4 ms·
Finally! Guidance on airdrops and forks was sorely needed. The guidance seems mostly in line with expectations, but I find one bit confusing. The IRS is drawin
by modeless 7y ago
Finally! Guidance on airdrops and forks was sorely needed.
The guidance seems mostly in line with expectations, but I find one bit confusing. The IRS is drawing a distinction between a hard fork with an airdrop and a hard fork without an airdrop. I don't understand the concept of a hard fork without an airdrop. If the new chain doesn't at least maintain the balances of all existing accounts using the new chain's token, then IMO it's not a fork at all but simply the launch of a new cryptocurrency. Can someone give an example of the kind of hard fork with no airdrop the IRS is talking about?
- draaglom 7y agoPeople are speculating this is for e.g. when your coins are at an exchange; the currency hard forks; and the exchange does not (yet) implement the fork so you can't access the coins.
- modeless 7y agoNo, that's handled separately. You're not in possession of the coins if you can't access them, and you aren't taxed on them until you gain possession.
- gamblor956 7y agoThis guidance specifically applies to forks where you receive the forked coins through an exchange because you held pre-fork coins in the exchange. If you receive the new coins directly, this guidance does not apply to you.
- Scoundreller 7y agoQuite refreshing to see. Canada’s CRA publishes some crypto guidance, but delicately avoided any discussion about forks and airdrops, which is the only thing that’s unlike any other asset that someone buys and sells that goes up or down in value. Clarifying the parts that are already clear wasn’t too valuable. Maybe useful for a consumer that thinks “I can trade all day and never pay tax”, but nothing actionable for any accountant.
- nullc 7y ago> The guidance seems mostly in line with expectations, I'm curious what expectation you feel it met? I believe it somehow managed to provide absolutely no clarity on any of the difficult questions. And to the extent that one can attempt to apply it literally and conservatively the results are unconscionable (e.g. having to pay income tax many times over on any hardfork-prone cryptocurrency). The only way that I can see that this met expectations is that those of us that don't own hardfork prone centrally administered assets and diligently sold fork coins ASAP and recording ordinary income for their sale won't be impacted significantly by this. But anyone who didn't do those things is now in a world of confusion.
- modeless 7y agoI expected that airdrops would be ordinary income based on the market value at airdrop time. I expected that stock split rules would not apply to forks (though this may seem obvious, there were many that were arguing the opposite). I was hoping that tokens you can't access due to exchanges not supporting them or whatever don't count as income. Those are all aligned with my expectations. I agree that the rules are stupid and have bad outcomes in many cases. But I didn't expect IRS guidance to change that. I also agree that the guidance is ambiguous on hard forks (is it an "airdrop" or not?) and that's a big problem.
- nullc 7y agoExcept in the situation where the HF coin gets the original ticker or the very rare situation that there is a liquid futures market in advance of the fork (has only arguably happened once that I'm aware of) there is no market value at the time of the fork-- the fork happens at an instant, and the asset cannot be traded at or before that instant. A market value might well be established in the hours or days after, but it isn't always. In cases where the newly created cryptocurrency immediately carries the market there is an unambiguous value for the new system (and the original cryptocurrencies value becomes ambiguous), but applying income tax to the new asset there leads to absurd results. I agree that the ruling seems to generally support some aspects of one of the most obvious conclusions in the simplest of cases, but it fails to meaningfully clarify the application... and also suggests some absurdities that almost no one was expecting.