5 ms·
The dual share class thing needs to be phased out, at least as it pertains to separating voting rights from economic rights. (Seems fine for other purposes like
by lordnacho 7y ago
The dual share class thing needs to be phased out, at least as it pertains to separating voting rights from economic rights. (Seems fine for other purposes like cross border listings.)
It's a bubble symptom that investors are happy to go with reduced influence, both wrt equity share classes as well as looser covenants on debt.
As for planning for your kids to own the company, that's pretty common.
- robbiep 7y agoThere’s nothing wrong with setting up company structures that have radically different rights wrt. Shares; what is important is that the market prices them correctly. And the market clearly has no idea how to price the control. Look at Facebook or many of the other major tech exits that have allowed ords to be priced from a ‘control’ perspective. The market believes in a BDFL model at the moment and is being taught a bit of a lesson
- tim333 7y agoI guess if you are going to have a benevolent dictator, check they really are benevolent.
- zaphar 7y agoThe hard of a benevolent dictator isn't finding a benevolent person. Its ensuring they stay benevolent. That type of power has a track record of corrupting the holder.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tim333 7y agoThe organisation of shares is really a matter for the shareholders and many of the well known dual share class companies seem to have done well for investors. BRK, Ford, Google, Facebook. Even Uber is still valued at $54bn which is not bad for a taxi app.
- awinder 7y agoCorrelation is not causation, and the period of time that dual class has been used this way is not long enough to establish causation. Wait until there’s a real crisis that runs up against the dual class share issue. That’s when the wheels will come off.
- unreal37 7y agoIsn't Ford 100 years old? Not long enough? The Ford family has 40% voting power and 2% share ownership.
- tim333 7y agoAlso the alternative arrangement where things end up controlled by wall street types trying to boost things short term to increase their bonuses often has not worked out great over the long term.
- awinder 7y agoFord was around for like 53 years before they publicly offered stock. And they’re a success story for dual class sure. Check out hollinger for a case where dual class didn’t work out great. Theres definitely not enough source data to say that dual class is responsible for positive outcome.