12 ms·
Entire lives are wrapped up in Google accounts! They're used for administering other accounts, taxes and payroll, subscriptions, keeping in touch with family, p
by echelon 7y ago
Entire lives are wrapped up in Google accounts! They're used for administering other accounts, taxes and payroll, subscriptions, keeping in touch with family, photos...
This could easily ruin someone's life.
What the fuck, Google.
We seriously need to break this company up into its constituent pieces. This is beyond unacceptable.
- ben_jones 7y agoI wonder how decentralized Google accounts were before the Google+ unification process. Funny that management of that project is still having long lasting negative affects!
- antocv 7y agoThis is one of the reasons why I ditched google, especially gmail a few years ago. Yandex, pretty decent email web interface, and I can have my own @domain.com emails for free, if I ever need to move away from Yandex I can do so without telling everybody I "changed my email". But I doubt Yandex will ever "inspire" me to move away form them, I think they dont even think of me at all, unlike Googles algorithms.
- tiborsaas 7y agoNice try, Boris.
- javagram 7y agoI pay yearly for G Suite to avoid this issue by using my own domain instead of @gmail.com. If I ever had an issue I can change my email provider (also backup email regularly using Takeout or in the past using offlineimap). Unfortunate that it’s necessary but I think it’s a good idea for everyone who can.
- generalpass 7y agoDo you use Google Drive or Docs to store anything critical?
- mcv 7y agoHow does G Suite help here? If you've just got your own domain, you can do the same thing without G Suite.
- metalliqaz 7y agoI presume he wants to use the gmail tools.
- mcv 7y agoI realize I've never checked if my Android GMail app supports using my other address as the From address. I guess it doesn't. I don't use GMail's web interface but prefer an actual mail reader which has no problem with using a different address. Maybe I should use an IMAP mailreader for GMail on Android as well.
- jpindar 7y agoYou have to use the Gmail web page to set it up, but it is possible to use the Android Gmail app to send from non-gmail accounts. The 'From' field becomes a drop-down allowing you to choose from the accounts you have set up.
- jrodthree24 7y agoI'm assuming to use all the google apps like Gmail. But in the case that Google suspends you, you can redirect your mail elsewhere and not be locked out from any other accounts.
- oliwarner 7y agoThe person in the bug post lost access to their email address. Just think of how many services you have tied into your email address. How many of those accounts would allow you to recover without email access? By having G Suite and your own domain, you get to port that domain to another email provider if something bad did happen with Google.
- 7y ago
- drharby 7y agoCan you expand for a scared dummy like me? Is your email infrastructure currently a gmail backend that you can hot-swap with any other provider?
- amdavidson 7y agoIf you have your own domain name for your email, you can point it at any host's servers. Google in the case of Gsuite or Fastmail or Pobox or anyone else. If you have regular backups, all you have to do is change a DNS record to switch to a different provider and you shouldn't lose any email in the process. This is what I and many others do. I have had the same email address for ~20 years and have had it hosted on at least a half dozen providers over that time with no loss in data.
- jsgo 7y agonot the person you're responding to, but I have G Suite and I have my domain pointed at Google for mail. If for some reason Google came down hard on me, I could login to Namecheap and setup email to be handled by another provider (Microsoft, ProtonMail, whoever). So if someone emailed me at my email address, the only gap I risk is between the last time I read my emails and when I setup the new provider. Added bonus, "forgot password" on various sites will continue to work at this stage and I don't have to mass email people that my email address is now name@domain.tld.
- emailforus 7y agoWe should be able to port emails like we are with phone numbers. Keep your @gmail.com address but host it with another provider.
- tastroder 7y ago> We should be able to port emails like we are with phone numbers. We already have that if the e-mail address was "yours" to begin with, you can buy domains and keep using e-mail addresses pointing to them, moving to whatever e-mail provider you prefer this decade.
- lexs 7y agoFrom a consumer perspective the phone number model is much more usable though. You buy the service from a carrier but you can still keep your number when you change carrier due to it being regulated. No need to buy phone numbers separate from the service.
- emailforus 7y agoAnd what do you do with the hundred of millions who have all of their accounts tied to a gmail/...
