15 ms·
I've been on the beta for a while. I'm sort of surprised that they actually released with the state it is currently in. Most things work, but my CPU still spi
by jedberg 7y ago
I've been on the beta for a while. I'm sort of surprised that they actually released with the state it is currently in. Most things work, but my CPU still spikes for no reason running some OS process or another.
Also, clicking on a dropdown box in a web browser (Safari, Chrome, or Firefox) after the computer has been asleep for a while freezes the whole computer for about 10 seconds.
Maybe it's just me, but that feels like a showstopper.
The whole 32/64 bit thing doesn't seem too bad, although I've had to use Pages instead of Word and can't use Adobe products anymore and have had to switch to open source alternatives, but I don't use those products very much so it wasn't a huge deal for me.
- e40 7y agoAs a long-time macOS user, I don't upgrade to a new version until x.y.5. I've just had too many issues over the years, with stability and application compatibility. Of course, for development, I install it into a VM right after release.
- dwighttk 7y agoAs a long time macOS user[1], I've always installed on public release and I've only ever experienced issues maybe once or twice. Rare enough that I can't think of any specific issues. [1]didn't really pay attention to version numbers before 7.6, but I guess "install on public release" didn't begin until OS X...
- pier25 7y agoYou've been lucky. Many big vendors like Adobe take its time before fully supporting a new macOS version.
- shawnz 7y agoI'm not a macOS user, but if the situation is anything like on Windows, then luck has nothing to do with it. The updates by and large work just fine for almost everyone, but with such a widely deployed product you inevitably will still see hundreds or thousands of people that experience issues.
- pier25 7y agoNo the situation is totally unlike Windows which has legendary backwards compatibility.
- ryandrake 7y agoIt looks like waiting is not going to help in this case. It’s not like 32 bit apps were accidentally broken. When Apple kicks something to the curb they do it forever. I’m probably stuck on Mojave for good.
- H1Supreme 7y agoI only use my mac for audio production these days. I'll upgrade from 10.12.6 when I'm absolutely forced to.
- wildrhythms 7y agoLogic? :)
- H1Supreme 7y agoLogic and Numerology. More so for Numerology, if I'm being honest. I could probably get along with any DAW after the initial learning curve. Plus, I make heavy use of IAC Buses. But, I believe there's a Windows version that people use.
- gnicholas 7y agoThanks for sharing. I would have upgraded for the sidecar capability, but if things are still dicey I’ll wait it out. And like you, I also have a super old version of Word, so will have to switch to Pages. I wonder if this OS update will result in a spike of Word upgrade purchases.
- jedberg 7y ago> I wonder if this OS update will result in a spike of Word upgrade purchases. Unless you use some of the very special features of Word, or you're in a profession that requires Word docs specifically, Pages is a very good substitute. It can even open old Word docs (and new ones too). I haven't tried Sidecar yet because the iPad is on my wife's iCloud account since she's the primary user and I'm not sure how to make it work across iCloud accounts, or if you even can. She uses it so much I can't get my hands on it!
- zitterbewegung 7y agoFYI you need a MacBook Pro 2016 to use sidecar.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoA terminal command could be used to enable Sidecar on older Macs, on Catalina beta. defaults write com.apple.sidecar.display allowAllDevices -bool YES I don't know whether it works on the release build.
- kstrauser 7y agoIt didn't work for my 2015 MBP.
- w1nst0nsm1th 7y agoThey deactivate the command in beta 2. For Apple, you and your 2015 Macbook Pro are just poor losers. Now, You're free to buy a new one.
- zitterbewegung 7y agoWhat Mac / config are you using ?
- jedberg 7y agoMacBook Pro (Retina, 15-inch, Mid 2015) 16GB RAM 1TB SSD (3rd party upgrade)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 120bits 7y agoAfter the upgrade every time after sleep, a window pop ups saying "Verifying Dropbox" and it takes 30-50 minutes before it completes verifying. I don't get it. Why does it has re-verify the same binary over and over again. I'm really disappointed in this release over all. Also, ejecting a application freezes and ask to force eject. Macbook Pro, 15inch, Mid 2015 2.5GHz i7 16GB RAM 500GB SSD
- gherkinnn 7y agoI had the same CPU issues. It turned out to be some bug with the iCloud sync. Constant updates also ate up my phone’s battery and storage. Turning off iCloud capability stoped the insanity. Have been using Apple’s betas for years now. This season was the first time I regretted it. But I like telling myself that dark mode and iPad OS multitasking made it worth it. Some UX improvements across the board are very neat though.
