8 ms·
It would be nice to at least see some hazy consideration of the impact of this. I know a probation officer for sex offenders and she tells me trying to keep up
by wpietri 7y ago
It would be nice to at least see some hazy consideration of the impact of this. I know a probation officer for sex offenders and she tells me trying to keep up with their technology use is a nightmare. I can only imagine how this complicates her job.
That's not saying that on balance this shouldn't exist. There are of course good uses of technology like this. But I'd at least like to see builders grappling with that balance. Especially given recent prominent reporting around this: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-abuse.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-...
- faissaloo 7y agoFredrick Brennan calls this the "Pedo Problem", whenever you create a free space for people, pedophiles will flock to it.
- commandlinefan 7y agoGot to be honest, that was my first thought - if anybody actually comes up with something that's actually anonymous and actually uncensorable, it will be shut down, by whatever means necessary, by the government with the full blessing and support of the public.
- fishtacos 7y agoThe Tor network hasn't been shut down, has it? Dark sites of all types still continue to run uninhibited for the most part. From my readings, the major or at least known/researched security holes have been plugged already by the developers, and the rest of convictions have happened because of user error, not the technology involved. If memory serves me correctly, one particular pedophile abuser was caught after years of being investigated because he was identified through skin marks (I want to say it was freckles on his hand, though I don't recall the exact details of the article) that led investigators to him, not anything technological. I'm a proponent of total anonymity online because it allows for whistleblowers to leak information that is untraceable to them (again, without consideration of human error). In the case of Wikileaks, for example, even though they weren't on an anonymous network, it still led to the largest classified information leaks known, from NSA tools to national and international communications between heads of states, diplomats and everyone in between. The general consensus was that it was a good thing. I don't necessarily agree with that, but one can't discount its value.
- newguy1234 7y agoThere was a large bust of a pedophile forum years back. Police took over the site and run it for years and it was ran on TOR. Pretty interesting story overall: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/jul/13/shining-a-light-on-the-dark-web-how-the-police-ended-up-running-a-paedophile-site https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/jul/13/shining-a-li... From what I recall, most of these TOR sites are only taken offline because of some server misconfiguration or some other opsec weakness in the people who run these sites.
- geggam 7y agoThe interesting part about that to me is the authorities seem to break the law with impunity under the guise of enforcing the law. Seems a bit disingenuous to do this. Why not sell drugs as a cop to arrest people for buying them... er wait... they do that too.
- MS90 7y agoIf they just shut down the site, those who weren't busted would just migrate to a new one. If you run the site under the guise of the owners, you can keep catching more and more users as they come in. Not just the people who are seeking the kids, but possibly also the ones supplying them. It's a grander version of the old trope of an FBI agent posing as a 14 year old girl in a chat room to nab a predator. I agree with you that selling a dimebag to a teenager to bust them is shitty and shouldn't be done. But there's a world of difference between busting kids for weed and catching pedophiles. If they're taking these people off the streets I really do not care if they're "disingenuous" to get them.
- geggam 7y agoYou should care and at some point you will. When you let the rules slip eventually that slippage will be used against you. History shows this... First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
- leetcrew 7y agoI'm not so sure. .onion sites are already close to anonymous and uncensorable. the people who do illegal stuff on the darknet seem to get caught because of personal mistakes much more often than a vulnerability of the medium itself. even if you had some perfectly anonymous, uncensorable medium with zero security flaws, people would still make mistakes and get caught. it's never impossible for the state to catch someone, but it can certainly be too expensive to be worth it. this is a feature imo, not a bug. it should be expensive to investigate people.
- rsync 7y ago" ... if anybody actually comes up with something that's actually anonymous and actually uncensorable, it will be shut down, by whatever means necessary, by the government ..." This is correct. However, the building blocks of circumvention technologies (et. al) and the building blocks of basic consumer Internet services and communications channels are indistinguishable. You can't preemptively disable secure, covert communications and also provide rich, secure Internet services (such as banking, corporate email, etc.) It is very much "Free Speech or Stone Age".[1] [1] https://blog.kozubik.com/john_kozubik/2009/06/free-speech-or-stone-age.html https://blog.kozubik.com/john_kozubik/2009/06/free-speech-or...
- dependenttypes 7y agoYou do not need covert communications for things like banking or corporate email. You only need a safe way to perform authentication.
- rsync 7y ago"You do not need covert communications for things like banking or corporate email. You only need a safe way to perform authentication." Agreed. However, the building blocks of that authentication (and other security protocols involved) are the same building blocks used for covert communications.
- Darth_Hobo 7y agoIt already exist and called freenet. If you read the arrest cases for freenet - they are almost non-existent.
- newguy1234 7y agoSome people use cars to crash into large crowds of people on purpose. Should automakers implement devices to make sure the cars can't be misused? The reality is everything can be misused.
- TuringTest 7y agoThere are circulation codes and policemen watching the roads, trying to reduce reckless behaviour. How do you police and bring down misuse of onion sites for hideous crimes?
- newguy1234 7y agoYou just infiltrate the site and use social engineering to hack it. TOR site does not stop police from investigating and catching the people running the site.