- tastroder 7y agoThose hundreds of millions of users would not switch providers anyway. Breaking protocols that lasted for decades for the sake of achieving nothing seems like an ineffective reaction to stupid corporate policies and a total lack of customer support.
- josteink 7y agoNonsense. You have no ownership claim to the domain gmail.com. You are merely renting it, and for free no less! Stop acting entitled. If you want ownership, the option already exists, and it’s easy: get your own domain. That’s yours to keep and manage as you see fit, with Gmail a possible service attached to it as you see fit.
- decoyworker 7y agoIs there a way to get your data out if your account is suspended? In the very least there needs to be some recourse and a way for users to export their data if their account is suspended.
- mantap 7y agoIf you live in the EU you could threaten them with GDPR, also you have a right to not have decisions made by algorithms without recourse. If you live in US you are pretty much fucked.
- londons_explore 7y agoGDPR requires them to answer your request within 30 days. They are allowed to give you your data as it appears when they process your request. Google's policies, as required by their privacy policy, are to delete all data associated with a suspended account in 30 days. That means any GDPR request submitted after the account is suspended will be responded to on the 30th day, and the response will be "we hold no data about that account".
- shadowgovt 7y agoAlternatively, one should probably break up one's interface to Google into a personal Gmail account and a professional Gmail account. I don't disagree that Google could do a better job firewalling TOS violations in one service from blowing up all your interaction with Google, but in the short run, defense in depth.
- slightwinder 7y agoUntil you link them in some way, in which case Google might suspend the linked account too. There are some nasty stories about those things going around.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThat's generally true, and the solution is to avoid linking them. It's a rock-and-a-hard-place problem, since the most common scenario Google is dealing with is criminal enterprises trying to obfuscate their activity behind dozens of "independent" accounts (so of course they have to try unifying accounts). But this is analogous to the scenario one deals with separating concerns when forming an LLC; you keep your work and personal stuff separate, including finances and capital (i.e. don't do work stuff on your personal computer; that's riksing having your LLC status collapse if someone has occasion to sue you).
- vbezhenar 7y agoI've heard from one Android freelancer developer, that he creates pristine VM for new project, uses it via VPN, creates new Google Account, uses it only inside that VM and does not use that VM for other tasks, so there's no correlation between his accounts.
- rootsudo 7y agoTechnically they're already linked - it's an android, it can query the bluetooth mac address, the wifi mac address, the hostname of the device and the serial number / imei / esn of the device. There's no "unlinking" it unless you manually modify the serial numbers on the device, which is possible, if you have qualcomm diagnostic tools (QPST/QXDM) and are able to communicate to the modem softband directly.
- mcv 7y agoIf ever there was a clear case for breaking them up, it's this. An issue with Youtube should not impact all other Google services you're using. If they don't like people avoiding Youtube ads, I guess they're free to block their access to Youtube. But don't block access to Android, GMail, Docs and whatever.
- mbreese 7y agoBut YouTube and Search ads are what pays for all of the other services... If you really want to break up Google, people are going to have to get used to paying for a ton of other services. I’m not saying this is wrong, but it will come as a shock to many people when they have to start paying for email again (or start seeing ads in gmail again).
- iroo9fkn 7y agoOr we could just pay for the infra and host our own, rolling open source into user friendly packages I mean look around Github: people all around the world breaking through social barriers and norms to provide safe, useful software Then look at how every tech company behaves
- ryanmercer 7y ago>But YouTube and Search ads are what pays for all of the other services... Then charge me 1-2$ a month for gmail access... oh wait I already pay for extra storage. I'm quite fine paying if it means that if for some reason I offend them and they decide to suspend my service that I have a window where I'm allowed to exit their ecosystem. Remove my ability to send email, allow me to receive email and give me a 1 week period to export everything and change contact info elsewhere.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoYou may want to get a head start while you still can honestly.
- me_me_me 7y ago
- rb808 7y agoYou definitely shouldn't be using the same account for all these things. Split into at least work and personal accounts.
