3 ms·
Assuming they use CRISPR outside the body, on blood, then infuse the blood back in... Are there any credible risks that something unexpected happens?
by tyingq 7y ago
Assuming they use CRISPR outside the body, on blood, then infuse the blood back in...
Are there any credible risks that something unexpected happens?
- AndrewDucker 7y agoYup: "During a routine data run, they unexpectedly found foreign, non-bovine DNA that had bound itself to the animal’s genetic sequence during the edits—specifically, genes from the lab material" https://newfoodeconomy.org/fda-gene-edited-cattle-antibiotic-resistant-crispr-dna/ https://newfoodeconomy.org/fda-gene-edited-cattle-antibiotic...
- justinjlynn 7y agoWhat's the probability that the sequencing sample was contaminated and that the sequence result doesn't represent the animal in question? Has that been ruled out? Obviously such integration errors occur in reality. Though, in therapy I'd expect the rates to be quite low. It'd be interesting to find out how often it happens in these applications.
- aae42 7y agosuperheros?
- ben_w 7y agoWell, the Milkybar Kid is one of the few superheroes whose origin story has not been done to death in the endless reboots that afflicts the genre, so that could work as a good story…
- mbreese 7y agoIntegration errors aren’t the main concern with treating patients - it’s the off target effects. In other words, changes to genes you didn’t expect. You don’t want to fix one problem, only to cause something else. IIRC, the reason why the integration errors were such a big deal is because they made it to the germline of the animal and could be transferred to offspring. This would have been extensively validated given the amount of press and regulatory pressure.
- maxerickson 7y agoThat isn't what they are doing. They are extracting bone morrow and editing that and then reintroducing it. It's basically a bone marrow transplant using the patient's edited stem cells. http://www.crisprtx.com/programs/hemoglobinopathies http://www.crisprtx.com/programs/hemoglobinopathies Words like "credible" and "unexpected" sort of make it impossible to answer the question. The doctors probably expect some editing errors and things like that. They are also doing a really small study to see what happens.
- tyingq 7y agoWords like "credible" and "unexpected" sort of make it impossible to answer the question I guess I could reword. Is there more than a remote chance the patient dies because of an error related to the gene editing?
- maxerickson 7y agoThey don't know for certain, hence a small pilot study. They of course believe that it will work and that there is a limited chance of such things.
- dekhn 7y agoTo know that with any confidence, you'd have to do this for a lot of people and look at the stats. We don't currently have the technology to answer a question like that convincingly for n=1 studies.