of rules within the IRC's Corporation Regulations, thus it is for all legal purposes a regular corporation with certain special rules. A reasonable salary is a fairly straight forward question. The IRS won't nitpick with you on silly numbers as long as you fit within the range. Obviously, for every position there is a high and low salary range, so as long as you fit within that range the IRS will leave you alone. The CPA is an idiot because he underpaid himself below market rates to the point where he couldn't justify his position under any reasonable defense. If you were developer, then you would be paid anywhere from 40k to 250k+ depending on your company, position and experience. Thus, you could potentially pay yourself 40k in reasonable salaries if you owned an S-Corp and take the rest as a dividend. As long as you are able to provide "comps or comparable salaries" to positions with equitable responsibilities and experience in your local region. The important thing to remember is to be reasonable. I'm a full-time tax accountant, so this is coming from years of experience in the field with direct contact with auditors from the federal and state levels. They won't come knocking unless you were being a greedy idiot because like the article states it's expensive for the government to audit someone, so when they do audit you it has to be a profitable venture (thus, they usually audit the sure-thing losers).
- DenisM 16y agoDoes any of this apply if you're not distributing the cash at all? Say, I am making money in my S-Corp, but I keep all of it in the bank (minus the expenses) and instead live off my savings. The plan is to save enough to expand the business, but for now the money is just sitting there, doing nothing.
- patrickgzill 16y agoAside (but relevant): some countries have as an explicit rule, that if you get a letter from the IRS on an issue, both you (as someone who has to comply with the law) and the IRS itself, is bound by the interpretation that is given. In the USA, even if you get a private ruling, the IRS can decide to renege on their advice at any time, and investigate you and charge you, making you pay penalties and fines for following their own advice. These ambiguities and "tricks" could be cleared up with simple guidelines backed up by such private rulings; however that would not be in the best interest of our "gotcha now!" system of taxation.