9 ms·
I'm a SWE at Google, and as much as I love unions, I'm not sure it makes sense for the software industry. Further, the larger tech companies already have a con
by onlyrealcuzzo 7y ago
I'm a SWE at Google, and as much as I love unions, I'm not sure it makes sense for the software industry.
Further, the larger tech companies already have a concept of "levels" to ensure some sense of pay equality, we already get better benefits than you can get anywhere else in the states.
Realistically, what more will unions accomplish at a place like Google?
I'd love 6 weeks of paid vacation as much as anyone. I don't see us getting that. I'd love to make twice as much money. I don't see that happening. I'd love for promotions and hiring to be more fair / better, but I don't see how this accomplishes that (nor do I know anyway to improve it).
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI'd ask only that you not impede those who do believe in more workplace protections and benefits while they get that work done (ideally locked in with labor law, along with strong unions). I'm sure a two day weekend and 40 hour work week was once thought of as impossible as well.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoI'm not impeding. And I could get behind it. I just don't see what realistically it can accomplish.
- Kalium 7y agoLive and let live, right? Some people are leery about the possibility of their employer turning into a closed shop. I know I would not be happy if my employer suddenly turned into a union shop in a way that strongly affected me and gave me minimal choice in the matter. I only ask that you consider why people might choose to sit on the sidelines.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoBased on my experience, people sit on the sidelines because they're comfortable. People advocating for change should be polite first, and then not polite if politeness fails.
- Kalium 7y agoIs it at all possible, in any scenario, that people might have other reasons than purely personal comfort for sitting out a particular push for change?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIt is possible, and I am receptive to enumeration of those reasons. One must be able to entertain both sides of an argument. Selfishly, it would help me strengthen my own argument.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoSo you plan to force me into accepting your position if I don't take it when you ask nicely? I'd say you're already not polite.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYou already exist in a democratic system (assuming you're posting from the first world) where majority (mostly, some caveats) rules. This isn't any different. Everyone gets a vote, not everyone gets their way.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoNot quite. I live in a republic. The majority wins elections but still don't get to totally trample on the minority, because we have a limited government. Now, a union election isn't a government election, so that doesn't totally apply. But, for example, the majority has decided to pass legislation that makes my current state a right-to-work state, so a union can't require me to be a member, even if they win the election. Of course, unions could campaign to change that law. But that's a different set of elections they'd have to win...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- philipov 7y ago> I'm not sure it makes sense for the software industry. Why not? Such a vague claim needs substantiation.
- vowelless 7y agoIt will likely stifle my salary, and the salaries of a lot of high earning swes. Or not. Curious what others think.
- CydeWeys 7y agoSince when did unions stifle salaries? They generally get higher salaries for their employees, no? Isn't the typical complaint about union workers that they're "overpaid"?
- joshuamorton 7y agoThe common complaint is that since unions (at least in a lot of classic union jobs) force pay based on tenure, its difficult or impossible for bright people to succeed and change things. And I'd agree that such a style of union would be antithetical to a company like Google, but its also not the only kind of union.
- CydeWeys 7y agoYeah, I just don't see a tech union functioning like that. There's no reason a union would have to enforce strict tenure requirements on salary, especially if most workers in the union don't want that.
- bduerst 7y ago>It will likely stifle my salary, and the salaries of a lot of high earning swes. Yeah, this sounds like more anti-Union FUD than being based in actual data. I'd be happy to be proven wrong though if this can be substantiated through more than just cherry picked examples.
- icelancer 7y ago
- SomeOldThrow 7y ago> we already get better benefits than you can get anywhere else in the states. Wait until you hear how well the rich assholes that profit off your work live.
- Kalium 7y agoWait until you find out how far the pay of those rich assholes goes when you spread it around! There are good arguments to be made for unionization. That some people make more - sometimes substantially more - isn't always one of them. Certainly trying to stoke anger might not always be the best of all available ways to win over people trying to be thoughtful.
- memmcgee 7y agoExecutive salaries aren't the same thing as the surplus value extracted from your labor. If that was spread equally, each employee would make considerably more.
- icelancer 7y agoSurplus value extracted from labor is the literal definition of why you hire employees. If there wasn't surplus value, you wouldn't do it.
- SomeOtherThrow 7y ago> Wait until you find out how far the pay of those rich assholes goes when you spread it around! Like by raising wages? How else would you spread it around? > That some people make more - sometimes substantially more - isn't always one of them. Read marx. Or chomsky.
- Kalium 7y agoYes, like raising wages. Big piles of money tend to turn into surprisingly small ones when spread out across big piles of people. You'll have to pardon me if I'm reluctant to take my economics lessons from a linguist.