- tracker1 7y agoI'm pretty much stuck a couple versions back now (last rmbp with NVidia graphics, mid-2014). Really wish they'd let NVidia release drivers for the last two versions again. In the end, new desktop runs Linux, and aside from a few issues for brand new hardware, it's been a nice change of pace.
- mtelgon 7y agoIm not sure I understand. Did your nvidia card not work on mojave? What were you gaining not being on mojave?
- tracker1 7y agoIt doesn't work correctly, no. Apple stopped allowing signed Nvidia drivers starting with Mohave and the drivers from Apple for the device are buggy and cause issues.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 7y agoMaybe the driver issues you experience are resolved in more recent macOS versions. I run macOS 10.14.6 on a Mid 2014 MacBook Pro with GeForce GT 750M. No issues here.
- tracker1 7y agopossibly... I don't actually use my laptop, and when I did my hardware refresh a couple months ago, I went linux from my older hackintosh (nvidia gtx 1080)
- smsm42 7y agoI've just checked which 32-bit apps I have (system information/software/applications if you wonder) and turns out if I upgrade I lose: - My scanner support (they have new version, which is insanely buggy and can't even detect my scanner properly) - All my games (literally every single one of them turns out to be 32-bit) - I don't play that much but still, would be a shame to lose all of them - Postal label printing app (no idea if they have an update, need to check) - App supporting my stand-alone disk array (not using it too much though) - My niche learning apps (pretty old, from small providers, not sure if they'd ever be updated) Much more than I expected, given that I don't have any exotic stuff like music instruments, specialized equipment, etc. So I personally probably would hold off upgrading as long as I can.
- guidedlight 7y agoIt really demonstrates how incredible Windows 10’s 16-bit application support is. Although I understand the Windows codebase is a nightmare.
- ljm 7y agoAnd how much they tolerate it, as it's so embedded in their engineering culture and I imagine "backwards compatibility" is drilled into your face when you start working on Windows at MS. It's not easy to get into the mindset of fixing every problem a 3rd party app creates. Some will say Apple is offloading tech-debt onto client apps, but Microsoft is allowing client appts to offload tech-debt onto itself, and it's big enough to take that burden on so its users can still use the stuff they bought. I dunno, sometimes I hate having to do it but it's all about user/dev experience and if you're optimising for your own employees you're making it worse for everyone else who makes your OS/machinery worth buying. There's got to be some compromise, coz it sounds like if you buy into Apple then you're SOL if they can't be bothered supporting your hardware. Which, additionally, must contradict their environmental aims. It's not good for the environment if upgrading an OS means you throw away your printers and scanners and buy compatible ones.
- userbinator 7y ago
- bitL 7y ago> The whole 32/64 bit thing doesn't seem too bad Homebrew has some broken packages, e.g. trying to run Midnight Commander dumps a nice "Bad CPU type in executable" message.
- bonestamp2 7y agoI'm on Word/Excel/Powerpoint 2016, which isn't even the latest version, and it's 64 bit. So, you might be due for an update. I've noticed complex excel spreadsheets are much faster on 2016 vs my previous version so it might be worthwhile anyhow (or run it in VM if you want to keep using it).
- FraKtus 7y agoNow I realize that I still use Word 2008 for when I need to open a .doc or .docx document that Google drive does not want... Time to upgrade...
- bluedino 7y agoThat dropdown freeze happens on the latest safari under Mojave as well (only on certain message boards, so it. Might be CSS or JS related?)
- icodemuch 7y agoThanks for the heads up! I was just about to update. Didn’t see anything about the 32/64 bit thing in the update release..
