7 ms·
How exactly are they "bad for the environment"? Would you prefer we revert to manufacturing plastic VHS tapes, then distribute them by diesel trucks like we us
by jiggawatts 7y ago
How exactly are they "bad for the environment"?
Would you prefer we revert to manufacturing plastic VHS tapes, then distribute them by diesel trucks like we used to in the good old days?
Would you prefer people get their morning news on broadsheets made from the bleached pulp of rainforest trees?
Or would you like to go back to the good old days of AM radio when the inadequacy of the receiver electronics was compensated for by sheer power at the transmitter, to the tune of megawatts of broadcast power?
You're probably one of those people who would prefer to breathe in lungfuls of woodsmoke rather than bathe your skin in the harmful rays of electric light.
- NateEag 7y agoI believe he's implying we don't need to share all that information, period. I agree. Remember: reduce, reuse, recycle is a hierarchy. Reduction is far more effective than the other two.
- rvense 7y agoOne of the use cases I saw somewhere for 5G was "smart wine glasses". Like glasses with sensors in them so the waiter at a restaurant would know where he needed to go to refill someone's glass. This was in a context where it definitely was not an ironic jab at the overuse of technology. I don't know if the product actually exists, but honestly. Honestly. Smart wine glasses! I think it's just like... a really, really dumb idea. And if that's the kind of thing that 5G is going to enable, I absolutely do think we should consider it a threat to the environment.
- antisemiotic 7y agoI've seen wireless thingies that would beep when your order is ready at kebab joints. Since the basic principle is the same (1-bit signaling), I'm pretty sure it could be just as well rolled out right now, unfortunately.
- cesarb 7y ago> And if that's the kind of thing that 5G is going to enable, I absolutely do think we should consider it a threat to the environment. That use case is already enabled by existing 802.15.4 protocols, no need to wait for 5G.
- ss2003 7y agoHow much water does it take to purify the silicon used in your phone?
- rimliu 7y agoIs that water destroyed beyond repair? Is there a water shortage where silicon is purified? What would you do with that water if it was not used to purify silicone, bring it to Sahara?
- rvense 7y agoI have definitely read that water poisoning is a problem in areas surrounding semiconductor fabs, but I don't have a citation on hand. Drinking water shortages are certainly common enough.
- ss2003 7y agoIt is certainly contaminated after being used. It has to be purified before hand too. The energy cost and environmental impact of manufacturing a single phone is tremendous.
- philjohn 7y agoAllegedly streaming a single 2 hour HD feature length movie online consumes the same amount of energy as boiling "10 kettles" of water - https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/energy-used-in-streaming-one-film-on-netflix-makes-60-cuppas-0hkp690rm https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/energy-used-in-streaming-...
- jokoon 7y agoConstantly replacing antennas, smartphones, having large datacenters, network infrastructure that consume a lot of energy is bad for the environment. Video is a big offender. Instagram and facebook feeds also consume a lot of memory and energy. Even storing document as PDF instead of paper might be worse after all. If at least smartphones would be designed to last 4 or 5 years it would make a big difference. Wirth's law is also an excellent way to describe how computer software is most often horribly designed, and it also plays a huge role in how we could have cheaper and eco-friendly devices. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law > You're probably one of those people Lowering yourself to snarky comments is not helping your argument.