5 ms·
This stance is a little silly from tech circles. Something you are is the perfect form of authentication. If you had a guard sitting at a door with only biome
by Spivak 7y ago
This stance is a little silly from tech circles.
Something you are is the perfect form of authentication.
If you had a guard sitting at a door with only biometric information about the people they’re supposed to let in: faces, fingerprints, DNA samples, voice samples, etc. you could not fool them. Why? Because they can authenticate that the reading is coming from the actual person.
This is the revolution. If your phone can with good enough accuracy determine that it’s looking at a real alive attentive human face or a real finger then it’s game over. It’s an auth cred that can literally only be used by you, it can’t be copied, stolen, hacked, phished, and can be totally public while being useless to an attacker because they can’t mint a live human with real matching fingerprint.
If you think of biometric auth as “present a picture of your fingerprint” and not “present your actual finger” then of course you arrive at the conclusion that they’re useless as a credential.
- scarejunba 7y agoIn general, I'm on board with what you're saying, but there's a thing with security credentials: it's important for me to allow me to give them away to the guy with a knife. If knife guy comes for me and says "Your phone and password or your life" I can give it to him. It's kind of important that I can or else he'll take my bloody finger with him and body integrity is way more important to me than any amount of my data. Literally, I prefer my fingers attached and you can clear my bank account rather than the alternative.
- Marsymars 7y agoThe solution here seems to be some credentialing solution that can neither be given away voluntarily nor taken by force. Is such a thing possible?
- munk-a 7y agoI disagree, I don't think there is any need for proof of identity to not be voluntarily relinquishable. I think relinquishable credentials are quite useful for a number of delegation related uses - but if they are relinquishable then they need to be expirable as well.
- Marsymars 7y agoThe guy with a knife won't ask for proof of identity that he knows you can't give up.
- rolph 7y agothe guy with the knife is why fingerprints retinal or iris scans, and facial metrics shouldnt be used. You may not be able to give these things but they can be taken, using that knife.
- godelski 7y agoYou don't even have to be alive for those things either.
- munk-a 7y agoIf a guy with a knife wants my password I'm going to give it up and walk away alive, then try and recoup the loss of whatever I gave up... maybe I get the debit against an account reversed or purge recent account activity from social media. There currently is nothing secret like that that I'd give up my life to protect, and I can't conceive of anything of such import existing... for those cases where the item is truly dangerous (like the nuclear football) then a guy with a knife being a threat is already a failure of security.
- lonelappde 7y agoThis is how iPhone works today. Apple bricks your phone if it is stolen, as a disincentive against theft.
- scarface74 7y agoDetached fingers don’t work with modern implementations of fingerprint sensors.
- munk-a 7y agoOh, I was unaware of that - so I'm not certain I want to rely on the knowledge of someone in a position to cut off my finger... additionally, they don't currently work, but I'm sure there could be developed ways to spoof them by artificially circulating warmed blood or some such. Just... biometrics are such a terrible idea - let's not even open that door.
- rolph 7y agothe problem isnt weather or not its true, the problem is how likely someone is to try using a severed part any way, because it just might be FUD and a dead finger is just as good as attached. aside from that, a severed finger continues to live for a while afterward, it doesnt instantly perish. it has to metabolize its oxygen reserves.
- scarface74 7y agoThe most popular and high priced phone has had fingerprint authentication since 2013. If there was going to be a rash of people cutting off fingers, wouldn’t it have happened by now?
- rolph 7y agoIf it happened would any PR department admit it? so far the tactic of waiting for someone to unlock a phone then robbing them has been effective. as soon as it becomes required behaviour it will happen. so far there are methods of hijacking a phone from its original owner, even without the phone in hand [simjacking] and as such tactics are stymied, other more brutal force methods would be required.
- scarface74 7y ago
- datapunk 7y agoThe issue with Biometrics, atleast for those in the US, is that they are not protected by the 5th amendment. Court cases have reaffirmed this, meaning you can be forced to provide your Biometrics for law enforcement to gain access to your devices. Some may feel this is acceptable with the thought if your not guilty then you should have nothing to hide, but this is a fallacy as it tramples over our 4th amendment rights. With passwords locked in your head, you cannot be forced to give that information as that is protected by the 5th amendment. Accessing the device or any information protected by a password must then be done with other means or not admissible as longer delays violates due process.
- scarface74 7y agoYou’re assuming that law enforcement doesn’t routinely force suspects to give up their PINs and lie and say it was voluntary. On the other hand, it was reported in the UK (?) that law enforcement follows around suspects, wait for them to unlock their phone in public and tackle them before they re lock it.
- datapunk 7y agoNo one is forced to give up information, you mean they were convinced and ignorant of their rights. Which was given up voluntarily in any case. The tactic you mentioned has been used here in the US aswell. Something similar was done to DPR that brought down The Silk Road.
- scarface74 7y agoYou really don’t think that police brutality is a thing - ie rubber hose decryption?
- datapunk 7y agoI think your point is moot. Is torture legal? Is any evidence gained through torture admissable? Are any law enforcement allowed to use torture to gain access to information? You should be able to answer those yourself. Legal rights are not trumpt by illegal tactics, no matter what information is recovered.
- disappearance 7y ago> Something you are is the perfect form of authentication Disagree. A bank manger with a gun held to their head is not a bank manager for the intended purposes.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoShould an authentication system be expected to reliably determine the motive of the user in addition to their identity? Various anti-fraud systems address this to varying extents, but a bank manager sitting at their laptop, tying in their password and TOTP with a gun to their head isn’t materially different to them providing biometric authentication with a gun to their head.
- zarify 7y agoAuthentication != authorisation. The bank manager is still authentically the bank manager, gun or not.
- ryan_lane 7y agoIdentity != authentication. The bank manager is, from the identification POV, still the bank manager. The bank manager may not be intending to authenticate, though.
- jryle70 7y agoI think you're splitting hairs. Authentication simply means to verify someone being who they claims they are. No more, no less. If we go by your definition login with id and password isn't authentication either. How would we know if the person is "intending to authenticate"!
- lonelappde 7y agoThe bank manager is identified, but the request is not authenticated.
- CDSlice 7y ago
- macspoofing 7y ago>If you had a guard sitting at a door ... you could not fool them. What??? Of course you could. That's why no building that cares about security actually relies on a human guard for authorization.