14 ms·
A lot of my teachers... and one of my parents... made this mistake with me. "You're so smart, why are you unable to do X ??". Which only made me feel as if I wa
by dragontamer 7y ago
A lot of my teachers... and one of my parents... made this mistake with me. "You're so smart, why are you unable to do X ??". Which only made me feel as if I was dumb.
Obviously, my teachers and parents were raising me the best they thought was possible, but I think they were mistaken with this strategy.
I read a blogpost that really spoke to me: NEVER tell a child that they are smart, or dumb. Frankly, it doesn't matter. If they are unable to do X, tell them "You are unable to do X", no if-and-or-buts about it. Tell them you expect them to be able to do X, but in a way that doesn't bring up "intelligence" or "general performance".
Its something I strive for with the next generation: my little cousins or nephews (no kids of my own yet) will be told what my expectations of them are, but I try to avoid the "intelligence trap" when talking with them.
- K0SM0S 7y agoYou're totally right. "Mindset" by Dr Carol Dweck is probably the most important book (research) on this topic. A must-read for anyone pretending to educate kids, actually to anyone period.
- Kaveren 7y agofunny you say that because growth mindset seems to be one of the clearest examples of modern feel-good science. invariably when a topic about intelligence gets posted we need someone to come around with an IQ around the 140 mark (I have no reason to doubt they are being honest fwiw) to tell us how because they personally failed, genetic intelligence is really unimportant (smarter rebuttals acknowledge that genetics plays a major role in intelligence, but that IQ is a really poor proxy of this, which is debatable). this ultimately culminates in Almost Everyone Can Be Good At Almost Everything If They Try Hard With A Good Minset, The Growth Mindset. the science is weak. it's baffling how her book can be a "must-read". https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/08/no-clarity-around-growth-mindset-yet/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/04/08/no-clarity-around-grow... https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/05/07/growth-mindset-4-growth-of-office/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/05/07/growth-mindset-4-growt... https://www.buzzfeed.com/tomchivers/what-is-your-mindset https://www.buzzfeed.com/tomchivers/what-is-your-mindset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carol_Dweck#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carol_Dweck#Criticism edit: this article only addresses MENSA members, so i think this submission is bad. most well-adjusted intelligent people want nothing to do with MENSA. so even the claims of the submission are questionable.
- kick 7y agoCredible sources, please? Buzzfeed and a Wordpress blog don't lend much credence.
- Kaveren 7y agojudge the articles based on their merits. they're not hiding their sources, you can go check the study of 5,000 british students if you want to read it yourself. ironic because you'd think that if buzzfeed was as bad as its reputation, being a left-leaning outlet, it would be reasonable to assume they'd be in favor of growth mindset.
- rjf72 7y agoImagine two worlds. In one world all people are completely and absolutely identical and unable to change themselves in any meaningful way. In the other world people are all completely identical, but able to radically reshape themselves as they see fit. In one world an individuals actions and decisions would largely determine their outcome. In the other world things completely outside of an individual's control would be the primary determining factors in their outcome. One of these worlds would imply the need for systems directly subsidizing those who fail to achieve. In the other world, poor outcomes would be attributable in large part to poor decisions. The latter scenario doesn't necessarily preclude a subsidization of those who fail to succeed, but it makes it a much more tenuous proposition.
- concordDance 7y agoOddly enough, slatestarcodex is considered a highly reputable source. I reccommend checking the sources given in the blog post.
- K0SM0S 7y agoI had no idea the book was so much of a "thing", its name and principles are basically inexistent here (France and nearby countries). People either feel they "are" smart or not, and believe it's forever. More strikingly it's about logical intelligence (IQ), as if that was the major deciding factor for success (it's really not). Hence why I always try to mention Dr Dweck (especially for kids). I trust you've done your research so this isn't a rebuttal — merely a surprised observation. You probably have too much of it in the US (and indeed too much of even a good thing can hurt) whereas we have way too little of it in the EU (at least the "Latin" world). 100% agreed on Mensa (we don't have that here but even I know it's almost a scam).
