12 ms·
Kim Peek
- jonbaer 7y agoThis was pretty remarkable to watch, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLpCfHH1OVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLpCfHH1OVU The fact that he lacked conceptual encoding really says something.
- x220 7y agoWhat do you mean by conceptual encoding?
- obituary_latte 7y ago> Conceptual encoding contributes to the construction of conceptual representations in the mind of the addressee, whilst procedural encoding provides the addressee with instructions as to how conceptual representations are to be manipulated to achieve relevance. To me it reads as a lack of ability to conceptualize, for instance, others‘ state of mind.
- jonbaer 7y agoIt's explained @ ~around the 35' minute mark, but basically he did not understand or grasp metaphors, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor - like a machine he would interpret everything literally, excellent case study for some of the obstacles facing AGI in my opinion.
- Kenji 7y agoBut Kim Peek does seem to get some metaphors. He said "My dad and I share the same shadow." towards the end of the video. Maybe he just picked it up from someone else, though.
- wubblebubble 7y agoalso recently featuring kim https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcPzTr-BbAA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcPzTr-BbAA
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> Peek read by scanning the left page with his left eye, then the right page with his right eye. According to an article in The Times newspaper, he could accurately recall the contents of at least 12,000 books.[6] These are pretty extraordinary claims and I'm curious to know whether they were ever tested in controlled conditions. For example, how does one verify the recollection of the contents of "at least" 12,000 books? Was there an experiment performed, where he was asked questions about a sufficiently large, randomly chosen, sample of those 12,000 books? I understand that Tim Peek made a living out of his mnemonic abilities and I think, in that context, skepticism is justified.
- ggm 7y agoI grew up in a house of books and have lived with a bookseller for most of my life. Having therefore owned and lived with 10,000 to 15,000 books, periodicals and related ephemera (catalogues, concordance &c) I can assure you I cannot recall even fractional amounts of most of these although I can recall significant amounts of many and quite inaccurately quote some small amount. So I too think the question demands testing: it's the kind of thing people say but actually don't mean. "What is written on page 150 of the third book on the tenth shelf" is quite different to what comes after 'it was the best of times it was the worst of times' and many Shakespearean fans could quite easily quote significant amounts of most plays, Wagnerians could sing the ring cycle, my mum who certainly didn't have eidetic memory could whistle a lot of Mozart or Bach: getting from pedestrian memory to this specific recall Peek is said to have had is pretty strange, and I think should be verified. Day of the year or train timetables are tricks. Flow text with meaning? That's hard.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI know that calculating what day it was on a given date is a common mnemonic trick, e.g. see [1]. It's not easy to do but a person well-trained in mental arithmetic and memorisation should be able to pull it off. I didn't know about recalling trains timetables and I can't find any pointers online. Can you point to a source explaining how it's done? I always like to impress at parties :) Btw, the fact that Peek demonstrated common mnemonic skills that don't require unique abilities to perform casts further doubt on the fact that he had such unique abilities. _____________ [1] https://artofmemory.com/blog/how-to-calculate-the-day-of-the-week-4203.html https://artofmemory.com/blog/how-to-calculate-the-day-of-the...
- riffraff 7y agoI recall seeing him for the first time in a documentary about Daniel Tammet[0]. Seeing him read books by basically just scanning two pages at once was astonishing. If I recall correctly, his father mentioned he had recently started to understand and tell jokes, which I found interesting, and somehow moving. And on a side note, after seeing "the original", Dustin Hoffman's interpretation in Rain Main felt way more precise than I would have ever thought. [0] "Brainman", I believe https://guidedoc.tv/documentary/brainman-documentary-film/ https://guidedoc.tv/documentary/brainman-documentary-film/
- mlguide 7y agoIt is worth noting that Tammet is widely believed to use regular mnemonic techniques: https://forum.artofmemory.com/t/ask-a-memory-champion/28565/33 https://forum.artofmemory.com/t/ask-a-memory-champion/28565/... "I’m a bit surprised by Helix’s idea that answering this question might get me into trouble, because it’s not something that’s debated among the people who go to competitions. It’s well known that he uses memory techniques like a ‘regular person’ - he was a regular at the world championships for years, slightly before my time (though we did meet in 2000), and always talking about the specific techniques he used. It’s not really that much of a secret…" There also is a Letterman interview where he behaved rather normal, to the point that Letterman asked him if he was actually autistic (Letterman clearly did not believe it).
- narrator 7y agoI know a guy who competes and does well in memory sports. I'd say he's above average intelligence for sure, maybe in the top 5%, but not some sort of extreme freak of nature. He's spent thousands of hours drilling memory techniques though. "Moonwalking with Einstein" is a good book about memory sports and has an intro to some of the basic techniques. From what I've seen, it's really about deepening a set of specialized ruts in the road in the brain around remembering numbers and other things that memory sports athletes compete on. It's essentially building custom designed specialized neural networks in the brain through thousands of hours of drilling. One thing I told my nephew is that he can spend thousands of hours playing video games and then have his head full of video game trivia or he can spend thousands of hours learning to program or learning memory sports techniques and have almost as much fun, but instead wind up with something that he can actually use later in his life that doesn't involve working for a video game company.
