4 ms·
The underlying study is misleading, and the article’s characterization of the findings is outright deceptive. The article claims that “nearly a billion dollars
by rayiner 7y ago
The underlying study is misleading, and the article’s characterization of the findings is outright deceptive. The article claims that “nearly a billion dollars a year is flowing into the organized climate change counter-movement.” That billion dollars is the total funding flowing into a variety of conservative and pro-market organizations, which advocate on a wide variety of issues.
The underlying study and the article also lump all of these organizations into a “climate change denial” movement. That’s totally false. The official position of organizations like Heritage Foundation is not to deny that climate change is happening. Their position is, basically, the potential risks of climate change are overstated and extreme solutions are not worth the cost. That is not a climate denialism position, it’s a costs-and-benefits analysis. The IPCC’s own estimates of the business as usual scenario show modest economic impacts even under a business as usual scenario out to 2100. (Large in absolute terms but relatively small in terms of the total world GDP.)
- onemoresoop 7y agoThe way I see it is fighting with the same weapons, deception if it may since this is what climate change deniers do. It is not hard to see some sort of deception on both sides of this issue
- prepend 7y agoDeception on both sides is a failing strategy. A big benefit of the moral high ground is having the high ground. If morals lack on both sides then it is difficult to convince people with evidence, I think.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y ago> The IPCC’s own estimates of the business as usual scenario show modest economic impacts even under a business as usual scenario out to 2100. Is that the impact that occurs up to 2100, or the total future impact that will be unavoidable if we do business as usual until 2100? This sounds a lot like you are saying "if we continue business as usual, the world won't be destroyed before 2100", which might well mean "but it's completely impossible to escape complete destruction until 2150 then".
- abledon 7y agoThe author posts his link at the bottom, I am sure he would appreciate your point, as he may include an addendum. Contact him!
- kbutler 7y agoTo a 2013 article? (HN headline should include 2013)
- ianai 7y agoThere’s the distinct possibility of 8c change by 2100 under business as usual. 8c means palm trees at the arctic and no clouds ever forming. If you think that’s a tenable position for life then you’re fully on the denier side.
- rayiner 7y agoThat’s not a business as usual scenario: https://www.carbonbrief.org/extreme-co2-levels-could-trigger-clouds-tipping-point-and-8c-of-global-warming https://www.carbonbrief.org/extreme-co2-levels-could-trigger... > The Representative Concentration Pathways 8.5 scenario (RCP8.5), a very high emissions scenario examined by climate scientists, has the Earth’s atmosphere reaching around 1,100ppm by the year 2100. But this would require the world to massively expand coal use and eschew any climate mitigation over the rest of this century. Also, it’s clearly a “tenable position for life” because temperatures were that high as recently as 55 million years ago, and mammals survived: http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150914-when-global-warming-made-our-world-super-hot http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150914-when-global-warming-...
- lern_too_spel 7y agoWhen global temperatures were that high, the change happened gradually over many millions of years, allowing ecosystems to adapt.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoHere's the last 22000 years of climate change in comic form to illustrate the point. https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/
- staktrace 7y ago"Tenable for life" is not the same as "tenable for human life"
- refurb 7y ago
- dwaltrip 7y ago> The official position of organizations like Heritage Foundation is not to deny that climate change is happening. This is a flat-out false representation. The Heritage Foundation has sown the seeds of denialism many times. https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/how-the-scientific-consensus-global-warming-affects-american-business-and https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/how-the-scientif... https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/congress-should-stop-regulations-greenhouse-gases https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/congress-should-... (section titled "climate change realities") https://www.desmogblog.com/heritage-foundation https://www.desmogblog.com/heritage-foundation Some of the problematic articles are from years ago, you say. Well, where is the retraction? The damage of denialism (and their credibility) has already been done... Redemption would not be trivial.
