3 ms·
Why do people have to register to vote at all? The state has a sort of pretty solid idea of where they live...
by maxerickson 7y ago
Why do people have to register to vote at all?
The state has a sort of pretty solid idea of where they live...
- aaronbrethorst 7y agoTo make it more difficult for prospective voters who are perhaps not white, poorer, younger, are working multiple jobs, or are a single parent, just to name a few examples. You can connect the dots on why groups like these are disenfranchised by the state.
- awayfromhomenow 7y agoThat's a pretty strong allegation over something that is free. Voter registration costs the person registering nothing but time, and states make it as easy as possible to register. Anyone wanting to vote can register.
- ahbyb 7y agoMy favourite conspiracy: you only know you have to register to vote if you are white.
- crooked-v 7y agoThat's not what the comment you're responding to said.
- scrooched_moose 7y agoNot really. You can easily move without informing the new state. Millions of college students do it every year. The last move I made was in September so I hadn't changed licenses or filed income taxes yet, so they had no awareness of me yet. Luckily I'm in a fairly permissive state and was able to register with a couple utility bills without any hassle. Some sort of voter registration is a necessity when you can move 3000 miles in a weekend. Unfortunately it's often used to disenfranchise voters, but a significant subset of the population does not have up-to-date records. Registration is a way to fix that.
- maxerickson 7y agoSo the utility bills are sufficient to jump through the hoops before the fact but not at the time of voting?
- swsieber 7y agoYou can still do it automatically for a majority of voters though. Having to register should be the exception, not the norm.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNot everyone is eligible to vote. Heck, I had to correct my wife’s driver license application because she definitely isn’t a citizen, and the question was phrased to be very confusing....
- tathougies 7y agoSure, it's done automatically when you apply for a driver's license or change your registration, by the Motor Voter Act. Registering to vote is incredibly easy if you keep your state documents up-to-date. We just moved states. When we got our driver's license, we checked a box to change our voting record. We received in the next week a letter from our old county asking us if we did indeed move and if we should be removed from their voter roll, as well as a letter from our new county informing us we will be voting there from now on. But... driver's licenses or state IDs aren't the end all be all. If I keep real property in another state, I could potentially qualify for a license or state ID there as well, but that state would not be my main residence and I could not be a citizen of that state unless I actually intended to move there permanently. If I lived a more transient life, I would be able to freely choose which state I wanted to be a citizen of. Like if I spend 73 days exactly in each of five states and received mail there, then I would be able to choose which state to register in. There's no way for states to know or to control my movement without imposing arbitrary and illegal restrictions.
- wingspar 7y agoOne purpose for registration is to lock the person into voting in a particular district. Why? Ballots can and do vary by district. Different districts have different representatives (on both state, county and town/city level) Different districts have votes for different issues (state amendments, county amendments, town/city amendments) Different districts have different local offices (county officers vs city/town officers) Registering also locks a person into voting only once.
- maxerickson 7y agoYou are arguing from presumption of massive fraud. There's barely any fraud. It's sort of ridiculous that some of your rejoinders are basic civics.
- tathougies 7y agoBecause if you own ten houses in ten states, you only get to vote in one state, despite potentially being in residence in nine other states at various points of time. There are various criteria by which you qualify as being a citizen of exactly one state.
- maxerickson 7y agoRight, but there's literally no good reason this has to be an a priori process anymore. We could easily have a system where you get to vote once in one place where you are eligible without having any preregistration.
- tathougies 7y agoSure. Try getting 50 sovereign states to agree and get back to me. Its not like the federal government has any authority to decide how the states run an election