3 ms·
The benefit is that for profit companies have incentives for quality that public entities do not. In New York, at least ConEd gets you reliable power. The New Y
by rayiner 7y ago
The benefit is that for profit companies have incentives for quality that public entities do not. In New York, at least ConEd gets you reliable power. The New York subway by contrast is literally struggling to hit 70% on time performance.
It’s a simple calculation. Would you want your local (almost certainly public) transit operator to take over your electric service? I’d suspect in the vast majority of places, the answer would be no.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago> The New York subway by contrast is literally struggling to hit 70% on time performance. Because politicians cut its budget while requiring 24/7 operation, not because the subway operator doesn't have ~profit motive~
- chachachoney 7y ago>> Because politicians cut its budget while requiring 24/7 operation, not because the subway operator doesn't have ~profit motive~ The MTA's dysfunction and inefficiency scale to accomodate whatever budget they are given and this will continue until city and state politicians are actually held accountable for its performance.
- beerandt 7y agoWhy would you think public utilities are any less beholden to politics than public transport? If anything, utilities are almost always monopolies, transport at least has some competition.
- harryh 7y agoThe MTA is currently in the process of spending 5 billion dollars on ~70 elevators. The inefficiency (and, frankly, corruption) of the agency is staggering. The organization's problems have very very little to do with budget constraints.
- throw0101a 7y agoAnd yet Berlin, Paris, and Copenhagen are all able to build similar infrastructure for much less: * https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/1/1/14112776/new-york-second-avenue-subway-phase-2 https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/1/1/14112776/ne... Chicago seems to be doing okay, or at least much better than NYC: * https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/18/nyregion/chicago-l-train-mta-subway.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/18/nyregion/chicago-l-train-... The problems of the MTA are unique to the MTA itself (AFAICT), and should not necessarily be extrapolated to other places.
- astura 7y agoI have municipal electricity, I've had it for more than a decade over three different apartments/houses. I flippin' love it! The service has been absolutely top notch and cost has been reasonable. The surrounding area is serviced by the publicly traded company and the difference is noticable. When I was a kid I got most places using public transportation and it was fine.
- Buttons840 7y agoWhat are the incentives? You answer the question of what are the "benefits" with essentially another vocab word, and a single word at that, "incentives".
- vojta_letal 7y agoIn the Czech Republic and the neighboring countries the grid operators are state owned, the power plants are mostly private. Works like a charm. We have like minutes of blackouts per year on average. Compare to hours in the US.
- trdtaylor1 7y agoThere are many nonprofit electric co-ops providing high quality service in America. Public transit in America most often the answer would be no. But public transit of say the rest of the world with multi-billions of dollars invested over the years into the public transit infrastructure leading to public owned and operated highly functional transit systems. A for profit company will invest when it makes sense from a bottom line perspective. A public non-profit without corruption will invest when it makes sense from a public good perspective.
- rayiner 7y agoNon-profit co-ops are not comparable in scale and challenges to big power providers. Especially because they don’t operate the sort of large scale transmission grids that caused PG&E’s wildfires. (They’re dependent on the big providers for that capital intensive infrastructure.) That’s why I used transit as an example. It’s similarly large scale in terms of capital costs, intensive maintenance of outside equipment, etc.
- amelius 7y ago> The benefit is that for profit companies have incentives for quality that public entities do not. Not if they are a monopoly.
- jfnixon 7y agoWhat if we had something like a Public Utilities Commission regulate these companies in return for granting them monopoly access to public right-of-way? A PUC that had accountability to the public, and veto rights over the rates and capital planning of these monopoly private providers? What an idea!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- peteretep 7y ago> Would you want your local (almost certainly public) transit operator to take over your electric service? I would love Transport for London to take over electric and water and internet provision in London, yep. And I feel like most everyone in the UK would prefer the trains to be renationalised.
- vixen99 7y agoAs I understand it, re-nationalization of the railways cannot be undertaken while Britain is still in the European Union given its objective of 'Opening up national freight and passenger markets to cross-border competition'. The EU railway directive (2012) "separating management of railway operation and infrastructure from the provision of railway transport services, separation of accounts being compulsory and organizational or institutional separation being optional.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_European_Railway_Directive_2012 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_European_Railway_Direct...
- peteretep 7y agoAs long as they keep Network Rail separate, rolling up the operators who make up National Rail should be fine
- enraged_camel 7y agoWhy are you ignoring the large number of scenarios where public utilities not only work, but work well? Also, surely you understand that the New York subway system’s problems cannot simply be chalked up to it being public?
- jfnixon 7y agoLet me see if I follow... a publicly regulated private monopoly can work well, as can a public monopoly, if there isn't rampant corruption in government? Is that about right?
- PeterStuer 7y agoFor profit companies have an incentive for making profits. That incentive might accidentally be aligned with providing a quality service, but more often it is not. A public entity is not restricted by the need to maximize profits and can fully concentrate on providing the best possible service within the budget. Both public and private organizations can have efficiency challenges, which for the most part correlate with their size. A private company that is granted a monopoly will tend to exhibit the worst of both worlds, maximizing private profits while providing minimal service and putting all risks onto the public sector.
- tomohawk 7y agoInteresting theory. In the USSR, there were no private entities. It must have been a utopia, no? Obviously, it was not, and there was widespread devastation of the environment, unreliable service, etc. Whether a company is for or non profit is almost beside the point. What made utilities work was that the private corp ran the business and the government board provided oversight. This eventually broke down as people are people whether they work at a for profit or non profit organization. If the board becomes filled with people with a different agenda than providing cheap, safe, reliable power, then they will take actions that, over the long term, will make it impossible for the utility to do those things. The signs of this are not allowing new transmission lines or power plants, and directing that the company use specific technologies that are not part of the (cheaper/safer/more reliable) core values.
- metacritic12 7y agoA public entity has an incentive to maintain appearances to the public. That incentive might accidentally be aligned with providing a quality service, but more often it is not.
- throw0101a 7y ago> A public entity has an incentive to maintain appearances to the public. A public entity may have more mechanisms for transparency, whereas a private entity can keep also maintain appearances of good customer service, and as long as they're making profits the shareholders may not care about what's happening under the hood. Until things get so bad that the private entity implodes, but by that time it's too late.