- tacone 7y agoon separate phones :)
- marcinzm 7y agoMay not help, Google associates accounts together: https://www.reddit.com/r/androiddev/comments/b2ztr0/google_terminated_our_startups_developer_account/ https://www.reddit.com/r/androiddev/comments/b2ztr0/google_t... So make sure you never access them both from the same computer, phone or IP.
- londons_explore 7y agoThe association is generally limited to recovery email and phone numbers. In the case of AdWords, your billing address is also a linking factor. In the case of Google Cloud, being Owner of the same project or organisation is a linking factor. In the case of Google Payments, using the same bank details is a linking factor (also applies to GCloud).
- marcinzm 7y agoEven if that's the case they may change it with some new ML/AI solution in the future. Then run it retroactively on past data. That's the thing, you have no control over what Google does and little recourse once they do it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- woodgrainz 7y agoIt's entirely possible the banning had nothing to do with NewPipe. No other NewPipe users seem to have had this issue. But of course it's fun to yell at Google. We know nothing about this person. Isn't it very possible he was actually violating Google's terms in some way?
- djsumdog 7y agoWith so much tied to a Google account, there should be some means of dealing with it. With this person being in Finland, they should have some means of at least extracting all account data thanks to the GDPR or other protection laws.
- olivierduval 7y agoExcept that, if your account is cancelled, the datas are deleted (or should have been)... so there's nothing to download, even from a GDPR point of view. So the probleme to be able to use that GDPR feature... is to still have an account
- judge2020 7y agoI find that to be a possibility too. If none of the other newpipe users in the thread got suspended for "using 3rd party app outside of Play Store to go around Youtube ads", chances are newpipe isn't on the app blacklist.
- usrusr 7y agoIt might also be possible that someone was violating terms while imposting as the user in question using snooped access tokens or whatever. There won't be a trial where the reason might come to light.
- falcolas 7y agoAs has been proven by other companies recently, so long as there is a "catchall" clause in the terms, anything you do has the potential to be against their terms. All you can ever really do is hope to not be caught up in something Google (or its bots) considers "bad". EDIT: A few catchall terms from YouTube's TOS: "YouTube may, in its sole discretion, modify or revise these Terms of Service and policies at any time, and you agree to be bound by such modifications or revisions." "You agree not to access Content through any technology or means other than the video playback pages of the Service itself, the Embeddable Player, or other explicitly authorized means YouTube may designate." (There go all New Pipe accounts) "YouTube reserves the right to discontinue any aspect of the Service at any time." "YouTube reserves the right to decide whether Content violates these Terms of Service for reasons other than copyright infringement, [...]. YouTube may at any time, without prior notice and in its sole discretion, [...] terminate a user's account for submitting such material in violation of these Terms of Service."
- ArtWomb 7y agoI just discovered a mission critical bug in their 2FA flow as well. Gist of it is if you switch phones, verifying the new number, it still prompts to the old number. You cannot login to update to the new number, without the old number. It then locks you out of your account for hours. The kicker is I am authenticated on the new phone! But cannot make changes because of the 2FA bug. So at some point, randomly, it decided to revert to an old phone number. Even though I am certain I disabled it! I feel even submitting a detailed report, it would take quite a while to pierce the layers of bureaucracy and come into contact with a technical human that can diagnose and understand the nature of this issue ;(
- kd913 7y agoThis is on purpose, otherwise anyone can just register a new phone including an attacker. In these contexts, you should have a recovery mechanism in place such as recovery codes or a recovery email.
- sebow 7y agoMaybe stop using google at all? "The web"'s future mustn't be about corporations and centralized control of information, but rather decentralized (or even better, distributed) systems with freedom of speech and freedom of information exchange(a.k.a everything done on the internet)in mind.I would say privacy at upmost priority as well, but this is obviously impossible for some services/products. People who are so vehemently against this and still use google(or any other monopoly corporation for that matter) products need to be called out.Just because it's convenient doesn't mean you should do it,especially when you know how for-profit corporations work and operate.(Google is one whether we like it or not,even if they contribute to open projects,their profit ramifications outweigh their effort/money poured into these open projects). Alt-tech is possible, alt-education is possible.We have a massive opportunity to change the hierarchical way of computing and flow of information yet we still do it because "it's convenient". And i'm not delusional, people who know about these are in the very minority,but i would say it's our "duty" to at least inform others that are not aware of the potential abuses and how hard their lives can be impacted by choosing convenient.(at the moment anyways).A centrist position will stagnate at best the centralization of power. If this sounds very "anti-profit" and "socialistic" speech, it's really not.We should just consider the value of our information and whether we really like essentially "selling ourselves" because it's the easy path. If one decides they would make the trade, so be it.But at least people should be informed about the data-mining possibilities of our tech industry.