- anon1m0us 7y agoYou weren't dumb, you were ignorant and ignorance can be overcome and more likely so if you are high IQ. In asking, "why can't you do x?" what they were really saying was, "I know this child has the capacity to understand this material but I don't have the power to help them do that." It wasn't about you. It was about them. Children don't understand that. Children internalize everything. They blame themselves and you blamed yourself.
- chrisco255 7y agoI would say that compliments can cut both ways. If a gifted student or child is encouraged in a productive way it can have a magnifying effect on outcomes but I think that has to be balanced with the understanding that social, emotional, and physical skills are completely orthogonal. Work ethic is also completely orthogonal. But you know, we do this too with other natural gifts. My exceptionally tall friends were constantly encouraged to enter sports like basketball. Tall people are built up emotionally through compliments that they receive on a daily basis from people. I would say it's not necessarily bad to compliment smart people for being smart. I was a short scrawny kid growing up and I was bullied but I definitely took solace in the fact that I had a higher IQ than most people.
- Infernal 7y agoAnecdote is not the singular of data and all that, but I am exceptionally tall as well (would be in at least the top third or so of most NBA rosters) and yet was not encouraged to play sports as a child, largely due to my anxiety exacerbated at least somewhat by not having any extra money for luxuries like joining sports teams. That is to say, I fucking hate having to say "no" every time (and it happens at least once every couple weeks) I am asked if or where I played basketball. I'm also somewhere around 3 std dev above average IQ (mid 130s if I look at SAT equivalents, ~150 if GRE) and experienced the "but you're so good at school, why don't you like it" stuff. In both cases, physical and... mental feels wrong, but it's the best word I've got, I feel as though I have wasted huge gifts. I don't take solace in any of it. And since I'm full of anecdotes tonight, your bullying comment made me remember another. I had a target on my back for bullying due to my size I believe, everyone wanted to take a shot. I once got gang tackled by about 5/6 football players when I was 16 - the resultant slamming of my right knee into the tile floor means it will be my "trick" knee for the rest of my life. So, the size didn't give me a pass - if anything it made me stand out more. YMMV and all that.
- chrisco255 7y agoNobody asks me if I play any sports at all, ever. Because I have unremarkable physical traits. A lot of people will just stream their consciousness in the case that they observe a trait that they wish they had. It's a projection, but it's also a tell. Is it the anxiety that makes you feel wrong for receiving compliments?
- xattt 7y agoThe use of language extends beyond smart/dumb and includes concepts of good/bad. I found that a lot of concepts of child-rearing overlaps with management, but with different labels. My grad-level Nursing Ethics class discussed qualities of a nursing leader, that employees need to made to feel personal worth. I made the link with ideas expressed by Mr. Rogers and on Sesame Street.
- caconym_ 7y agoI never got my IQ tested or if I did I never learned the result or didn't care enough to remember it, but I did pretty well on standardized tests (e.g. great scores on SAT and ACT with no prep) and people were always saying I was smart. Usually it was something like this: I was obviously capable of doing the work, so why didn't I? I was an absolutely abysmal student all the way through college, though I did graduate. To be honest I have been pretty successful despite that, but I don't feel like I'm as smart as people were always trying to convince me I was, or at least I have a different sort of intelligence from the sort of thing they were implying, and I definitely have a complex now where I don't like to expose myself to failure. I guess there was not much else to praise about me except for my apparent general intelligence, but I wish they'd come up with something. I was, I think, a friendly, creative, thoughtful kid? But that's not enough, is it?
- thebigspacefuck 7y agoYou probably have ADHD. You should look into it, it might help you understand yourself.
- bnjms 7y agoThat's a good thought. ADHD's an executive function failure and does not necessarily come with hyperactivity.
