8 ms·
There are several world leaders that I'd be happier with if they weren't leaders. (And some local leaders too! There are city councilmen I would send to Mars if
by fortran77 7y ago
There are several world leaders that I'd be happier with if they weren't leaders. (And some local leaders too! There are city councilmen I would send to Mars if I could.)
But I absolutely want and need to know what they're saying. A platform that provides a direct way for them to speak shouldn't be interfering with that.
- badrequest 7y agoAre they interfering with that, or are they simply limiting your ability to interact with the content beyond viewing it?
- inimino 7y agoA part of using the platform is the ways in which other users respond to your content, so this seems like a distinction without a difference.
- metalliqaz 7y agoThat sounds awfully naive to me. World leaders have all kinds of options for communicating with the public. Official press releases, for example. Press releases are preferable because when they tell falsehoods, they can be fact checked in the press. We have no obligation to allow them to use social networks for propaganda purposes.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoPersonally, I'd rather hear directly from the person, rather than get someone's spin on it. Believe it or not, some people are smart enough to make decisions for themselves, and don't need the corporate media to make decisions for them. I've seen their fact checking, it's hilariously biased.
- metalliqaz 7y agoperhaps some people are we know for a fact that most people are susceptible to misinformation and propaganda. the modern advertising industry should be more than enough proof of that
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoSo who gets to decide what is misinformation and propaganda? Because it seems liberals want to paint any conservative idea as propaganda, just because it's a different though. From my perspective, and proven via wikileaks, the Democrats have been a propaganda machine, and definitely conspire with the corporate media, but sure, let's target the President.
- iron0013 7y agoWell, since it's Twitter's own platform, and they make the rules, they could just as easily ban someone simply because they don't like them. That's how owning things works.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoAh yes, so now we'll fallback to they are a private company because there is no other defense. They are free to do whatever they want, they are not free from criticism. That's why I don't deal with Twitter, I support freedom of speech, and clearly they don't. So them, and the Saudi's that own them can go tweet themselves.
- iron0013 7y agoIt's not a "fallback", I'm pretty sure being a private company is their entire raison d'etre. And, you know, like the sign in every small-town diner says: “We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone.” Which is to say, they can give any reason, or no reason at all, for showing a user the door. That's their prerogative as the owners and operators of a business.
- 7y ago
- braythwayt 7y ago> Personally, I'd rather hear directly from the person, rather than get someone's spin on it. Well, that's ridiculously easy on Twitter. Just follow them. What is changing here is whether you hear from them just because your buddy Ed(wina) thinks they said something amazing, when they have a track record for breaking the Twitter rules. IME, keeping on Twitter's good side is a pretty low bar is you're powerful and well-connected, so you will still hear plenty from the usual suspects. > I've seen their fact checking, it's hilariously biased. Twitter recently published their rules for fact-checking, and it involves relying on a very small set of third-party fact-checking organizations. Look it up for yourself.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y ago> Well, that's ridiculously easy on Twitter. Just follow them. I was responding to the GP "We have no obligation to allow them to use social networks for propaganda purposes." > Twitter recently published their rules for fact-checking Didn't find anything, care to link it? I hope it's not PolitiFact
- billions 7y agoVia downvotes HN is making sure your opinion is invalid
- brlewis 7y ago> Press releases are preferable because when they tell falsehoods, they can be fact checked in the press. I would question whether social media posts are immune to fact checking, but you didn't post an official press release, so apparently I can't.
- ctdonath 7y agoThe fact checkers are too often biased/liars/propagandists. I want to hear what someone has to say. As an adult I don’t need someone to translate a tweet for me, nor protect me from its contents. Most media is propaganda today; Twitter is the closest to live news we have, and @Jack is eager to end that too.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIf you think Twitter is informative and actual news is all fake news I invite you to in depth fact check 10 pages of news stories and 10 pages of your favorite tweets and tell us how it goes. Blog about what you learn even.
- ctdonath 7y agoAh, the “absurd absolute” tell.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWhich fact checkers and news organizations do you think are liars?
- pdonis 7y ago> If you think Twitter is informative and actual news is all fake news That's not what he said. He said he wants to see what people say directly, not filtered through anyone else. Then he can decide for himself what is informative and what is fake news. I feel the same way.
- michaelmrose 7y agoYou are yourself a filter as is every useful aspect of human civilization. A tiny fraction of the sensory data around you becomes your perceptions a microscopic portion thereof is communicated to other people. We filter for quality and 90% of everything is crap or noise. One wouldn't learn physics by seeing what the entire human race had to say on the subject because virtually the whole of humanity knows next to nothing on the topic. We instead filter it by people that are known to be knowledgeable on the topic. People that are paid to teach it, people that work in relevant fields, people that have published papers in journals that themselves act as filters. When people say they prefer twitter it is because given the entire population of users its trivial for any person to find people who reinforce what they already think no matter how silly. If you believe the flat world was farted out by a goat there are fellow goat worshipers that will by happy to make you feel good by expounding on the topic.