- oconnore 7y agoIt’s not just TOS violations... I can’t get into my google account because they locked my password and don’t recognize any of my current devices. The account isn’t even suspended, they just have no support team so I can’t recover my account in any “algorithmically approved” way.
- pingyong 7y agoBtw. what usually works is just giving them a phone number, ideally a number that is associated with with one gmail account that is still in good standing. Which of course completely defeats the "security" of this "security feature", but that's probably not the point of it anyway, they just want your phone number for meta data collection.
- monktastic1 7y agoUnless you use Google Fi and get locked out of that, too, I guess?
- briandear 7y agoIt is possible to not use google for payroll, subscriptions and keeping in touch with family. That people allow Google to have prongs in every aspect of their life — that’s on them. Just because Google enables you to put all of your eggs in one basket doesn’t mean you should.
- greggman2 7y agoI don't disagree but it's not just Google. Apple is doing the same thing. In fact agressively with their new login system that they require that if you support any 3rd party system you must support "Sign in with Apple" https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#sign-in-with-apple https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#sig... AFAIK Google has no such requirements for apps on Android. As more and more people use "Sign in with Apple" it will end up being the same issue. If Apple locks your account they'll ruin your life. I generally use neither. I don't sign into things with Google nor Apple nor Facebook. The exception is I do sign into a few dev related things with github but only of they are related to my github account (example, Travis CI). I also have my own domain as I learned the hard way in the 90s that losing your email address to your ISP is no fun.
- briandear 7y agoAn app that exclusively offers third party sign in.. not all apps. Apple is forcing choice: it isn’t going to allow an app that only allows Google for sign in (and not email.) That’s a win. Apple is saying that you can’t only offer Google sign in. If you allow standard email/password you don’t have to allow Sign In with Apple. Apple says: “either allow normal sign in or, if you only allow 3rd party, then one of the choices should be Apple. Basically Apple says: you are required to offer choices and you can’t force users to only use Facebook/Google. A big difference and a big win for choice.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI agree that maintaining some independence from a central provider with little accountability is a Good Idea(tm). But Apple is far less dangerous than Google. Partly because you're actually a customer to begin with, rather than just a data source. And partly because there are well-known ways to get ahold of humans at Apple, one of which is to walk into the local Apple Store.
- charles_f 7y agoI have been using email and password instead of Google SSO for a while now, never been fan on concentrating so much power on one single company, who just proved to be unreliable. It's harder and harder, Sign-up UIs are hiding it. Sign-in with Google or Facebook is really the norm nowadays.
- olivierduval 7y agoI was more thinking of a kind of "Right to keep at least a basic service"... a bit like a kind of GDPR ANY identity provider (meaning email, facebook, ...) can terminate any account BUT MUST provide a temporary (maybe 1 month) minimum service (maybe only replying to incoming emails for example, with a cap) to allow identity migration out of the platform... because identity can't be owned by anybody. It doesn't need to apply to ANY website, ONLY to website providing some identity service (like email or auth provider). And this could be quite a simple law. It wouldn't forbid the website to cancel accounts, only would they have to give enough time and functionalities to properly manage the cancellation and its impact on the user digital life
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duxup 7y agoWe thought some evil AI would take over the world and make arbitrary decisions that we struggle to undo. But really humans are happy to do it to each other ...
- dbuder 7y agoGoogle/Youtube love to pretend it was the AI that made the decision when in reality many are made by humans. Companies get away with so much lying.
