9 ms·
I wonder if anyone here has seen any net new adoption of Oracle DBs in the last few years? It was an absolute juggernaut 10-15 years ago and has rapidly tanked
by tootie 7y ago
I wonder if anyone here has seen any net new adoption of Oracle DBs in the last few years? It was an absolute juggernaut 10-15 years ago and has rapidly tanked their reputation and spread their business across software, services and cloud with mixed results. Is it actually still growing or just milking their stodgy enterprise customers for more money?
- rossdavidh 7y agoI think that not very many existing customers of Oracle migrate off, but I have to think that they are no longer the default for new and growing businesses to move into. AWS seems to have become that, with Oracle not even the second-most likely option (that would probably be Google or Microsoft). Having said that, Oracle is probably the COBOL of databases, in that it will still be around (collecting good $$) from its existing customers for a long, long time.
- mxschumacher 7y agoI believe the business model is that it is near impossible to leave the ecosystem (this is also how SAP can still thrive). It takes a lot of money and expertise to make the migration happen. Few companies have scaling problems as pronounced as Amazon and as much of a vested interest in migrating to their own custom solutions.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoSAP survives because it's good and handles a lot of business cases. I still hear implementations. I don't hear implementations of Oracle.
- bluejekyll 7y agoWhen they threaten you with lawsuits for using their software, and make their pricing completely opaque so you don’t really know what you owe (Comcast style), why would you knowingly choose that? Postgres is pretty darn good these days. I still love Java, but I won’t be surprised if that language becomes a business risk because of Oracle’s behavior in other spaces.
- onefuncman 7y agoYou must have missed the Amazon Corretto announcement— there’s an Amazon JDK now.
- bluejekyll 7y agoMy guess is that like they did with Google, with time, Oracle will go after all the OpenJDK derivatives. To be clear the licensing appears to be open enough so that this shouldn’t be a real threat, but IANAL.
- briffle 7y agoI'm sure it will be priced at just below the cost in legal fees to defend yourself..
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 7y agoCoretto passes TCK (as well as RedHat and Zulu, amongst others out there), there's nothing to sue for.
- tsimionescu 7y agoGoogle did not have an OpenJDK alternative, they had a implementation of a language and stdlib that was 99% identical to Java.
- vbezhenar 7y agoOracle owns Java. Amazon just builds its own version.
- GetOutOfBed 7y ago> Postgres Yes, maybe there will be built in automatic fail over in a few years so you don't have to hack it together using a bunch of scripts. Of course there's overlap in functionality and most companies should probably chose PG over Oracle. But PG is a joke in some areas like the above mentioned.
- 7y ago
- thrower123 7y agoOracle is slashing positions in a lot of their sales divisions. There was a large layoff this spring/summer, and from what I can tell from contacts that were there, anyone who can is jumping ship to AWS or other competitors, and poaching as many of their old customers with them as they can.
- drawkbox 7y agoIn 2001/2003, I led a small team at an agency that converted Kraftfoods and 50+ brands from 25+ ATG Dynamo web/app CMS servers + 20+ Oracle servers to .NET 1.0 CMS on 3 web servers, 3 app servers and 3 Microsoft SQL Servers. Even then Oracle tools were horrible for developers and still are. The only reason they had that many databases was Oracle's business is licensing, massive, expensive licenses, and their sales pushed them sold through upper management. Those days are almost over, developers choose the tech, the cloud is here. Without Tom [1], Oracle was basically not even a great developer community, all documentation was bad and the Java interfaces on the tools / management studio were horrendous. Oracle is fast but for most things on the web caching comes into play heavily and other databases are good enough. Oracle is good for large datasets/reporting, cursors are extremely fast when Oracle is tuned, the problem is it is like vehicle that needs tuning and optimization all the time or it drives bad. The cost and upkeep make Oracle mostly overkill and too painful. Ellison laughed at the cloud like Ballmer laughed at the iPhone. That was a major error. But ultimately Ellison is an engineer that forgot to make sure developers like to use the product. That will ultimately be their fatal flaw as now the developers choose the tools not what is sold in above them. All other platforms are developer centric and cloud first now. Oracle the all seeing one says the end is nigh for Oracle the database. No new projects will be using it without force. Too bad Oracle also owns MySQL, Java etc. I really wish someone else had bought Sun. [1] https://asktom.oracle.com https://asktom.oracle.com
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoOracle's new licensing requirement for Java is a bit threat to that platform. My company for technical reasons can't switch to OpenJVM so we're going to pay Oracle their new licensing money but we're not doing any greenfield Java development and are going to work towards moving our Java applications to another platform. That's an n=1 example but wouldn't be surprised if others end up migrating away, causing longterm harm to Java.
