11 ms·
Builders Ditch Nest After Google Ties Devices to Digital Assistant
- neonate 7y agohttps://outline.com/JUHxC3 https://outline.com/JUHxC3
- sdan 7y agoNot surprised. Google should’ve left nest out of this. Now they need everyone who has a house, a google account as well. Tony Fadell probably wouldn’t like how google transformed his product.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>Tony Fadell probably wouldn’t like how google transformed his product. as if Google was a paragon of integrity and privacy when Nest was sold for billions...
- navigatesol 7y ago>Tony Fadell probably wouldn’t like how google transformed his product. I put zero stock in the words of people who sell their company for vast sums of money, then complain how the new company runs things.
- _iyig 7y agoI've been leery of Google ever since they required me to enable web and search history to use weather and calendar alerts with Google Home.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI got rid of my Nest products and switched to a HomeKit versions because of this.
- vinay427 7y agoThis annoyed me quite a bit as well. My Google Assistant device has a LED display that ordinarily displays the time and the temperature below it, but the temperature part was just blank without the history enabled which seems incredibly vindictive to be.
- dillonmckay 7y agoThat is hostile to the user. Wow.
- mindslight 7y agoBut when are they/we going to learn the meta lesson, which is that this is an inevitable outcome [0] of every "cloud" connected piece of trash? With the ease of distributing software to mobile devices, there is little reason for something to be designed around phoning home instead of using well documented protocols on the local network, but for the "value add" of gradually implementing ever more surveillance and lock in. Frankly the tech community is shirking our professional responsibility by not loudly condemning marketing-pushed junk like Nest, and letting it gain market share in the first place. [0] Well, one of two possible outcomes really. The other being plain abandonment.
- wizzard 7y agoNot only do they now force you to have a Google account and Google Assistant (via Android or Google Home) to take full advantage of your Nest now, but they also pretty much gutted the API in the name of "privacy." Ironic. I was looking to play with my historical data to try and figure out how my two heating and cooling systems were interacting, but that data is no longer available to non-grandfathered developers. The only way to access my own data from my super-technologically-advanced-device-owned-by-Google is by ordering a dump of CSV files.
- ethbro 7y agoI don't think anyone in the tech world believes Google killed integration features in the name of privacy. The fact that that's the PR spin they chose points to how poorly managed the entire division must be. If you want more control, just say it.
- wizzard 7y agoIt's definitely a convenient excuse if you just want to be lazy. I certainly can't imagine how any Nest developer could abuse my private data any worse than Google already does. God forbid any third party should find out -- with my permission! -- what my thermostat was set to last Monday.
- techslave 7y agoyou have only yourself to be angry with
- wizzard 7y agoHow so? I bought into Nest long before it was bought by Google. Should I have been able to predict all this somehow?
- epc 7y agoI finished setting up a pile of Nest thermostats and cameras about a month before Google killed “works with Nest”. Am now planning to remove all of the Nest products. Haven't figured out what to replace the cameras with (I do not want to go through this again with another vendor). The Nest thermostats were great for the first couple of years we had them and we saw some measurable savings on heating and cooling. Killing off the automation options via IFTTT kills the utility of the thermostats for me (and Google Assistant is useless as a replacement if your primary Google accounts are G Suite accounts).
- _iyig 7y agoFire Phone notwithstanding, Amazon seems to offer good long-term support for their devices. I've been very pleased with my e-Ink Kindles, first-gen FireTV, and first-gen Alexa. I expect the Amazon Cloud Camera to have a similarly lengthy product lifetime.
- el_benhameen 7y agoI use Wyze cameras for baby monitors, home security, etc., and I’ve been pretty happy with them. They’re cheap enough that you can throw a camera at pretty much any idea. They are a cloud-based product so they come with all of the associated privacy concerns, but if you were using Nest then that’s maybe not a huge deal. Not affiliated with the company, just relatively pleased with the products.
- icelancer 7y agoSame. I use their cameras and now their motion detectors. They are cheap and work well. Their IR filters jam regularly though on the cameras, giving everything a blindingly purple shade unless you just have IR/night mode on at all times. Small price to pay for the cost of the camera I guess.
- the_pwner224 7y agoThe Wyze cams are very cheap and you might be able to use them locally as normal network cameras without any internet connection. A year or two ago I looked into this and there was a 'jailbreak' to load different firmware onto it, but I think it stopped being functional due to updates. However, I have heard things about an official offline firmware being released by Wyze which you may want to look into.
- epistasis 7y agoNest has been so terribly mismanaged seemingly from the beginning of the acquisition; has there been any management level change to compensate for the poor execution? I really like the look of the Nest thermometer, but I definitely don't want Google in control of anything in my house, or listening to anything in my house, with how the manage this stuff. If I do automate anything, I will be going with Home Assistant, even though I kind of despise home rolling these sorts of things. I don't trust any of the major players, and their recent behavior and lack of care for the user makes me nervous for the future of tech.