- m000 7y ago> I've had to use Pages instead of Word and can't use Adobe products anymore And this "doesn't seem too bad"? These are the industry standards for productivity. Pages on the other hand is only good for throw-away projects. Last time I checked, importing and exporting to Microsoft Office sucked. So, Catalina pretty much turns your professional machine into an overpriced netbook. Microsoft/Adobe will of course eventually release 64bit versions of their software. But these will cost extra $$$ on top of the premium you have already paid for Apple hardware. A lot of money with doubtful productivity gains. This won't make any professional happy.
- sitzkrieg 7y agonot sure about this, I just upgraded and all of my office apps still work
- jedberg 7y agoMicrosoft and Adobe already have 64 bit versions of everything. I just haven't upgraded in eight years. So it's really my fault.
- m000 7y agoI was pretty sure I got 64bit warnings for both of them fairly recently. But looking at the binaries now, they're both 64bit indeed. Still, I'm running both using a site license from my work. The upgrade cost per user in site licensing is pretty low. If I had to pay myself for a single license, I'd bet I wouldn't have upgraded for eight years either. And the Office/Adobe CC subscription costs may not be insignificant either, depending on where you live.
- gergles 7y agoThere are 64 bit versions of the Microsoft Office apps. Do they not work in Catalina?
- mrpippy 7y agoOffice on the Mac has been 64-bit (only) for the last 3 years, and it should work fine in Catalina.
- rabboRubble 7y agoHa! Literally just upgraded to Mojave yesterday thinking it had been long enough to iron out the bugs.
- FraKtus 7y agoI use Media Rage to tag my mp3 since ever, and there is no hope that it will be updated. The application does just what I need. I am also about to buy RockSmith on Steam, but it's 32 bits at the moment. I currently used it on my PlayStation but want to have it on macOS to access more songs. It looks like you find many games on steam that are 32 bits only. On our side when OS X was introduced we trusted Steve when he said Carbon is there to stay and will be 64 bits. We took a few years a few years ago to do the switch...
- mkasu 7y agoThis year all their OSes seem to be riddled with issues at release. - iOS 13.0 was so bad they released 13.1 in less than 5 days, but even now many things are still hit and miss (with 13.2 in beta) - watchOS 6.0 is also still pretty bad and not yet fixed (with 6.1 in beta) - macOS 10.15 GM seems pretty buggy - Well, I think tvOS 13 is ok? While the situation might be better for people who use the latest betas, it is still a horrible current user experience for all normal users just updating their devices. Lots of cross-platform features introduced across these updates (like the new iCloud features and new Reminder apps, etc.) are also in a horrible state. I'm not sure what their QA team is doing this year but it seems almost everything planned for this Fall would have been better off if pushed back a couple of months. Well, if it weren't for device compatibilities... (the iPhone 11/Watch 5 seemed to be more important than stable software across all their platforms and other devices)
- neuronic 7y agoThe question is what is Apple doing in their software development? From the outside, it looks like there are glaring issues within their engineering teams. iOS 11 was a complete disaster and it took an entire OS upgrade cycle (iOS 12) to control the most pressing issues. Apple is constantly releasing wild bugs and after getting burned multiple times now, they still don't seem to tackle this internal problem.
- saagarjha 7y agomacOS was pushed back. Not a couple of months, mind you, but at least a couple of weeks.
- mkasu 7y agoComparing iOS 10~13 with macOS 10.12~15 release dates, macOS seems to always come out 7 days after iOS. This year it has been 12 days after iOS 13.0, instead. Wouldn't really call that much of a push back. It's less than one week behind the usual schedule..
- Uupis 7y agoFor me, tvOS 13 broke HDMI-CEC and rendered AirPlay audio extremely spotty.
- jacobjuul 7y agoAren't most Adobe products 64bit?
- bonestamp2 7y agoCurrent versions are. But, if you bought CS6 outright when Adobe switched to a cloud subscription model then CS6 is not going to work any longer (it's 32 bit). That's the boat I am in. I can afford their cloud subscription but out of principle I will try their main competitor first (Affinity: $50 one time purchase). I will try running it in a VM second. Only if neither of those solutions are satisfactory will I pay a monthly fee for software that I use very little.
- dgellow 7y agoNo adobe and office products? That sounds quite bad! Edit: it seems to be only old versions that won’t be supported (office 2011).