6 ms·
“I was told to buy a software or lose my computer: I ignored it”
- mysterypie 7y ago> With a U.S. population of ~200M, let’s call it 4M infections/year. We know that 4% of respondents paid the ransom, so that’s 160,000 ransom payments. If we say $200 per paid ransom as a guess, that means the ransomware ‘industry’ is making about $32M a year. The U.S. population is actually ~327M, but since we're talking ballpark figures, let's just say that ~200M represents the adult computer-using population. It strikes that ransomware is both much bigger and much smaller than I thought. The 160,000 ransom payments is much bigger than I would have guessed. It's not like being struck by lightning; it's more like a serious car accident. But the actual revenue generated, $32M as he's estimated, is pitiful. There are all sorts of illegal, quasi-legal, and legal ripoffs that generates billions per year. For the amount of attention ransomware gets, it's just noise.
- mannykannot 7y agoThe attention seems to be due to two factors: the high-profile cases that hit large organizations like school districts, local government or hospitals (which are not affected by common scams), and the relative novelty of using cryptocurrency for paying the ransom (though not predominantly, according to this survey; I would guess that using cryptocurrency reduces the yield from the individual users that are the common victims.)
- Frye 7y agoFor now it may be just noise, but the ransoms are quickly getting bigger and bigger. Last month I facilitated the payment of 3 BTC to decrypt the files.
- celticninja 7y agoI imagine these sort of attacks are more like spear phishing, in that they look for high value targets. No one is paying $25k for the family laptop files, but a medium sized business,perhaps digital in nature, would be quick it pay that price to fix the problem.
- sp332 7y agoRansomware can be hard to trace, which keeps risk low, and that means criminals can afford to ask for less money. It's also a benefit to keep the ransoms small enough that people will pony up instead of getting the FBI involved.
- est31 7y agoAs with most criminal activity, the damage created by it is much larger than the money made. I couldn't find any US figures, but global estimates claim ransomware-caused damages of 11.5 billion USD in 2019: https://cybersecurityventures.com/ransomware-damage-report-2017-part-2/ https://cybersecurityventures.com/ransomware-damage-report-2...
- dhruvmittal 7y agoI'm guessing the damage numbers are higher because of a number of high-impact city-focused attacks. I live in Baltimore, where all of the city's systems were shut down for a few months over a ransomware attack asking for <100k. A similar attack occurred last year in Atlanta; wikipedia quotes a demand of 50k & Atlanta estimated around 10M in contractors for recovery. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Atlanta_cyberattack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Atlanta_cyberattack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Baltimore_ransomware_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Baltimore_ransomware_atta...
- Bartweiss 7y agoLong-tail damage to governments and hospitals is definitely part of it - there's very little upper bound on how much ransomware can cost if you botch the response badly enough. And given how much ransomware simply doesn't decrypt if you pay, there's no reason the ransom prices should have any real correlation to the damage inflicted. The other part of it appears to be some slightly funny calculations. If ransomware shuts down Target's online store for a day, Target might compute the loss based on 24 hours of no revenue, but purchases that go to Amazon, or to Target a day later, shouldn't be added into total "damage". The dollar value being computed there is something more like disruption.
- codemac 7y agoThis was calculated by Cisco & Cybersecurity Ventures, who both directly profit from the fear generated by these figures. I do not trust these figures. This is marketing for CIO/CISO's to read so they make sure to add in various security features to their BoM for purchase.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- downrightmike 7y agoNow that there is insurance for ransom ware, The insurers are usually paying the criminals, which will only lead to more attacks.
- tmikaeld 7y agoOn MacOS, the free "RansomWhere?" tool is a really nice thing to have, it warns if any app is hammering files and stops it until you approve/deny. https://www.objective-see.com/products/ransomwhere.html https://www.objective-see.com/products/ransomwhere.html
- vezycash 7y agoWindows 10 now has in-built randsomware protection with Windows Defender.
- jermaustin1 7y agoDoes it actually work? I haven't had a virus in decades to my knowledge, and I stopped running virus scanners back in 2005 or so. Windows Defender is on my computer, but I never run a scan. Maybe it does in the background, but I've never seen anything notifying me about a virus or ransomware or malware.