- mtgx 7y agoIs it poor management or exactly what Google wanted to do with it all along?
- mmmBacon 7y agoManagement at big companies like Google is about protecting your $1M+ paycheck a year and not about innovation. You don’t rock the boat and you don’t stick your neck out. These companies are not hungry, they are simply greedy.
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoYou're underestimating the complexity of the game. It's not certain that not sticking your neck out protects your paycheck or the company's profits. Some other company or employee may be willing to take more risk and succeed. https://www.cio.com/article/2379013/satya-nadella-to-succeed-ballmer-as-microsoft-ceo.html https://www.cio.com/article/2379013/satya-nadella-to-succeed... https://www.cnet.com/news/google-buys-android/ https://www.cnet.com/news/google-buys-android/
- ageofwant 7y agoThis. Any company pass a certain size has a legion of upper, and middle manglers whose sole responsibility is risk management, and paramount to anything is the risk to the personal wealth and progression of said manager. There is very little incentive to 'innovate'.
- 7y ago
- olliej 7y agoI bought a nest thermostat just before google bought it. Returned it immediately because even before the current “smart home” insanity I knew google couldn’t be trusted to not harvest and steal information about you.
- PeterStuer 7y agoIt is not just Google. Regulation on listening devices, especially those that can connect to or transmit to a network, needs a big overhaul. Yes, I know every phone is basically the same thing and we all have those near or with us all the time, but that does not mean all our conversations and other sounds are up for grabs. A more sane model could be requiring a deliberate manual action to turn on the the microphone for up to 10 seconds. Something like STNG's comms badges that you touch to speak would be nice.
- GistNoesis 7y agoWe are at kind of reaching climax here, it's going to get harder to collect anymore thing. With the gesture recognition SOLI chips, they managed to introduce what is technically a sexual performance monitor in the android phone near your bed, without even an ounce of resistance from the public. Every advertiser and surveillance wet dream is now achieved. There is no other term than total victory for the post-privacy world. It is time to surrender without conditions before they leverage their knowledge of our declining interests in our wives or of our extra-marital adventures. (edit:There is still time to avoid blood and tears)
- pas 7y ago... if you want privacy, maybe turn off these things on your phone. Even just simply switching off the phone is easy. My phone boots in half a minute and switches off in ~5 seconds. Home automation should have a switch off too.
- pacala 7y agoGood luck turning off your home-automation controlled heating when it's 20F outside.
- pas 7y agoThat's why it should have an off state. When life support stays on, and nothing else. Maybe a dumb-switch. Also, I haven't said that privacy is not a valid concern. But if heating is so tied to your home automation, then that's a problem. It should be able to maintain a steady temperature, just as simple thermostat system, just like before buying the fancy home automation system. (Sure, there are probably homes being built now with integrated smart/fancy systems, but still, if those lack the aforementioned fallback functionality, then they are very predictability going to have a bad time when the fancy system needs maintenance and the folks living there start to get cold.)
- Fezzik 7y agoIt really is a pox of a product. I’m in the process of buying a house and any listings with Nest products I just skip. I know it is negligible, financially and physically, to remove them, but why even bother when there are plenty of options that don’t come pre-equipped with dysfunctional spyware.
- goatinaboat 7y agoWhat happens with Nest if your Google account gets locked out for any reason? You can no longer heat your home?
- BeanoBox 7y agoIf you can get a pay as you go Sim card it may be worth it to register a new Google account just for nest. Separate nest from your personal Google account. That's if nest is worth that effort.
- goatinaboat 7y agoThey absolutely will know it’s you straight away... their algorithms will instantly match the address with the location data they slurp from your phone, if nothing else.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoSharing an address isn't uncommon. I don't think there's a big risk that a Google account would be locked because another account at the same address had been.
- dillonmckay 7y agoThis is not a confidence inspiring answer. It is not worth the risk. They ban other accounts based on IP, so this would not be a stretch.
- dbuder 7y ago
- Animats 7y agoBuilders have to offer warranties on new houses, including HVAC systems. Which means that the builder and their insurance company is liable when Google screws up. What insurance company would want to be in that position?
- Gibbon1 7y agoThis is the correct answer. When the next recession hits and google panics and dumps all this crap overboard, the builder is left holding the bag.
- bencollier49 7y agoSomeone needs to start a home device company with open-source firmware. Yes, susceptible to cheap Chinese clones, but if done correctly could control the market.
- ficklepickle 7y agoMozilla WebThings is pretty cool. The gateway software runs on a Pi. They have their own open protocol over wifi or you can use ie. a ZigBee adapter. I've played with it and I think it has a lot of potential.