- jorgenveisdal 7y agoRelated, on calendar calculations: https://medium.com/cantors-paradise/how-to-perform-calendar-calculations-5617f35d3070 https://medium.com/cantors-paradise/how-to-perform-calendar-...
- l5870uoo9y 7y ago> In psychological testing, Peek scored low average (87) on general IQ tests. I would have presumed that would have been much higher.
- jcora 7y agoThis could be a case where cognitive functions were highly uncorrelated. For example he could've had enormous working memory but extremely low spacial intelligence. In most people these are highly correlated and so IQ can be an informative number but in his case, it might carry less information.
- nabla9 7y agoAverage IQ of unskilled worker is 87 and it's considered normal level (assuming SD 15 points normally used in IQ tests).
- r34 7y agoIQ measures few cognitive skills - with some relevant to abstract thinking amongst them, which were problematic for KP. Most savants have low IQ scores.
- corpuscallosum 7y agoIQ tests in my experience are better for logic, maths and abstract thinking, eg trying to spot the pattern in a series. Other tests which can be used to measure brain abilities, could be the brick test, where you are presented with a brick and have to list all the ways a brick could be used. This is somewhat dependant on life experience of course and its hard to know what someone has seen and thus experienced. Another example of brain function is identifying auditory tones and patterns, some people are better at picking up notes in a section of played music than others. School in some ways and interests is an intelligence test in itself by virtue of the subjects a child wants to study and is good at. So IQ tests are somewhat limited in determining brain function and abilities.
- partyboat1586 7y agoI've always been good at the alternative uses test. I'm better with possible than probable. Is there some kind of standardised test I could take for it?
- ianai 7y agoI’m deeply offended by the commenters questioning the authenticity of this guy’s bio. The poor man lived and died essentially an outcast and alone.
- Carpetsmoker 7y agoWhy is it offensive to ask if specific and extraordinary claims have ever been verified in controlled conditions? I also don't see how this has any relation on Kim living as a lonely outcast.
- _0ffh 7y agoBecause offended is the new black.
- delinka 7y agoYou're offended. Says more about you. Why would it even be offensive at all (but especially to you) to question the veracity of facts in a Wikipedia article?
- Carpetsmoker 7y agoAs far as I know, Kim Peek has never made any scientific discoveries, or had any wisdom to tell the world, in spite of being able to remember ~12k books. It's a good reminder that knowledge does not equal intelligence or wisdom.
- unkulunkulu 7y agoDid he understand those books? Was he able to present the premises, propositions and arguments from those books or just to recite them? The latter does not constitute even knowledge, just memory.
- jcutrell 7y agoFor most (not Peek), memory and knowledge are necessarily linked since memory tends to work better when there is a previously existing connection to attach a new piece of information to. So, we don't tend to remember facts for the sake of facts. This obviously isn't always true, but for vast amounts of information, it would be very difficult to remember single "nodes" of information without having some connection to other information. Memory contestants use this to their advantage, by creating some sense of story and/or place to attach the otherwise arbitrary information, like digits or cards, to.
- vinceguidry 7y agoScientific discovery may have been in the realm of individual accomplishment 200 years ago, now it requires organization. I wouldn't let this fact color your judgment. I'm sure he could have done a PhD like anyone else.
- kiba 7y agoWell, scientific discoveries required creativity and innovation, not just intelligence. At least, some of them probably do.
- MagnumPIG 7y agoIn Kuhn's main book (scientific revolutions), he mentions creativity as vital to discoveries, multiple times. Not sure if intelligence is ever mentionned, but I doubt it because it can't be defined in a useful way.
- r34 7y agoAnother guy with savantism, who impresses me a lot: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigel_Richards_(Scrabble_player) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigel_Richards_(Scrabble_playe...
- McKayDavis 7y agoI recall seeing Kim Peek many times in the old downtown Salt Lake City library in the late 80s. I always saw him camped out at some table near the reference section under the escalators on the main floor. He would usually have a stack of phone books (The White Pages) from around the country and spend hours methodically scanning and memorizing every page.
- rurban 7y agoIt also helped that the new Salt Lake City Library is so beautiful to work in. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_Lake_City_Public_Library https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_Lake_City_Public_Library On of the world finest libraries imho.
- umvi 7y agoThis guy is said to have memorized decades worth of newspaper articles, phone books, and other potentially PII. How does that jive with GDPR and Right to Be Forgotten? If people just start using him to do background checks, wouldn't that be a violation of RTBF?
- umvi 7y agoIs he actually comprehending what he is reading or just indexing it? I doubt he could comprehend an entire physics book in 1 hour, so I'm guessing this is purely memorization, not comprehension.
- miohtama 7y ago"Indexing" - see this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21239389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21239389