4 ms·
Half of the complaints quoted are about overzealous moderation, half are about low question quality. So it's unclear whether the article offers a coherent criti
by lmm 7y ago
Half of the complaints quoted are about overzealous moderation, half are about low question quality. So it's unclear whether the article offers a coherent critique; if you're somewhere in the middle of the complaints then maybe you're doing it right.
I do think a coherent issue emerges here: much like wikipedia, stack overflow rewards and privileges those who do "meta" actions over and above those who make positive object-level contributions, when it should be the other way around. Answering a question should be more rewarding than closing it as a duplicate. Helping a newcomer should be more rewarding than driving them away.
- Supermancho 7y agoAnother problem that MANY moderated forums suffer from is too much focus on identity. If everytime you posted to SO or HN or /. or wkipedia or whatever, you were assigned a random id (consistent id for all responses to a specific story) rather than linking to your acct/post history/achievements, with a policy against posting with PII... the cliques might dissolve and the trolls do not benefit.