- 3c22594668b 7y agoThis thread made me think. Some of the symptoms of ADD seem to describe much of my behavior to a shocking precision, mostly lack of executive function. But I wasn't hyperactive so I wasn't sure it applied to me. Still, I lose track of time when working on projects I enjoy. That doesn't even invalidate the progress I make on them, but the act of me deciding to work on them on a whim and forgetting everything else until I'm too tired to go on is a very common occurrence for me. At a young age my parents were told by someone I did not have AD(H)D. I believed them. But later when I was living on my own I felt his methodology lacked credibility. (He was a person who called his treatment "turbo-drive psychotherapy" and dismissed questions about its effectiveness, calling them "pooh-poohing the next generation of technology". Not really someone who would want to hold an intellectual dialogue). Looking back on it in the present I realized that if my parents were going to tell me I was or wasn't X or Y at that age, I was going to believe them - for as long as they were physically around to assert it. It had always felt wrong to disagree. For various reasons I had internalized that argument was not a means to find truth but instead an unreasonable risk when you could be locked in a closet for it. I'm not sure what being diagnosed today would do for me since it wouldn't change any of that. Though it could give some more clarity to my past.
- gleenn 7y agoI'd like to add to not saying "you're so smart," you should say "wow it looks like you worked really hard at that." Makes the kid realize that's what's important, the effort.
- chrisco255 7y agoBut is it the case in life that effort is always rewarded? No. Look you can invest an incredible amount of effort into constructing a bridge. If it collapses and kills people, nobody cares about how much effort went into it. It was a faulty design. Human civilization is advanced by working smarter, not harder.
- dragontamer 7y agoI disagree on "effort counts". In practice and in the work place, the only thing that matters is if you get your work done or not. You can spend a lot of effort on things and get almost nothing done... I know programmers who spent 2+ years on custom unit-testing solutions (and I guess management never noticed this guy was spinning his wheels on something that has been solved in multiple github projects or something...) Just because he put a lot of work in doesn't mean that other engineers respected his work or even he got anything done. All it means is that he wasted 2-years on the project. That's real life.
- alexbanks 7y agoThis therapist had some interesting methods, most of which I think did me a ton of good. We talked a lot about the fallacies of "motivation" and "discipline", which are both just carrot-sticks people use to beat themselves up for not doing things they don't _really_ want to do, but wish they did. We talked a lot about how literally no one on earth is capable of seeing an understanding your flaws as well as you, but also most humans on earth are infinitely less interested. The lens you view yourself with is totally unrelated to the lens with which the rest of the world sees you; you'll drive yourself insane if you think you and the world interpret you the same. The point is, I think he did a phenomenal job at blasting my self deprecating brain into reality, but his initial spin of "Stop treating yourself like you're an idiot, because you're not and I can prove it" was just a slight misstep.
- Al-Khwarizmi 7y agoAfter reading both of your posts, are you sure it was a misstep? Maybe realizing that you were intelligent did hurt in the short term, but was a necessary step towards improving your attitude in the long term? Obviously I'm just theorizing from my armchair and don't know more than you about this, or want to be agreed with, it's just that your post sparked my interest and I'd like to know more because my hunch is that removing excuses to not change oneself is generally a reasonable thing to do, even if it can hurt in the short term. In fact, it kind of worked for me to improve myself in the past (not regarding intelligence or academic/professional achievements, but other aspects of life). Maybe it depends on the particular person and situation?
- alexbanks 7y agoI'd love to believe it was the right move because I'd love to continue giving this therapist more credit, but I'm not sure. It' might've helped things looking forward, but looking backward I think it wasn't great. As in, "I am so smart and yet thus far have accomplished nothing." So, maybe that's a debt to be paid, and once paid a person is able to move forward at a better trajectory than before? That might make sense to me.
- nicolapede 7y ago
- kordlessagain 7y agoHowever good at a given thing you are probably depends on whether you form custom internal imagery or audio that helps you be better at that thing. Maybe a way to think about it is that analytical thinking can do a lot, but it can't do what someone can do when they are visualizing with imagery, internally. If anyone is into Yoga, or Yogachara, the way they put it is that internal formations (imagination or historic image/sound data/logging ala Parakalpita) represents one type of thinking (which everyone does not necessarily do) and analytical or "thinking mind" represents another type of thinking which everyone does, but may not be their primary mode. From a few of my interviews about this topic: - Old business acquaintance can visualize 2D seismic data in augmented reality 3D. He can literally see underground in his mind in front of him in his office. - Musically inclined acquaintance (singer) can hear all the accompaniment music for performances in her mind. - Guy who designed my kitchen can see my kitchen in his head.
