5 ms·
Humans are bad drivers, and countless people die in car crashes every year as a result. The question shouldn’t be whether autonomous cars will kill people, but
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
Humans are bad drivers, and countless people die in car crashes every year as a result.
The question shouldn’t be whether autonomous cars will kill people, but whether they’ll kill more people than human drivers. If they'll kill fewer people, then on net they're saving lives, not "sacrificing" them.
- LIV2 7y agoIf your wife or child got mowed down by an autonomous car would you be thinking "Oh well, that's progress!" Is it ethical to build something knowing it will definitely kill random people until you perfect the technology? Will auto makers be held accountable for any wrongful deaths caused by bugs?
- ryandvm 7y agoProbably not, but are emotional responses the correct criteria for rational decision-making?
- stagger87 7y agoIs there a name for this type of argument? I've seen it a lot with certain types of people, one that ignores any logic from the discussion and uses a sort of trap that makes you appear insensitive if you try to argue it? Is it appeal to pity?
- MPetitt 7y agoFeels like a combo? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/appeal-to-emotion https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/appeal-to-emotion https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/loaded-question https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/loaded-question
- beerandt 7y agoThe good place makes me think it's a version of the trolly problem. IANATOMP.
- ben_w 7y agoA fascinating display of the human mind. If your wife or child was mowed down by a normal car, would you be more supportive of autonomous ones? If your wife or child wasn’t mowed down because the car was autonomous rather than manual (or vice-versa), would you even notice? Yet, which of human or AI drivers get banned by 2040 depends on convincing people like you — assuming I am inferring correctly that your question is rhetorical and the answer is “no, obviously”.
- jakeogh 7y agoThere is no good reason to think pre-programmed computers are going to outperform human drivers when it counts. It's a prediction about the future, someting that has not happened yet. It's most likely wrong. No amount of marketing hype will change that.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI can think of lots of theoretical reasons computers might outperform human drivers. A computer won't get distracted, will have nearly instantaneous reaction times, and can literally have eyes in the back of its head. I don't know if that will be enough to make the difference, but I can certainly see how it could be.
- catalogia 7y ago> "might" You're still making a prediction about the future. Some predictions are safer than others: I predict I will see the sun rise tomorrow. Some predictions have little rational basis in reality: I predict you will agree with me. Your prediction about automomous cars being safer than human drivers? That falls somewhere in the middle. From my perspective, all computer vision systems are abysmal crap and spend orders of magnitude more power to accomplish results many orders of magnitude less impressive than the human brain is capable of. The human brain uses something like 10-20 watts, how much CV/ML can you do with 10-20 watts? Not much at all. There is clearly a huge disconnect between our current approach to solving the problem technologically and how the evolutionary wetware solves the problem. That gap may be bridged sometime in the future, but I'm not holding my breath. I think the problem is being approached from the wrong direction, like trying to drive a screw with a hammer. Maybe we'll still get the job done, but I do not consider that a foregone conclusion.
- mythz 7y agoaka anti-vaxxer logic, anecdotes > real world stats. There are ~1.25 million car deaths per year (20-50 million injured or disabled), a lot of room for "progress" to save countless lives.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> There are ~1.25 million car deaths per year (20-50 million injured or disabled), a lot of room for "progress" to save countless lives. The vast majority of those occur in areas that will not see autonomous vehicles for a very long time, and have a lot of environmental challenges that make it much harder for an autonomous vehicle to outperform a human.
- mythz 7y agoand? it's not worth doing unless every life can be saved? The point is thousands of people die per day at the hands of human drivers. The sooner we can transition to autonomous vehicles, the sooner they'll start saving lives.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> and? it's not worth doing unless every life can be saved? I did not say or imply that. > The point is thousands of people die per day at the hands of human drivers. Yes, and thousands will die every day for quite a long time. You make it sound like autonomous vehicles are going to make a significant dent in that number. > The sooner we can transition to autonomous vehicles, the sooner they'll start saving lives. This is quite true. It will just be limited to lives in developed nations and a few select other major cities.