- tzs 7y ago...and if it does happen, they say [1], worst case estimate is 7 F increase in the global average temperature. Dubai is about 35 F above the global average, and they do fine by using their abundant fossil fuels to power air conditioners. A globalized market in cheap fossil fuels will let other countries do that so 7 F is nothing to worry about. [1] https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/how-fossil-fuels-will-help-us-confront-climate-change https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/how-fossil-f...
- dwaltrip 7y agoYeah, no biggie, let's just run the air conditioning 24/7/365 for 10 billion people. And it's not like we should expect any other severe worldwide impacts from the rising temperatures, so we can all be relieved about that.
- kgwgk 7y agoCurrently more energy is used for heating than for refrigeration.
- polotics 7y agoThere is your answer courtesy of the OECD a month or so back: https://youtu.be/vwwvZ8g5eHE https://youtu.be/vwwvZ8g5eHE
- specialist 7y agoThat's a distinction without a difference. Judge the results, not the (stated) intent.
- AndyMcConachie 7y ago"Their position is, basically, the potential risks of climate change are overstated and extreme solutions are not worth the cost." Stating that the risk of climate change is overstated is denying the risk of climate change. I don't see how you can interpret it any differently. In your own words they are denying the risk of climate change. Saying that climate change is happening, but that it is not a risk, is the same thing as saying that climate change is not happening. They're just moving goal posts and being mealy mouthed.
- ThomPete 7y agoCan you mention a single scientifically demonstrated consequence of climate change we dont know how to handle with todays technology let alone in 50 years time? I am not talking about speculated but demonstrates. Thats what they mean.
- dwaltrip 7y agoWhen flat-out denial slowly morphs into "maybe it isn't a huge deal", one must question if that is actually what they mean.
- gjm11 7y ago> The official position of organizations like Heritage Foundation is not to deny that climate change is happening Not now, but the official position of, say, the Heritage Foundation has always been the most do-nothing position that they might hope much of the public would accept. As the evidence mounts they have to back off a bit. Let's take a quick trip back in time: Heritage Foundation in 2010: https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/how-the-scientific-consensus-global-warming-affects-american-business-and https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/how-the-scientif... First sentence of abstract: "The only consensus over the threat of climate change that seems to exist these days is that there is no consensus." (This was not true then any more than it is now, of course.) Heritage Foundation in 2001: https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/warming-the-truth-the-real-story-about-climate-change https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/warming-the-trut... "The human influence on global climate change is small and will be slow to develop." (This was not mainstream science then any more than it is now, of course.) Heritage Foundation in 1998: https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/no-evidence-global-warming https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/no-evidence-... Title: "No evidence for global warming". Heritage Foundation in 1992: https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/guide-the-global-warming-theory https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/guide-the-global... "Question #1: Is the Earth warming as a result of human-caused greenhouse gases or because of natural phenomena? [...] The existing scientific evidence does not give clear answers to these questions."
- rayiner 7y agoRegarding your earlier citations, the consensus for anthropogenic climate change is much more recent than you seem to assume. The IPCC was not formed until 1988. Even as of the 1995 report, the conclusions regarding the anthropogenic nature of observed warming was tepid: > An introductory preface to the SAR written by IPCC chairman Bolin and his co-chairs John T. Houghton and L. Gylvan Meira Filho highlighted "that observations suggest 'a discernible human influence on global climate', one of the key findings of this report, adds an important new dimension to discussion of the climate issue."[12] It wasn’t until 2001 that IPCC took a definitive position that human influence would be the dominant effect on warming going forward: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/07/WG1_TAR_SPM.pdf https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/07/WG1_TAR_SPM.... (pages 9-11). In that same report, the IPCC took a much milder view on whether human influence had been the dominant contributor to date. They assert that a human “signal” is detectable, but do not assert that the warming to date had primarily resulted from human activity. They also note no impact on, for example, the extent of sea ice. The 2001 Heritage article you posted is probably an optimistic reading of the 2001 IPCC report, but not an unreasonable one. Of course they’re not going to be out front embracing the impact of climate change. But being slow to accept the evidence as it rolls in is not denialism.
- seganddr 7y agoI suggest reading this users post history before taking this post as gospel.