- jsgo 7y agoWhat I find most ironic is that outside of Search, Youtube is probably the least linked Google service to your account that springs to mind. Ban your account? Private mode and/or VPN and you can access YouTube again. Can't get the curated lists thing that your data can provide, but you can still access the site. Whereas Drive, Mail, etc. are all deeply connected to it. So seems the punitive measure is specifically setup to have the most impact on you. Within their right, granted, but I feel for anyone who shares a device with someone who wants to circumvent ads in YouTube while they're logged in as they could be the person punished for reasons they don't understand.
- coldtea 7y agoThere should be a law like GDPR that forces them to justify account terminations, provide feedback, and even be sued for doing so, whatever their EULAs saw (and make that part illegal to enforce).
- iliketocomplain 7y agoWhy do people give all their stuff away though? It's literally saying, here why don't you control my stuff instead of me. So stupid, I never got that.
- meerita 7y agoI will start migrating all soon, I don't want to be fucked by any mistake of Google
- jwr 7y agoHey, it's really easy: do not rely on a Google account. There are choices, and it's your decision in the end. Google is actually rather clear in the terms of use that you have no rights whatsoever and that they can use your data for training their algorithms.
- manigandham 7y agoCCPA and similar regulations are going to have an effect on at least recovering and restoring your data so it's not a catastrophic loss. Also after hearing these stories, I keep my cloud accounts as light as possible and use S3 + NAS for actual data.
- ganeshkrishnan 7y agoI got my AdSense account suspension notice yesterday about an game I had built nearly 7 years ago. Stuff like this are downright scary but there is absolutely nothing we can do. Google is too big to fail now for consumers
- anoncow 7y agoCompletely agree. Unless Google can assure some amount of access to accounts, even in cases of potential abuse, the behemoth threatens to destroy lives with ever scratch, sniffle and scare that it gets.
- ghaff 7y agoIf losing access to Google would ruin your life I’m pretty sure you’re doing something wrong. To be sure, many don’t have the knowledge to put in place fallback plans. But if you think that about yourself you really ought to do something about it.
- Frost1x 7y agoI certainly don't wrap my life around my Google account, most of my important accounts have secondary emails tied to other service providers and other means of contact that Google has no control over (yet). I'm always amazed at how quickly people jump into these massive corporate product/service ecosystems gung-ho as if we haven't learned anything about large business behaviors (including technology companies) over decades and decades of history. You should always remember that a business has one goal: to make money for its shareholders. Anything and everything else is a side effect, so if you can forsee any goals you have utilizing a business product/service ecosystem not in direct alignment with a specific businesses' shareholders' interest in profit, then you should hedge your bets and have backup plans if you interconnect important aspects of your life with that business. To me, this includes career paths which is why it's always fun to see businesses get heavily entrenched in AWS or some other ecosystem when their needs don't even require the benefits AWS actually provide. I'm singling out AWS because that's the case I'm dealing with on current projects at a current employer but it applies to any similar ecosystem.
- simion314 7y agoThe issue is that this massive corporations are buying stuff left and right. Google,Facebook,Microsoft are buying things left and right and you are forced(or tricked with dark patterns) to link your Google account with your YouTube account,your Skype account with your MS account etc. This companies should not be able to suspend your account for everything, if my son broke some TOS rule on my console I should not have to have access blocked to anything except online gaming, my emails. my phone , my apps should still work.
- anonuser123456 7y ago>Entire lives are wrapped up in Google accounts!...We seriously need to break this company up How about users that don't like the TOS just find another service? I'm perfectly happy with the way things are.
- stiray 7y agoUnfortunately this will not work. Google must stay until lawmakers figure out all the walkarounds company can use and close all the loopholes. One by one, law by law. Or there is going to be another google company stepping the same steps. But this is just the beginning. Cloud is next, raising prices, preventing people from leaving by crating apis you cant simply rewrite... Mainframe history all over again. (disclaimer: googless for a decade, once I prediceted where this is going I became completely self hosted, learned to build my own roms without gms etc. Today is much easyer with microg, newpipe, aurora, apktool, ... On the other side, people are less and less knowlidgable as a result of helpers from companies and dependant to them. I am eager to see how this will end)