- kick 7y agoEight days ago on Hacker News: Yup. Happened to me. Big corporate decided most of our floor were surplus to requirements. Got an email on Sunday telling us to be in early on Monday for an off-site meeting. Got handed my redundancy / compromise agreement and told not to return to the office. And, the kicker, told my non-compete meant I couldn't work for a competitor during the redundancy process. It was devastating and emotionally wrecking. It was like being dumped, out of the blue, from a multi-year relationship. And being told you couldn't see anyone else. I went through all the classic stages of grief. And then... I contacted my Trade Union and explained the situation. They took a look at the contract I'd been given, passed it to a very expensive lawyer, who made a couple of phone calls. The next week I was free to work for whoever I wanted and was paid ~7 months salary (tax free). Join. A. Union. Your employer has more lawyers than you do. Pay a couple of quid per month to have decent legal representation on hand when you need it. That layoff was the best thing to happen to me. Shook me out of my cosy job, forced me into building my own consultancy, and taught me the power of solidarity. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21242176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21242176
- tastythrowaway 7y agothank you for posting this. it's a point worth realizing.
- kodablah 7y ago> That layoff was the best thing to happen to me. Shook me out of my cosy job, forced me into building my own consultancy, and taught me the power of solidarity. This last part sounds like an argument against unions. One wonders, had the commenter worked in an environment where layoffs/firings aren't worth it due to externalities (and therefore never really happen), whether they'd rethink.
- kick 7y agoThat last part sounds like an argument for. If not for the benefits he got from the union, the very last claim wouldn't have happened, and the second to last claim might not have been possible.
- 7y ago
- BeetleB 7y ago> I'd love 6 weeks of paid vacation as much as anyone. I don't see us getting that. I'd love to make twice as much money. I don't see that happening. I'd love for promotions and hiring to be more fair / better, but I don't see how this accomplishes that (nor do I know anyway to improve it). Not at Google so I can't comment about them directly. Also very neutral on unions, so don't take this comment as my preference. 6 weeks may seem hard to get, but many companies offer only 2 weeks, and 3 weeks seems the norm. 4 weeks seems doable with a union (although it may not be necessary - more and more companies are offering 4 weeks). Non-compete clauses are something unions can help with (I know they're not allowed in CA, but lots of other states allow them). The amount of time or how often one is on-call can be something unions can help with. Conditions for severance can be something unions can help with. On the flip side, unions can also make things a lot worse. YMMV.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cosmodisk 7y agoI'm in the UK. Currently have 25 days of paid holidays + 8 bank holidays. I believe this is a bare minimum one needs in order to maintain straight head and not go mad. I appreciate that's not something most people get across the pond, however I do see absolutely zero reasons,why this couldn't be the case over there as well. However,many heads had to roll and tons of blood was spilled in most European countries for these things to become a norm.
- souprock 7y agoMaybe the problem is job hopping. I got 5 weeks after being with the employer for a decade. I might be close to getting 6 weeks.
- UncleMeat 7y agoPay is not the only thing. There could be an employee elected board that is able to resolve things like disputes with managers. It's clear that there have been situations where HR is no help here. There could be agitation for greater transparency with perf, especially around things like promo quotas and ratings distributions. Unions aren't just about pay.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThose "levels" end up being oddly sexist at times. For instance, one of the women who sued Google for wage discrimination (Kelli Wisuri) was hired at L2, while male hires with similar or lesser experience were hired directly into L3 or above. And she and most of the women in her team were placed in a non-commission role, while working with men who gained commission on top of their salary. Source, page 11 of https://googlegendercase.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Ellis_v_Google_Complaint.pdf https://googlegendercase.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Elli...
- danans 7y ago> we already get better benefits than you can get anywhere else in the states I'm also a SWE at Google, and speaking only for myself, I might support efforts to ensure that those great benefits are harder to take away. Does that mean unionization ... I don't know, but there's a big spectrum of possible worker organization.
- occamrazor 7y agoHow many vacation days have Google employees in Switzerland? The legal minimum is 4 weeks, the industry standard is 5 and many companies iffer 6 after a few years.
- sanguy 7y agoLet's not forget all the bridge days as well, which are over and above vacation days. For those reading if a stat holiday falls on Tuesday or Thursday in Switzerland the Monday or Friday is a bridge day and also a holiday. It gets fantastic when Thursday and Tuesday are holidays so you get a 6 day weekend.
- ck425 7y agoMany European countries have minimum holiday entitlements close to 6 weeks. The main reason they have them is historical trade union activism.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]