- leetcrew 7y agono one employs perfect opsec at all times and all it takes is one small mistake. ross ulbricht (sill road guy) caught caught because of one silly forum post that linked his two identities.
- whiddershins 7y agoWell, for one thing, in order for the hideous crime to have real world impact it needs to by definition exist somewhere beyond just the onion site. Otherwise it literally just is information.
- JoeSmithson 7y agoInformation can be harmful. For example, people who were raped as a child do not want footage of that rape distributed as a masturbation aid, and yet numerous dark web sites are dedicated to exactly this.
- dependenttypes 7y ago
- noelsusman 7y agoThere is a fundamental, irreconcilable tension between the need for people to be able to protect themselves against abusive governments and the need for governments to be able to catch criminals. While it seems good to consider the full impact of anonymity, it's not going to generate any meaningful discussion. You can either be anonymous online or you can't. There isn't much middle ground there. There is no balance that can exist.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>There is a fundamental, irreconcilable tension between the need for people to be able to protect themselves against abusive governments and the need for governments to be able to catch criminals. Aren't these the same thing to the technology? To someone labeled a criminal, the government doing so is an abusive government. To a government that considers itself right, those who don't follow the rules are criminals. We each have our own personal views on what should and should not be allowed which we judge individual cases with, but technology does not have a sense of morality to make such judgment as to when the criminal is in the right and when the government is in the right. I think people far too often try to humanize computer algorithms with notions of right and wrong. The technology to avoid and oppressive regime is the exact same technology that protects the horrible person from justice.
- wpietri 7y agoIf that's truly the case, I'd like to see the developer grapple with that. However, I don't think that's the case at all. We can see in the real world there are many ways to strike a balance between safety and privacy.
- luckylion 7y ago> We can see in the real world there are many ways to strike a balance between safety and privacy. So how would this work online? "We have private chats, but the government can look into any of them at any time"? I suppose it depends on your definition of privacy ... are your chats still private if I'm unable to see them but your friendly neighborhood police department reads them?
- JTbane 7y agoLaw enforcement will always chafe at the chains of privacy. Hell, if the police could read your thoughts, they would.
- projektfu 7y agoMake a list of allowed technology items. Any internet connection out of the house must go through the specified router, which monitors traffic and proxies SSL/SSH to allow monitoring. Only allow a phone that the probation officer controls. Any attempt to tamper is a violation.
- spinach 7y agoI guess it makes sense in countries that have a authoritarian government to be able to subvert it, but in others it's hard to reason why a person should be totally able to untether themselves from meatspace and not be held culpable for their actions. That article on child sex abuse is absolutely sickening. (It's terrifying how common child abuse/pedophilia is)
- hnaccy 7y agoWhat country doesn't have an authoritarian government?
- matheusmoreira 7y agoIt's a politico-technological arms race. Governments make laws. People make technology that nullifies those laws. The government reacts and makes laws that circumvent the technology. People make even more technology to deal with the new laws. This can end in one of two ways: 1. Subversive technology becomes so ubiquitous and easy to use it's impossible to fight it. The government stops trying. 2. The government's control increases to the point of tyranny and people are no longer free. I want the government to give up. Anything else will mean the destruction of the free internet and free computing we all enjoy today. I don't want a future where encryption is military use only because of laws that make it impossible to run code not signed by the government. > But I'd at least like to see builders grappling with that balance. There is no balance to be had. The internet contains the full spectrum of humanity. The very best and the very worst of humanity are both be found on the internet. The governments were oblivious for a while but now they want to narrow down the spectrum. As they impose laws and exercise control, the internet becomes safer but it also becomes less international and more regional. The flow of information is no longer free and unrestricted. The spectrum is narrowed down from both sides. Sadly it will only get worse from here. I am happy to have enjoyed the internet while it was in its infancy, and I am sad that future generations will probably never experience it. > Especially given recent prominent reporting around this: Every article about encryption regulation is like this. Pedophiles and terrorists. Children in particular are the perfect political weapon. The exploitation of children provokes reactions in people that are so visceral they are ready to accept any law that would supposedly make it stop. Anything can be justified with these arguments and anyone who disagrees is labeled a pedophile apologist and instantly shunned.
- dependenttypes 7y ago> and she tells me trying to keep up with their technology use is a nightmare This sounds like a good thing. It might come as a surprice but a lot of people in the sex offenders registry are there for victimless crimes (such as sending nude pictures of themselves when they were underage - consider https://metro.co.uk/2019/06/27/boy-15-made-sign-sex-offenders-register-girl-15-swapped-nude-photos-10082969/ https://metro.co.uk/2019/06/27/boy-15-made-sign-sex-offender... as an example of the >10 instances in news reports that I have read of such situation). The probation officer being unable to keep up with the technology that these people use will guarantee them similar levels of privacy that people like you and me have. > https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-abuse.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-... Just an offtopic note, this site is painful to read (on the desktop at least). Whatever happened to simple text sites?
- Darth_Hobo 7y agoIf you are that worried about children you should think about inventing new ways to monitor children, so that it becomes impossible to do something to a child without a lot of people knowing about it. Instead of trying to find excuses to spy on everyone on the internet.