- organsnyder 7y agoWindows Defender does background scanning unless you disable it (and Windows will show a nice warning icon in the tray if you do).
- djhaskin987 7y ago"Removed by someone else" = my family member called me up in tears
- jnty 7y agoInteresting that despite the huge effort both sides put in to to fixing/exploiting vulnerabilities the biggest risk factor seems to be directly downloading random dodgy stuff.
- thomascgalvin 7y agoI suspect that this is always going to be the case. There are a lot of people literate enough to operate a computer, but not literate enough to understand the risks they're taking by running something they download off of scammers.ru. Exploiting these people will always be easier than actively circumventing OS-level security.
- inanutshellus 7y agoI was going to say "Desktop apps need permissions like Android apps" that ask your permission to access resources and then was immediately reminded of the "I'm a Mac" commercials mocking Windows for doing exactly that... /Le sigh/... I used to use this software called Clean Slate that would watch all the changes you made to your computer and undo them when you restarted. Maybe it's time for Grandma to get her own Docker instance.... :-)
- greggman2 7y agoIs Steam a big vector? Gamers download hundreds of apps, all get installed as admin. You have to trust every dev of the game and the devs of every library they use. Not just trust that the devs weren't actively trying to be evil but also that their is no bugs in their networking code (https://momo5502.com/blog/?p=34 https://momo5502.com/blog/?p=34) nor any bugs in their deserialization code for mods
- freeflight 7y ago> Is Steam a big vector? I've never heard of something like that happening, and I've been using Steam since day 1. Trying to find something on Google about that only turns up the usual "Hijacked accounts spreading malware to friends" scheme [0] and vulnerabilities in the client itself [1], but nothing about Steam distributing malware hidden in games. Which is kinda unexpected, I probably just didn't dig deep enough? [0] https://www.hackread.com/hacked-steam-accounts-spreading-malware/ https://www.hackread.com/hacked-steam-accounts-spreading-mal... [1] https://thenextweb.com/apps/2019/03/21/valve-steam-vulnerability-malware-steal/ https://thenextweb.com/apps/2019/03/21/valve-steam-vulnerabi...
- cat199 7y agousually I don't say anything since this usage is so prevalent, and I typically hate being pedantic about grammar, but since this is a journal title: it is not 'a' software. not here, not there, never. the construct <category-of-material>-ware is plural. period. therefore there can never be 'a' of them. it is 'software' or 'a <noun describing unit> of software', e.g. 'a piece of software' or perhaps '<quantifier> software' as in 'some software' 'this software', 'malware removing software', etc. 'a software program', which can be shortened to 'a program', etc, is fine, because the 'a' refers to 'program', which is implicitly in the singular.
- matthewowen 7y agoUhhhhh it's a quote from someone who said it that way, and that choice is presumably meant to convey that they aren't particularly tech savvy.
- posterboy 7y agothis is both non-sense. proscriptive arguments drawn from nothing but your single minded authority have little value in discurs. "a software" (sorry) is quite frequent. fullstop. Ger ware is singular by the way.
