10 ms·
From a copyright law perspective, this seems wild. Microsoft is downloading and running binaries from entities that may have never given Microsoft license to do
by AlexandrB 7y ago
From a copyright law perspective, this seems wild. Microsoft is downloading and running binaries from entities that may have never given Microsoft license to do so, including Microsoft's competitors. All based on a permission setting configured by an unrelated third party (the user).
- gnode 7y ago> never given Microsoft license to do so It's possible that they don't need it. There are fair use exemptions for reverse engineering and automated analysis. These may be the legal basis on which anti-malware research can be conducted.
- Analemma_ 7y agoIndeed, there have to be exceptions like this. Otherwise malware authors could sue AV companies for infringement, which don’t seem to fit the intention of IP law.
- zeveb 7y ago> Otherwise malware authors could sue AV companies for infringement, which don’t seem to fit the intention of IP law. 'You may sue the AV company for $1 million; users who suffered from your malware will civilly sue for $100 billion, and the government will charge you with crimes and put you away for a decade. Your move.'
- wtracy 7y agoA tangent: There's this fascinating (to me, anyway) line between "viruses" (including worms, Trojans, and similar malware) that antivirus programs will tackle, and adware/spyware that they usually don't. The difference between the two is whether it not there's a corporation publicly taking credit for the program and suing antivirus companies for defamation over calling it a "virus". Adware/spyware is limited in distribution methods and payload types by the letter of the law, but otherwise the two classes are functionally identical.
- appleflaxen 7y agobut until there is a court case with specific facts, that is very much a hope and a prayer by microsoft. it is, indeed, a risk they are taking.
- em-bee 7y agoi believe fair use only applies to software that you legally acquired. if microsoft copies an application from my computer without asking, then it did not legally acquire it. malware is a different case. malware entered my computer with the permission of the malware creator. i didn't steal it from them, but it came to me willingly. hence i am allowed to analyze it, and i am allowed to delegate that task to someone else.
- cududa 7y agoYes but who’s to say it came to your machine under such circumstances
- icebraining 7y agoMicrosoft is the one that has to prove it has a valid license, not the other way around.
- crest 7y agoLet Microsoft deal with VirtualBox license claims from Oracle.
- Someone1234 7y agoYou didn't explain what this has to do with copyright? CFAA[0] (or even [1]) seems like a better avenue to explore, but still likely a dead-end. Copyright seems like a misnomer. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Espionage_Act_of_1996 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Espionage_Act_of_1996
- TeMPOraL 7y agoSoftware is covered by copyright; if I write some program and compile it, and they copy it off my machine behind my back to run somewhere, it is copyright violation, is it not?
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoPretty sure by you having this malware submission feature enabled you have given a limited license for them to execute the binary. You're barking up the wrong tree.
- 0xffff2 7y agoYou (the user) may not have the right to grant such a license.
- moomin 7y agoAssume for a second this is correct. What's to stop virus writers from embedding a ToS preventing Microsoft from running the code? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm saying it's really hard to work out how this is meant to work.
- 0xffff2 7y agoI don't think a virus is relevant here. I'm not a lawyer, but the idea of a "terms of service" for an unwanted and maliciously installed executable seems nonsensical. Virus authors can include whatever TOS they want, but the "user" hasn't agreed to the TOS practically by definition.
- jumpingmice 7y agoIndeed the ENTIRE basis of the EULA is that the user copies the software by executing it, whereupon a copy exists both on-disk and in-memory. This is long settled jurisprudence. I’m sure that if Microsoft downloads and runs an AGPL-licensed work they expose themselves to pretty severe problems.
- moron4hire 7y agoThere is also the issue that MS would have been given the copy by someone who did not have rights to distribute it, so the infringement is with the user.
- paxys 7y ago> that may have never given Microsoft license to do so I'm willing to bet it is in the license agreement for Windows and Windows Defender, so you have likely allowed Microsoft to do this
- ZiiS 7y agoJust because I have a license to run a program does not mean I have a license to sub-license it to Microsoft.
- jhanschoo 7y agoI'm pretty sure that for most home users who are also administrators of their computers, a setting pops up asking if you consent for telemetry to be collected. I'm not sure if an appropriate warning or option is given for third-party users of a computer, or if it is required for administrators to warn third-party users as such.