- JohnBooty 7y ago"You're so smart, why are you unable to do X ??". Which only made me feel as if I was dumb. Yeah, I got this a lot. It reflects such an outdated way of thinking about intelligence - that it's just a single number. You can be superintelligent in general, and bad at lots of specific things. Or even bad at most things! It's not a contradiction in the slightest. I think that IQ has become less and less emphasized over the years, and that's a good thing. It has some utility, IMO, but a lot of care needs to be taken when it comes to applying it to... well, anything.
- arethuza 7y agoMy own theory is that really bad decisions often require a degree of intelligence as they are often driven by sheer hubris rather than calm logical thinking.
- mcv 7y agoJust because you're intelligent doesn't mean you're not irrational. Having intelligence is pretty meaningless except in IQ tests and similar puzzles. Applying your intelligence effectively is what it's all about.
- geggam 7y agoHaving intelligence is quite important. Otherwise you have a higher propensity to react with emotions and do irrational things. See : Modern society
- dmwallin 7y agoHaving intelligence in most cases just means you're better at post-hoc justification of your emotionally-driven decisions.
- geggam 7y agoAgreed, however those who arent intelligent repeat the same emotional responses over and over. Intelligence gives you the possibility of changing that, unintelligent dont have that possibility.
- noir_lord 7y agoI have a stepson who is bright like I sure many of us where. I try never to reward results directly, only effort. If the results are reward for effort then they are earns. It too me a decade to undo the damage from always been told I was bright and never learning good habits for studying/persistence. It’s just damn lucky that I enjoyed programming enough that I stuck with it and it became a career because otherwise I’d be earning a lot less.
- rglullis 7y ago> If the results are reward for effort then they are earns. Too much of that "focus on the effort" and you end up with a generation of bureaucrats - people that are good at miming processes and posturing but not capable of producing anything of actual value. Society doesn't care about the efforts, it cares about results. No matter how much neurosurgery you studied, if a patient dies at your table no family member will reward you for your "effort". > It too me a decade to undo the damage from always been told I was bright and never learning good habits for studying/persistence. The issue is not then about being result-vs-effort focus. The issue here is that unfortunately you didn't get people to push you for your best and to get out of your comfort zone.
- jddj 7y ago> Too much of that "focus on the effort" and you end up with a generation of bureaucrats The best things in life typically reward effort spent with incremental results, which come with their own dopamine rush. It's something I wish I had been made to understand at a much earlier age. Here's a short list: - Cooking - Playing an instrument - Singing - Painting - Drawing - Writing - Learning (..a language, a new skill, etc) - Developing and maintaining valuable social and romantic relationships into adulthood - Any and all sports - Crafting - Raising children The goal obviously isn't to maximize effort, it's simply to reinforce the link between effort and results and help the child understand that they can coast off their natural abilities (as we all have/do), but if they want to improve or excel in something that they enjoy then it will take real effort.
- 7y ago
- mcv 7y ago> A lot of my teachers... and one of my parents... made this mistake with me. "You're so smart, why are you unable to do X ??" Maybe I was fortunate that my parents are also smart. My dad once shared that he completely understood that we (his kids) struggled so much with finishing university and finishing the stuff we worked on. He had many of the same problems (though he did finish his PhD). He never managed to teach me that discipline to follow through and get stuff done, though. But at least I wasn't judged and made to feel dumb for it. My oldest son again has the same traits of high intelligence and extreme laziness. I'm trying to teach him better ways to handle this. I try to emphasize the importance of doing the work, doing homework, finishing projects, focus, and sometimes just doing what is necessary whether you like it or not. I try to de-emphasize intelligence without making him feel dumb. He knows he's smart, and he knows it a little too well in my opinion, but I try to praise him for the things he does, rather than for how smart he is. I try to challenge his intelligence, but also try to steer him towards things that aren't about IQ, like art or sports. (He's not interested though; he mostly just wants to play Minecraft and build beautiful houses and complex machinery there. Close enough, I guess.)
- UserIsUnused 7y agoMake sure he has "long" minecraft machinery projects then.