- cat199 7y ago1) Are you a native speaker? Frequency of 'a software' arrived with the growth of non-native speakers on the internet, and is irrelevant to its 'correctness'. Plenty of bad non-native speach patterns are 'frequent', one can often tell the country of origin of a person from speech irregularities and even adapt a pseudo-dialect which may even improve the ability to communicate with them. Don't have stats to back it up, but I have been involved in computers from the mid 80s and literally never heard this term until ~99 or so, initially typically in the context of text clearly written by non-native speakers, and then gradually gaining some traction among younger users who think it's 'cool' or 'normative'. I have no doubt that a more formal investigation would line up with this, give or take. 2) It's 'discourse' not 'discurs'. It's also 'nonsense' and not 'non-sense', and also 'full stop'. All of which would imply that the anser to #1 is 'no' - which proves a further point - that idioms and patterns of speech matter to correctness and are quickly seen by native speakers, but are not usually obvious to those who learned the language second hand. Based on these mistakes, the bizarre 'this is both' introductory phrasing, parenthetical '(sorry)' and the general dry, dismissive tone with a petite je-ne-seis-pas of anti-authoritarian mockery that is just begging for a leading 'pfft', my guess is that you are French. Not really germane to the conversation, but, if correct, it underlines my point about the obviousness of idioms and cultural undertones to native speakers (of any language really). 3) To support 1 and 2: If I am incorrect, which, weighing my thoughts against North American vs British idioms, I'd happy to be incorrect but am fairly certain am not, please show me a single usage of 'bakeware', 'cookware', 'hardware' or any other 'ware' where people say 'a <x>' existent in any piece of literature prior to the existence of computers: I took a bakeware and baked a lasagna: no. A pan is a bakeware: no. I washed a cookware and made a salad in it: no. A bowl is a cookware: no. Can you hand me a silverware? I need to cut my steak.: no. A knife is a silverware: no. I bought a hardware from the hardware store to fix the fence: no. A hammer is a hardware: no. And, even in computers, the (incorrect) 'a software' use is inconsistent w/r/t hardware: I bought a new hardware to run my application: no. The new iPad is a great new hardware: no. 4) 'A ware' is singular, but also non specific. X-ware is plural. Whatever this meant in pseudo-proto-germanic is irrelevant to a discussion of English.
- jansan 7y agoAt the end of the article you can see quite a bold attempt at curve fitting.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoNot to mention that there is very little motivation given for the quantification of the individual threats. Not having 2fa is apparently 1 point, backing up only ever few weeks is 2, .. it almost seems as if these were chosen retroactively to make the curve look the way it does. From the paper: > Given the results above, we now present and discuss a proof-of-concept approach to risk assessment to estimate futureransomware infection that is based only on self-reported se-curity habits and past exposure to online scams. The methoddemonstrates that assessments can, in theory, be made with relatively little information, enabling consumers to estimatetheir own risk. We stress from the outset, however, that wemerely intend to illustrate the general approach; in particular, the strategy we present would need to undergo more rigor-ous evaluation before it could be responsibly used for riskassessment in the broader population. Seems tenuous, that disclaimer notwithstanding.
- jmmcd 7y ago> it almost seems as if these were chosen retroactively to make the curve look the way it does. That's what regression does! And maybe they should've used regression, indeed. Instead, this looks more like an "improper linear model" http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.188.5825 http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.188.... -- something we see less and less of now that regression models are at our fingertips.
- rambojazz 7y agoIt looks about right though, doesn't it? What else would fit the dots better?
- IOT_Apprentice 7y agoI don't understand the title of the article or presentation. It appears to be a quote, and on first glance doesn't seem to be part of the article body itself.
- penisLiquor 7y agoPeople have learned to distrust all machines as unreliable, capricious and unredeeming. Most people attempt to minimize the relevance of computers in their life, despite the massive tidal forces that handily defeat any such sentiment. Indeed, right here on HN, the very idea that many people simply do not like to use computers at all will raise an eyebrow or two as borderline unthinkable, so strong are these tidal forces, and so betrothed computing acolytes are to their parasitic machine twins. This doesn't mean that regular people have the capability to step away from retaining limited skills as a novice computer user, but they instinctively deflect the degree control that any one entity (such as laptop, mobile device, online account, financial institution) can leverage against them, where possible, and minimize the damage that any single fault can inflict. Use of computers is often begrudgingly required, in some cases legally enforced, and with that awareness of obligation and power differential, people are prepared to suffer the cost and pain of being forced to trust something they never asked for. They know that sometimes it will hurt. Sometimes, they bite the pain and watch it burn.
- Const-me 7y agoOffline backups. A ransomware can technically encrypt all drives, steal password from cloud backup software, and destroy it too. Or they can be destroyed by uploading encrypted files. No software can destroy data on a hard drive that's disconnected and unpowered. Only I can.
- JohnClark1337 7y agoGiven the title I was expecting an article on the EOL for Windows XP or Vista