- m0zg 7y ago>> That sounds awfully naive to me. but then >> fact checked in the press Now _that_ sounds awfully naive to me. Have you seen the CNN leak that came out the other day? "If Jeff Zucker wants impeachment, there's nothing you can do" - direct quote from a CNN media coordinator. Zucker literally tells everyone to bash Trump all day on the daily 9AM conference call. The "press" isn't there to do journalism anymore.
- metalliqaz 7y agoThe world doesn't revolve around cable television. Pick up a newspaper.
- m0zg 7y agoYou think newspapers are any different?
- lm28469 7y agoThat, and since politics became social media's plague I don't feel like things improved at all. Now everyone is living in their small make belief bubble at either end of the political spectrum, completely isolated from any kind of meaningful discussions, it breeds mob mentality, hate and conflicts. I don't need to see Trump's idiotic personal attacks on other world leaders or AOC twitting insipid things like "Tax the rich." to farm virtual internet points, all of it is 100% meaningless and has 0 political interest. It's world politics, not a reddit thread were everyone talks about his favorite marvel superhero for fuck's sake. Just have a look at any of Trump's twit comments, it looks like a parody. We're not that far from "Rich men bad", "Criminal bad", "Tax bad", "Wall good", "Terrorist bad", "Health good": it's level 0 of politics and not too far from level 0 of communication.
- dmix 7y agoDeleting things off the source websites has always been overrated as a solution to problems. Its just the easiest, most local ‘solution’ around so naturally people gravitate to it.
- RugnirViking 7y ago"But I absolutely want and need to know what they're saying." So follow them. You'll get everything they say delivered right to you, same as before.
- rjkennedy98 7y agoTwitter is not an RSS feed. Twitter shadow-bans, sorts the tweets based on popularity, ect. Stopping retweets will absolutely affect your ability to see a tweet.
- RugnirViking 7y agoIf you follow somebody, does it ever not show you their tweet? I'm genuinely curious to hear more about their system.
- jki275 7y agoAbsolutely.
- namirez 7y agoDoes Twitter shadow-ban people whom you're following? I thought that's only for accounts that one is not following.
- MBCook 7y agoUse a 3rd party client like god intended.
- mixedCase 7y agoThe ones that you use Twitter's own site and/or gimped APIs?
- sixstringtheory 7y agoHaven't used Twitter for a year or so now, but last I checked, if you use their Lists instead of the main feed, then tweets are still ordered reverse-chronologically. But in general, agree with your sentiment.
- invalidOrTaken 7y agoOne of the most valuable aspects of social media, especially Twitter, has been that it is not media, in the sense of a middleman---it has served as a dumb pipe, or at least more so than newspapers, TV, etc.
- bradhe 7y ago> A platform that provides a direct way for them to speak shouldn't be interfering with that. The majority of Donald Trump's power is derived from his ability to say anything he wants (and have his crazy base eat it up). If we took that away from him he would be terribly crippled in what he could do. It seems to me we're really just giving them a platform to abuse.
- noelsusman 7y agoIt's hard to describe how little I'm worried about the US President's ability to speak and have people hear what they have to say.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oconnor663 7y agoIt sounds like that's exactly the concern that motivated Twitter to have this policy. Some politicians are using Twitter in ways that would get normal users banned. But there's a public interest in letting them say what they're going to say. So Twitter lets them stay on the platform, and this policy is about minimizing the fallout damage from that.
- r00fus 7y agoThat those leaders choose to a) not inform us of massive government policy decisions except by tweet and b) this has geopolitical impacts is a pretty tough issue. If/when the "leader of the free world" decides not to use Twitter (or make that a subordinate communication channel), things will become normal again. Right now it's a race to the bottom.
- hinkley 7y agoIn the west it is not my responsibility as a business owner to bow to the whims of public figures for free. I might make allowances on the grounds of free advertising, but there's going to be plenty of quid pro quo in the process. I am sure as fuck not going to do anything just because they told me to do it. If you want to throw your weight around you can do it officially. And just so we're clear, I'd include people I personally voted for in this. That's not enough reason to set precedents like that.
- intopieces 7y agoRetweeting is not the same as tweeting.
- pkmatador 7y agoGood deduction, Sherlock!
- DonHopkins 7y agoTrump has a taxpayer supported press secretary. The fact that he no longer has any daily press briefings is on him, not something Twitter is required to make up for.