6 ms·
If you think back to before gay marriage was accepted as a culturally obvious fact, some of the arguments against it involved hating gays, but others didn't. Wi
by whatshisface 7y ago
If you think back to before gay marriage was accepted as a culturally obvious fact, some of the arguments against it involved hating gays, but others didn't. Without the ability to tell which beliefs actually motivated his donation, it is not possible to discern if he was against gays or not. (I'll refrain from giving any specific examples in order to avoid starting that debate again, but I think most of us can remember that time in fair detail.)
- monocasa 7y agoThere weren't good arguments though, it was a rehash of the same 'debate' forty years prior on whether people of different races should be allowed to get married.
- cicero 7y agoMarriage throughout the ages is very much tied to the fact that it takes a man and a woman to conceive a child, and when a man and a woman have sex, they will likely conceive a child. Therefore, marriage was instituted to provide a stable home for such children. This is why sex outside of marriage was taboo since it could result in the conception of children that would not have a good home. Since "gay sex" cannot result in the conception of children, the marriage bond is not a necessary prerequisite, therefore "gay marriage" makes no sense in the context of the traditional understanding of marriage. However, many today have redefined marriage as a commitment between two people who love each other. Soon it will also be redefined to include numbers greater than two as well as animals. It is only with such a definition that gay marriage makes sense. There are those of us who think that such a redefinition of marriage weakens the strength of traditional marriage that is needed to build strong homes that are the best places for children to grow up in. Gay marriage is not the only culprit here. A far greater problem for families is rampant divorce. The debate about interracial marriage had two motivations, one of which was pure racism. However, there was also a concern about the welfare of the children of such unions because they might not be accepted by the race of either parents. (Watch the movie "Guess Who's Coming To Dinner" with Sidney Poitier. [1]) This was a real problem and continues to some extent to this day, but it is getting better as people become less racist. 1: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0061735/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0061735/
- SkyBelow 7y agoAnd expect it to be rehashed again. You know, 40+ years ago, if you brought up legalizing gay marriage many would have seen it as attacking interracial marriage. Even 5 to 10 years ago I met many people who held the view that it was an insult and attack on interracial marriage to bring up gay marriage. Today, if I bring up possible future rehashings, I think people would react the same, thinking instead I was attacking and insulting gay marriage. I wonder how long in the future before we see history repeat again.
- groby_b 7y agoIt's kind of hard to say "you do not deserve to share your life with the person you love. You don't deserve to take care of them when they're sick. You don't deserve a family with them. Because you're gay" without actually hating gay people. Just because you don't call for somebody to be killed doesn't mean you don't hate them.
- cicero 7y agoThere are very solid reasons for seeing marriage as a life-long commitment between a man and a woman for the purpose of providing a stable home for the children that they conceive that has nothing to do with hating gays. This is something humans have understood for thousands of years, but only in my lifetime we seem to have forgotten.
- groby_b 7y agoNo, there really aren't. The socioeconomic consequences of a couple are the socioeconomic consequences of a couple, no matter the dangly bits. We're not all having children. It also turns out raising children also is not negatively affected by the parents being gay. (Plenty of studies on the subject, go read some). Leaves actually having children. Is your argument that we all should breed? Then your argument is seriously broken, the world is about 300% over capacity already. So, no - it's still rooted in hate. (Or fear, really)
- whatshisface 7y agoYou're providing counter-arguments against the correctness of the argument the parent suggested, but otherwise good people can believe incorrect arguments. You can't assume that someone was aware of all those studies, some of which have been conducted in the years since, and none of which are taught about in elementary school. It is not sufficient to demonstrate that the Mozilla CEO believed something incorrect, you also have to demonstrate that evil was the only explanation.
- damnyou 7y ago
- mola 7y agoWhat is A genuine reason for being against gay marriage that does not include hating the concept of gays, or the concept of marriage? Two adults want to share their life, with the burdens and rights that non gays get. Really, why would you care if not because you find the concept of same sex couples bad and harmful?
- whatshisface 7y agoI can give a silly example in order to avoid restarting the debate. Someone who truly believed that gays would cause earthquakes could vote against prop 8. purely on the basis of the San Andreas fault. If you think for long enough you could probably come up with less and less silly sounding arguments, until eventually you arrive at one that a rational and non-evil person could convincingly be misled by. The essential point is that even if you are 100% convinced that the Mozilla CEO held an incorrect belief, it still remains to be shown that evil was the only explanation for that belief.
- mola 7y agoYou could never prove evil. Because it's a matter of values. You could easily say, that holding negative opinions on something strongly enough that you act upon them, without any proof of that thing being dangerous or bad is a sign you are prejudice about that thing. Now being prejudice is not evil in my opinion, but if you value being prejudice more than finding out the actual reality of your negative assumptions, makes you pretty much the text book definition of a bigot.
- ev0lv 7y agoI'll give it a try. Marriage yields children. Making new people grows a civilization. The state would definitely want to incentive any means to grow a civilization. In the modern day, these incentives look like tax deductions. Gay marriage doesn't yield children. Why should the state give the same incentives? My solution: The State shouldn't create incentives for people to get married. People will get married because they want to.