- danbtl 7y agoI'm curious, what are the technical reasons OpenJVM won't work for you?
- binarymax 7y agoI’m interested in seeing how much they try to milk Java in the next 10 years. I can see them getting desperate enough to really bring the hammer down on licensing, killing off openjdk, and making life miserable for everyone in the process.
- y4mi 7y agoHow? Its an Open source implementation of the java vm which they don't own.
- fiddlerwoaroof 7y agoDon’t they claim some sort of copyright on the APIs and also restrict what can be called “Java”?
- binarymax 7y agoThere are a couple ways they are trying to do this. They’re actively fighting the court battle vs Google for copyright of the Java api. They’re also adding more features to Java that are only supported in new versions, and they can/will attempt licensing lock in for those features. OpenJDK might survive as permanently stuck in version 8, or it might survive as a fork which will divide the community.
- dastbe 7y agoOpenJDK is not stuck on 8, and is where all language development goes.
- BoyRobot777 7y agoExcept the opposite is happening lol: - Contributes pretty much all of the closed source technologies (or what was originally to become closed source) of the Oracle JDK to OpenJDK, for example giving the community: JDK Flight Recorder; JDK Mission Control; ZGC; …and probably more stuff I can’t think of right now; - Ensures the Oracle JDK and the OpenJDK builds are virtually indistinguishable; - Starts providing a free OpenJDK build (which includes all these donated technologies); - Provides uncountable man hours of maintaining and innovating the Java platform; - Ensures that the community knows where to find the free bits by linking to them, and slaps on a bright yellow warning sign, so that everyone can see that the licensing has changed; Some bits do not even make sense: >OpenJDK might survive as permanently stuck in version 8 ??? Wat?
- solatic 7y agoI can imagine that there are more than a few Oracle customers whose spend increases year-over-year because: 1) they have significant investment in the human capital side of Oracle, which is to say, Oracle DBAs on staff who are highly capable at keeping the lights on for their Oracle databases, but have little or no familiarity with alternatives 2) enterprise architects are required to get approval from their DBAs for the design of new systems, who won't approve non-Oracle databases that they can't support, so new systems get built with new Oracle databases 3) the financial cost of the additional databases is organizationally far enough removed from the design phase that Finance has no real power to say no, and anyway such enterprises have other areas of the business that are far more bloated grabbing Finance's attention, where the cost of additional Oracle licenses is a rounding error by comparison 4) Anybody at a high enough level to see why this is a problem has far bigger problems to deal with and so the situation persists. I doubt that apathetic enterprises are enough to make Oracle database a growth center overall when nobody in their right mind adopts it for new companies, but I doubt that all of their customers are looking for a migration exit.
- fdjlasdfjl 7y ago#2 is my life. AWS is cheaper overall but that transition takes a ton of cash, because you have to pay the DBAs AND Oracle AND Amazon until you can transition to AWS (or Azure).
- matchagaucho 7y agoOften it's the apps, like eBiz Suite, that drive the net-new adoption of the underlying DB. The large Accounting firms handle 80% of the financial audits of Fortune 500 corporations. They are used to walking up to Oracle DBs and extracting the reports needed for compliance and reporting. If they have to learn a new ERP or proprietary Accounting system, then the T&M costs can mount.
- abraae 7y agoWe started a new SaaS company last year. We use Java + Oracle from the get go. Last company was very reliant on Oracle, we ran the entire business on a single Oracle instance for a couple of decades. We had our share of adventures, but over the years never lost a minute's worth of data despite server, hard drive and other issues. We've also had a few scary performance problems, but have always been able to tune the DB to get past them. And once or twice, we've been in a dark place where you are googling for cryptic error codes, and we've always come through. That's a lot of business and millions of dollars earned through having a very reliable database underneath. For us, the cost equation is whether it's worth learning a new DB. It's not. If you can run your business on a single instance, then on AWS, it's cheaper to stick with what you know than to try and move to a new DB for a few K of saved licence fees. What's more, using Oracle is a good answer when the PHBs at our customers ask about our stack. No one ever got fired for using Oracle. So yes, it certainly makes sense to use Oracle for new projects if you are already Oracle experts. Java is somewhat the same equation as well ;)
- joncrane 7y ago>No one ever got fired for using Oracle. Yet.
- arpinum 7y agoOne area of growth - Accidental Oracle customers. Oracle makes software acquisitions and bases the new version of the product on Oracle DB. Customers are forced to upgrade and take on an Oracle DB, or get a firm push into the Oracle cloud.