3 ms·
I am not such a fan of this one, they essentially gave two separate half-prizes this year. James Peebles’ contribution to science was not related to exoplanets,
by whatshisface 7y ago
I am not such a fan of this one, they essentially gave two separate half-prizes this year. James Peebles’ contribution to science was not related to exoplanets, nor was the exoplanet discovery related to cosmology. Instead, they could have waited a year, and given them sequentially. Has this ever happened before in Nobel history? Will this lead to an era where one hundred $10,000 Nobels are handed out each year? ;)
- BeetleB 7y agoIt happens all the time. 2000 is an obvious example.
- searine 7y ago>Has this ever happened before in Nobel history? In recent years the nobel committee has been grouping unrelated prizes in the same field. For example the parasitology prize a few years ago for treating two different parasite diseases (roundworm/malaria). I think its a good thing. It takes two similar discoveries, neither of which are big enough to warrant a solo prize and combines them to give credit to a field which has made advances. I was working in a parasitology department at the time and people were losing their minds about how awesome it was that the field was acknowledged on a world stage.
- evanb 7y agoThis often happens, and it's why the committee distinguishes between splitting and sharing the prize. The first physics split by separate citations was 1903 Becquerel / Curie+Sklodowska-Curie, though their citation explicitly mentions how it's related to Becquerel's work. But as early as 1961 Hofstadter and Mössbauer split the prize for two separate things that can be grouped together as "well... nuclear physics" in the same way as these prizes are "... SPACE!". It's happened a lot in the past. Often the split allows them to cover two things that are only really related on a superficial level. Just going through the list: 1963: Wigner (symmetry) / Goeppert-Meyer + Jensen (nuclear shells) 1970: Alfvén (MHD) / Néel (anti/ferromagnetism in solid state) 1973: Esaki + Giaever (semi/superconductors) / Josephson (Josephson effect) 1978: Kapitsa (low T) / Penzias+Wilson (CMB) 1983: Chandrasekhar (stellar evolution) / Fowler (nuclear abundances) 1986: Ruska (electron microscope) / Binnig+Rohrer (scanning-tunneling microscope) 1989: Ramsey (masers) / Dehmelt+Paul (ion traps) 1994: Brokhouse (neutron spectroscopy) / Shull (neutron diffraction). This one is weird because they also get a joint citation for using neutrons to study materials. 2000: Alferov+Kroemer (heterostructures) / Kilby (integrated circuit) 2002: Davis Jr.+Koshiba (cosmic neutrinos) / Giacconi (cosmic x-rays) 2005: Glauber (coherent states) / Hall+Hänsch (laser spectroscopy) 2008: Kobayashi+Maskawa (CKM matrix) / Nambu (spontaneous symmetry breaking). I think most physicists I know agree that this one should really have been two prizes, one shared K+M+Cabibbo (C in CKM) and one shared Nambu+Goldstone. 2009: Kao (fiber optics) / Boyle+Smith (CCDs) 2018: Askin (optical tweezers) / Mourou+Strickland (chirped pulse amplification)
- LatteLazy 7y agoThere is a rule that you can't award a prize to more than 3 people. I remember when the Higgs was confirmed at CERN, there was a lot of discussion over who (if anyone) should get the prize for that. CERN has something like 2500 permanent, scientific employees, plus 12000 users. So is it appropriate to give the prize to someone who is ultimately a project manager or administrator? It's an interesting question as science moves from a few great thinkers to huge projects with 100+ contributors...
- whatshisface 7y agoI think those accomplishments are large enough to have PR teams, or at least many people who can spread the word, and they may be outside the domain of where Nobel prizes are needed. The Nobel given for the Higgs discovery could not raise anyone's esteem for the LCH team, because the team was so large that everybody who would hear about a Nobel prize had already heard of the LHC.