3 ms·
Your statistical gymnastics is a case of how to lie with statistics. Most rapes aren't cases of random strangers grabbing you randomly off the street. That's n
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Your statistical gymnastics is a case of how to lie with statistics.
Most rapes aren't cases of random strangers grabbing you randomly off the street. That's not how that works.
Most rape victims know their rapists. It's usually a social acquaintance of some sort.
Most college campus rapes or date rapes involve alcohol.
There is this narrative that we can't try to talk about what women can effectively do to protect themselves because that would be blaming the victim. But if you tell someone to lock your door to make it harder for someone to rob you, we don't have the same problem with such advice. We don't get all up in arms about how robbers just need to keep their hands to themselves and advice to protect your belongings is somehow victim blaming.
- ALittleLight 7y agoI don't really know what we're arguing about at this point so I'm tapping out. I agree that it's good and not victim blaming to offer advice to people, regardless of their gender, as to how they can live safer lives. I agree that, in the US, most victims know their attacker. That doesn't mean it's safe for young women to hitchhiker in Mexico though. Similarly, you are vastly more likely to be killed by your own gun than any random gun out there. That doesn't mean you have nothing to worry about if some random stranger points a gun at you.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat doesn't mean it's safe for young women to hitchhiker in Mexico though. I never claimed what you are seemingly rebutting at all. I never said anything of the sort whatsoever. I only suggested that this particular woman probably wasn't simply lucky. She was probably doing some things right that helped keep her safe. It's an entirely different idea. It's the difference between saying "Lion tamers have lion taming skills and aren't merely lucky that they usually survive their shows." Versus "Because lion tamers exist, random people with zero lion taming skills are equally safe being locked in a cage with a lion."
- partyboat1586 7y agoLion tamers are also regularly killed and or maimed by their lions.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe word usually in that sentence admits to that outcome. Nowhere have I claimed any of this is "bullet proof." Just that consistent positive outcomes suggest an element of skill and knowledge that claims of pure luck erroneously dismiss as not existing at all.
- partyboat1586 7y agoFair enough there is an element of skill. It's still a foolish idea to be a Lion tamer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]