- throwaway66920 7y agoYou’re stringing together a few questionable statements here. It’s true that the vast majority of cars won’t be autonomous for “a very long time” so the vast majority of deaths won’t be prevented. But what’s your point? That if the vast majority of the problem can’t be addressed quickly it’s not worth exploring? On a quick search, 30% of fatalities involve alcohol. 7% involve rain (the most common condition that causes crashes). Cars don’t actually need to be better than humans, or even as good as the average human. They just need to be better than the bottom 5th percentile, prefer safe driving, and not get distracted/drunk.
- traderjane 7y agoDo you not put your hands behind the car wheel with moral confidence, the confidence that you are okay with the sum of your action? Do you view the medical system differently?
- beerandt 7y ago>countless people We've got very accurate counts. To say countless is hyperbole. >If they'll kill fewer people Everyone assumes ML / AI will be better drivers than humans, but I think that's just blind hope at this point. I've seen no proof or studies that show any better logic than fusion power being about 20 years away (indefinitely).
- mythz 7y ago> >countless people > We've got very accurate counts. Pointless rebuttal, the exact number isn't relevant, nor easily quoted as the number of deaths per day, month, year is fluid, evident as you've made no attempt to quantify an "accurate count" yourself. > Everyone assumes ML / AI will be better drivers than humans, but I think that's just blind hope at this point. You call someone out for non precision then follow up with a baseless supposition that you think people who believe autonomous drivers are safer then human drivers are hopelessly blind. You can include the NHTSA and the U.S. Department of Transportation in your blind hopefuls who are keen on moving towards an automated driving future: https://www.nhtsa.gov/technology-innovation/automated-vehicles-safety https://www.nhtsa.gov/technology-innovation/automated-vehicl...
- beerandt 7y agoCalling something countless is hyperbolic exaggeration. I wasn't expecting an exact number. I also was not expecting hyperbole. NHTSA is no different than the DOE stating their (thusfar inaccurate) expectations for fusion. Government agencies can also express hope. >The continuing evolution of automotive technology aims to deliver even greater safety benefits They have a very well thought out timeline with goals and expectations. But there's no real evidence of why we should expect to hit level 5 driving in a given time frame. It's still just a goal they hope (aim) to hit. Unless there's a Moore's law of AI driving ability that I'm unaware of.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Calling something countless is hyperbolic exaggeration. I wasn't expecting an exact number. I also was not expecting hyperbole. I'm sorry if I caused any confusion. I meant "countless" simply as in "more than a person could reasonably count". The usage I'm familiar with appears to be different from yours.
- mcguire 7y agoThe question is the intrim period, when autonomous cars are improving, but still killing more people than human drivers. Still ok in that situation?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoWhy should such a period exist? They can gather data with humans in the driver seat, as they have been.
- aeternum 7y agoThat interm period, if it existed at all, has likely already passed. > By this last estimate, Autopilot has about the same to 35% lower fatal crash rates than any conventional vehicle at this time. https://medium.com/@mc2maven/a-closer-inspection-of-teslas-autopilot-safety-statistics-533eebe0869d https://medium.com/@mc2maven/a-closer-inspection-of-teslas-a...
- mcguire 7y agoSo, an autopilot-equipped Tesla is a fully competent self driving car?
- wruza 7y agoI feel like this entire 0.0005% vs 0.0007% chance discussion is somewhat off-track, because it doesn’t matter. More can be less. Personally, and I tend to believe it’s not very different than average, I don’t want less chance to be hit. I want more control and awareness, which can reduce risk fundamentally. I know that accidents happen, but I also know that chances grow by orders of magnitude if I fail to detect dangers and/or make predictions. Malfunctioning traffic lights can do much more harm than your average drunk driver. Not seeing someones intent (or steering/braking problem) does that too. If autopilots provide me a way to reduce risks by clear means on my side, I would not mind [with a great share of egoism, but that’s how it works] if on average it could harm crazy leapers even more than human drivers do. Because the road is a source of danger (due to natural physical/perception failures) and by skipping safety checks they enter a potential chaos which is un-manageable by definition. Heck, I’d better coexist with a tech that never gets tired to send me clear “fuck off” messages, than with human drivers who e.g. think they are smart enough to not brake, because “our current inertial frames render a collision unlikely anyway”, or whatever bs they believe when doing this. But it’s a false negative for me, idk for sure if they see me at all or estimate their reaction time correctly.