- mehhh 7y agoDevice drivers seem to be the main issue for IoT gateways. That being said, I have been really impressed with Arcus, the open sourced Lowes IoT platform (formerly known as Iris). ZigBee & Z-Wave work out of the box, very broad device support, writing templates for new devices is pretty straightforward.
- chrisbennet 7y ago"Iris by Lowe’s is gone, but here’s the open source code to keep your smart devices alive Lowe's closed Iris, now renamed Arcus, but released software to let these smart home products continue to work" https://www.gearbrain.com/iris-lowes-arcus-smart-home-2633475020.html https://www.gearbrain.com/iris-lowes-arcus-smart-home-263347...
- JoBrad 7y agoI didn’t know they did that. Really commendable.
- mehhh 7y agoLowes also gave everyone back all the money they paid for Iris hardware, the only thibg they did not refund were monthly service subscriptions. Best Buy just shut down their IoT offering, open sourced nothing and gave no refunds.
- manigandham 7y agoWe have Nest thermostats without a google account or any mobile app connected to them. They work fine. This Google account stuff is only for extended automation or integration with other "smart" home stuff. I doubt many people really need or want all that, and it's mostly a gimmick anyway.
- slfnflctd 7y agoI don't know if I would exactly call the ability to monitor/adjust the set temperature in your home from in bed without having to get up and walk to the thermostat on the other side of the house a gimmick. It's also handy when you're on the couch and have a child and/or a couple cats sleeping on you that you don't want to disturb. It even functions to reduce low-level irrational anxieties when traveling [Is my house on fire right now? Okay, thermostat's still connected and temperature looks normal, I can stop worrying about that for the moment.] I'm as wary of this continuing mass privacy invasion as anyone, but the reason it's getting traction is because it offers new functionalities people value that are decidedly not just gimmicks.
- jpindar 7y ago"Is my house on fire right now?" may sound paranoid, but "Has my house lost power due to the blizzard, and if so, is it getting cold enough to burst the pipes?" doesn't.
- manigandham 7y agoIf you lost power how is it reporting anything? And how do you turn on the heat without power?
- jpindar 7y agoOK, if the power is out you wouldn't know the temperature. Although in theory you could build a battery powered cellular system. But like slfnflctd said, if it doesn't report that the situation is normal, there's likely to be a problem. If there's no power and it's cold enough to matter, you go there (or call a neighbor or handyman) to either start a generator, start up a kerosene heater, or drain the pipes.
- diogenescynic 7y agoI’m ditching Nest when my contract is up. They’re forcing everyone to convert to Google accounts. I guess I’ll replace them with Ring cams? Doesn’t seem like there are many other good cheap alternatives with a data storage plan. I also have a 4G Arlo security camera and wish there were more 4G/5G remote camera options.... hoping we’re about to get more options as 5G spreads.
- dcow 7y agoRing means you use an Amazon owned account.
- diogenescynic 7y agoI’m aware, but I firmly see Google as worse company and steward of my personal data than Amazon.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 7y agoI’ve been using a couple of Logitech Circle 2 and have been pretty happy with them. The software comes with data storage plans and integrates with all the major home ecosystems (Amazon, Apple, Google).
- diogenescynic 7y agoThanks, I'll do some research on those. Appreciate the tip.
- chinathrow 7y agoFirst they come for search. Then they come for e-mail. Then they come for mobile. Then they come for your home. Then no privacy is left. Then we lose.
- pacala 7y agoYou forgot autonomous vehicles, which double as a high capacity sensor platform connected to the mother hive. On which you can keep piling more and more intrusive sensors in the name of safety. If you ever wondered why Google of all companies is in the forefront of that technology.
- yardie 7y agoWell when they first came out I thought the product was super innovative. But the competition didn’t rest on their laurels either. I’ve looked at many smart thermostats over the last year. We settled on HomeKit because of the privacy and it not being IoT based. This knocked Nest out of the running.
- navigatesol 7y ago>Well when they first came out I thought the product was super innovative.* I never really understood it. It's a nice looking, albeit expensive, thermostat with some simple optimization algorithms. Now it's a spying tool. Meanwhile, my HVAC runs on a dumb Honeywell unit that I can program a schedule on. Haven't even replaced the batteries in years.
- DocG 7y agoI don't trust technology companies to mess up updating apps, removing features or breaking working functionality, sure as hell as I don't trust them with something permanently in my wall. Oh sorry, we decided to end the support for this product because there weren't any users. No, you can't use it offline. Buy a new one, break your walls every three years etc. Maybe, maybe companies who produce industrial equipment, and know what it takes to have something work for 20 years non stop. DOS based CNC machines etc.