4 ms·
I understand the joke, but let's take it seriously. What are the main reasons people want houses and how can we preserve them when stacking? * Noise. If you w
by im3w1l 7y ago
I understand the joke, but let's take it seriously.
What are the main reasons people want houses and how can we preserve them when stacking?
* Noise. If you want to create the house experience you need to be able to jump and stomp the floor in the middle of the night without bothering anyone. Need thick and advanced floors, walls and front doors (easy to forget the last).
* Garden. Probably would need artifical light, but might be possible.
* BBQ in the garden. Maybe not impossible but might take some engineering to get the smoke out.
* Parking. Just need to ensure it exists plentifully.
* Multiple floors. Idk if people care too much for this, but easy to handle if so.
- rebeccaskinner 7y agoNoise is such a huge factor. I don't really care about having a yard or access to a garden, and for an apartment in a walkable neighborhood I would even be happy to give up parking. Unfortunately my spouse and I are looking at buying a house, which is much more expensive, less environmentally sound, and more inconvenient in nearly every way because it's essentially impossible to find shared living spaces with anything approaching sensible levels of sound isolation. I have sensory issues specifically around low frequencies, and I've never been able to comfortably live in a shared building without having to wear active noise canceling headphones nearly 100% of the time because other people in my building must listen to bass heavy music or buy large subwoofers for their televisions, and the low frequencies travel too easily through shared walls and floors/ceilings.
- scarejunba 7y agoI've constantly encountered this problem in American buildings made of wood. No one puts that sandwiched layer of sound insulation in. In the UK, on the other hand, thick stone/concrete/brick where I lived and if I shut the windows I could barely hear anything. Quiet as a mouse. Never actually heard the neighbours.
- AngryData 7y agoThere are fairly simple ways to noise cancel very well with wood structures, the problem is nobody wants to pay to do it. Double drywalled walls, internally separated walls, internal insulation, better doors and windows,etc. And it usually is still cheaper than stonework, but it also still increases construction costs. People always, always, ALWAYS, try to skimp on construction costs, even when they are already getting a fantastic deal or something far superior is only like a few cents more. People will take a 50% reduction in construction quality, longevity, and finish if it will save them 10%. Even if it ultimately only accounts for a few months worth of profit, even if it will ultimately cost them more in maintenance, even if it makes energy costs twice as high.
- pkaye 7y agoThere is plenty of technology to do this. Well known brands like Rockwool or Quietrock. Its less labor intensive and probably better for earthquake country like California. But they do cost a little extra and many people are still not willing to pay the extra cost during house construction.
- imtringued 7y agoNoise is such a small problem that I often forget that other people are living in the same building. Maybe it's a problem inherent with drywall because sound proofing requires an additional filler which costs money. I have always lived in buildings that use plaster.
- Pfhreak 7y agoGarden and BBQ I've seen handled with awesome rooftop spaces.
- TuringNYC 7y agoIn NYC and especially Brooklyn, you can have it both for a premium above regular apartments but still far less expensive than standalone single family housing — residential conversions of old industrial buildings. The floors are industrial thick but you still get most of the economies of scale from building up rather than out.
- souprock 7y agoThen the deal killer: the desire for maximum possible control via ownership, without being subject to the whims of a landlord. Even a condo fails at this. The ownership is fake. You don't have permission to bore a hole in the roof, foundation, or exterior wall. You can't paint the building with Vantablack. You have to pay a condo association fee which could change in unpredictable ways. Regular houses get much closer to the ideal, especially if rural or at least without a homeowner association. Some states even let older people defer property taxes until the property is sold.
- ClumsyPilot 7y ago> You don't have permission to bore a hole in the roof Is this really a relevant issue, when you just need a decent place to live?
- oceanplexian 7y agoThe example is pretty ridiculous but yeah, ownership unencumbered by a landlord or HOA is immensely freeing. Want to run a machine shop in the garage? Go ahead! Want to change your own oil in your car? Nobody is stopping you. Don’t like the fact that anyone can simply walk in your front door on a whim and “inspect” things in your own home? Ownership provides all of those things and a lot more.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI don't know laws in the US, but we definitely own the apartments and people can't randomly walk in for 'inspections'.
- mreome 7y agoIn most US states all that is required is 24 Hours notice of entry for any maintenance, and emergency repairs/maintenance do not require any notice. Landlords and maintenance personal will always be assessing the state/condition of the apartment whenever they are there. Since they do not need a response to the notice, if you didn't see the e-mail, or missed the piece paper tucked in your door jam, it can feel a lot like a "random inspection."
- rory096 7y agoThere's no shortage of demand for apartments. There's a shortage of supply of apartments. The main reason people want a home is to have a safe place to sleep and live. That by far trumps the concerns you listed.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoMost things you listed, like BBQ, are clearly luxuries if you just need a space to live. I come from eastern europe, where apartment blocks are common and some are quite nice, and never understood the obsessions with houses so prevalent in Uk and US.
- oceanplexian 7y agoIt’s not a luxury in the US, it’s a fact of life. Most people here grew up with backyard BBQs, air conditioning, refrigeration, and personal automobiles. Telling Americans we should downgrade our lifestyle to be more like Europeans is ridiculous.
- zamfi 7y agoUmm...apartments can have all those things. Frankly needing to have a car where I live now is the huge downgrade, I’d much rather live somewhere with sensible transit and not have to deal with the car.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoNone of the things you listed make any sence. And we are in a thread about tiny house downgrades, if you realised.
- rorykoehler 7y agoIt's not really a downgrade though. Living car free is an upgrade for example. Americans have been robbed of the ability to live car free due to asinine urban planning. Thinking having a car as being an upgrade is more a product of the poor environment than a fact.
- zamfi 7y agoI grew up in an apartment in NYC with all these things except parking — which was fine because we didn’t need a car. Frankly is was glorious. I don’t understand why more apartment buildings aren’t like this. It can’t be that expensive to make a floor that doesn’t transmit sound.