2 ms·
properly correcting for socioeconomic status in determining causal relationships in epidemiology is still a very hard problem. What if, in this case, pollution
by dekhn 7y ago
properly correcting for socioeconomic status in determining causal relationships in epidemiology is still a very hard problem.
What if, in this case, pollution has a delayed effect? How would their methodology deal with that (it wouldn't)?
Personally, I think what happened here is the author started with a prior belief: ""Several years ago, Fort Collins experienced a fairly severe wildfire season," Burkhardt said. "The smoke was so bad that after a few days, I started to get frustrated, and I wondered if frustration and aggression would show up in aggregate crime data.""
and then they conducted a study that supported their belief, possibly making methodological errors along the way , generating a scientific narrative to support their belief.
- PeterStuer 7y agoIf you would actually read the paper you would find that all your remarks have been accounted for.
- dekhn 7y agothe article is paywalled, also, since I have plenty of experience in this field, I do not think my remarks were "accounted for", rather they probably wrote a couple hand-wavy sentences about how they corrected for SES, but didn't really. Edit: found a copy of the paper that wasn't paywalled, read the whole thing, and found their attempts to correct for bias wanting (section 4.2). " Overall, our heterogeneity results indicate the most important explanatory factor in the relationship between pollution and crime is age, and the results are not ameliorated by higher incomes." uh, ok. if you want to defend this paper go ahead but I've already read enough to know these folks started with a biased belief, carelessly analzyed the data in a way that supported their beliefs, and escalated the results into something that sounded far more significant and certain than their data shows.