7 ms·
It looks nice and I can appreciate the story, but saying « discarded » makes it sound like it has no value, but Scrap structural steel definitely does. > desig
by Scoundreller 7y ago
It looks nice and I can appreciate the story, but saying « discarded » makes it sound like it has no value, but Scrap structural steel definitely does.
> designed the Wikado Playground to address the issue of saving out-of-service wind turbines from landfill.
Nononono.
- floatingatoll 7y agoCan you please share more about what value scrap structural steel has that you see?
- scblock 7y agoMost metals are relatively easily recycled. Therefore scrap metal has value as feedstock for production of new equipment. A modern wind turbine tower might have 150 metric tons of steel in it, which absolutely makes sense to recycle.
- sp332 7y agofloatingatoll meant in the article.
- floatingatoll 7y agoThat answer was the path of answer I hoped to hear, actually.
- spqr0a1 7y agoThe article mentions "composite material". From the pictures it is hard to say whether it is fiberglass/polyester, carbon fiber/epoxy or what; but either way these materials are much harder to recycle than steel.
- scblock 7y agoWind turbine blades, such as those used on this playground, are typically not recycled and have little scrap value. Their structure is primarily of fiberglass, some with carbon fiber, often with foam and balsa wood as well. There is some metal, typically in the lightning protection system (copper and aluminum) and blade root (blade studs, covers, possibly a steel blade root insert), but they do not comprise the majority of the structure. On decommissioning it is relatively common for blades to be shredded and landfilled.
- kaybe 7y agoI've just read some book proposing to make the blades out of natural fiber materials such as bamboo. There seems to be quite a lot of research going on. Edit: The article does indeed appear to talk about composite materials. > According to research, there will be, at current growth rates, 225,000 tonnes of rotor blade composite material produced annually worldwide
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> > According to research, there will be, at current growth rates, 225,000 tonnes of rotor blade composite material produced annually worldwide My heart hurts when I re-read this as "225,000 tonnes of rotor blade composite material landfilled anually worldwide N years from now", N being the average lifetime of a wind turbine.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIs that better or worse than the X tones of carbon emissions diverted? Will any of the composite materials breakdown over time and leach in to water supplies?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoFor the problem of global warming itself, given positive EROI, it's better to have those turbines and emit that less carbon. But for the problem of not running out of resources, it may be worse. In a way, under existing economic regime you can pretty much consider renewables as non-renewable energy sources. A wind turbine doesn't burn non-renewable fuel, but it does "burn" non-renewable construction materials. Of course, climate change is the more pressing problem now, but I'm not 100% sure how much more pressing, given the exponents involved in all of this. Most of all, just thinking about how even renewable energy is entirely embedded in our process of transforming raw resources into waste (with a little bit of economic value extracted in the middle) just breaks my heart.
- 7y ago
- tpkj 7y ago"Unfurling The Waste Problem Caused By Wind Energy" https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759376113/unfurling-the-waste-problem-caused-by-wind-energy https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759376113/unfurling-the-waste...