5 ms·
FWIW: a few high-rise apartment buildings would do far more for climate impact than all the trees they could possibly squeeze into Paris. Paris's building code
by ajross 7y ago
FWIW: a few high-rise apartment buildings would do far more for climate impact than all the trees they could possibly squeeze into Paris. Paris's building codes have historically been a disaster for density, and at the end of the day it's urban density that matters more than anything else. Get/keep the people off then land, then turn it into something less impactful.
- selectodude 7y agoThat’s an odd take. Paris is the densest city in the EU and one of the densest cities in the world.
- greggman2 7y agoThat's arguable one of those lies of statistics. This comes up every time for example Hong Kong is way way WAY more dense than Paris. But because of arbitrary city boundries some unpopulated mountains are included in the city borders so the true density is not remotely the density listed on these kinds of lists. Go visit Hong Kong and you'll see it's easily 5x as dense as Paris. Maybe more. The same is true of many other cities in Asia. Visit and you'll realize the stats that show Paris in the top 10 are complete BS. The same thing comes up NYC vs LA. By the land / people they are about the same density but anyone who's been to both knows NYC is more dense than LA. Using population weight density shows NYC is up to 3x more dense than LA https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/ex/sustainablecitiescollective/census-bureau-embraces-weighted-density/69236/ https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/ex/sustainablecitiescollecti... With poulation weighted density Paris is not #1 in Europe https://urbantoronto.ca/forum/threads/weighted-density-of-european-and-australian-cities.24635/ https://urbantoronto.ca/forum/threads/weighted-density-of-eu... And if the same was applied world wide Paris would not even be in the top 100
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt's also tiny. It's easy to win the "densest city" contest when you exclude the decreasingly dense outer areas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_European_Union_cities_proper_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_European_Union_cities_...
- bouh 7y agoParis is pretty dense already ! In the top 10 cities : https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-world-s-most-densely-populated-cities.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-world-s-most-densely... High towers cannot be put everywhere
- MiroF 7y ago> High towers cannot be put everywhere Why not?
- BeniBoy 7y agoThe ground. Paris's ground is not strong enough to support high rise building especially in the southern part, where a lot of it have been excavated in the last 500 years (and filled with dead bodies, ie the catacombs). Of course with clever engineering everything is possible, but that really limits the development of such towers. It is true that the main limitation still is the construction code, which preserves the global proportion of the city.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThe usual approach is to punch pilings into bedrock. Nothing new really. Hollow shafts might be an issue, but nothing a stroke of the pen won't solve.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoGets a lot more complicated when you have tunnels everywhere already.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThat’s what I meant by shafts. You could fill them, but dunno how kosher that is. It’s not like they’re open to the public or anything. I believe you can take the catacombs under Montparnasse station, so it’s a solved problem ( I hope ).
- rustyconover 7y agoHaving more Montparnasse-esque towers would destroy the a lot of the streetscapes created by Haussmann that make Paris so distinctive. How can you not love all of the chimney pots? Keep the height restrictions inside of the city and continue to keep high rises near La Défense and serve them with efficient and effective mass transit.
- throwawaysea 7y agoAgree. For some reason many people either dismiss or undervalue the character of cities and neighborhoods, which are a critical part of their culture, the quality of life, and what made them attractive in the first place.
- yardie 7y agoParis is one of the densest modern European cities I have ever lived in. My first flat was a 20sqm studio. And my last apartment was 97sqm for a family of 4. Even in NYC the smallest place I could find was 45sqm and even that was considered less than ideal. It costs a lot of fuel to keep a large apartment comfortable. So your typical American, 800sqft, 1/1 simply would not work in Paris. Micro-apartments are just becoming a thing in the US and even then there is a lot of pushback from inhabitants and developers. Finally, Paris sits in a valley. The trees aren't just an aesthetic, they help keep the inhabitants sane and clear the air. New York City on the other hand turns into a miserable, swamp during the summer. It's hot, humid, and with no breeze the air actually feels gross.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThat’s because NYC itself gets hotter than Paris. Paris isn’t very breezy at ground level because the streets are all short and keep turning. The air stays stagnant, unlike NYC’s grids. Paris’ density is from the lack of building: instead units just get sub divided ad finitum, instead of building up. Still, density isn’t high, it just feels that way, especially with Paris proper's small size: not even 2 Manhattans. Then you have larger units 95% unoccupied kept as pied-a-terres/investments. Those Haussmann buildings don’t do a good job of insulating or HVAC. Even 1970s multiunit buildings in the burbs are all single-pane windows with cracks to the outside. When you have a weak radiator-based central heating system, you don’t dare turn it down or off when you leave: your unit may never recover and be warm again. Meanwhile in North America, I turn off HVAC whenever I leave for a few hours: I know it can get back to human temperatures quickly. Though the French do a good job in summer: every window has shutters, so you can block out the sun very well. Some of my darkest days have been in Paris in summer because my hosts kept the indoors in total darkness :)
- riquito 7y agoLet's put some numbers. Paris has almost double the density then New York (20000/km2 Vs 10700/km2) Source: Wikipedia
- 7y ago
- close04 7y agoIn many large cities you see sprawling suburbs and neighborhoods with individual houses. These take up a huge area that could have been planted with trees, need a lot of new infrastructure built (a lot of asphalt), and a lot of brand new lawns to water. All of which have plenty of negative environmental impact. This also encourages people to go for personal cars since public transport never really seems to keep up efficiently given the low density and large areas. And all of those cars go to the city every day. The problem is basically everyone thinks the solution to all of this is to buy an EV (I know I'll get a lot of hate from EV owners/fans for this one; still true for those who fit the rest of the description above) instead of seeing all the other ways with far bigger impact. Like not needing a car at all, for one. This would slowly reduce traffic to the point where cutting a lane doesn't cause any severe inconvenience.
- AdrianB1 7y agoI have family in the Paris suburbs: they never have to water the lawn, there is enough rain for that. Trey also don't have a lot of asphalt, there are some narrow streets connecting village to village and even smaller streets in the villages. There are lots of trees everywhere, it's as green as you can get.
- close04 7y agoWhat I described is a general problem around most if not all big cities. This is a random internet picture from a Paris suburb (close to CDG) [0]. While there are some trees it's far from a forested area. A green lawn is a far cry from a green forest when talking climate. And any unnecessary asphalt is too much. Just browse around with satellite view if you're curious how such villages look like compared to the actual patches of forest. This is a village ~25Km from Paris, right next to a forest [1]. While these low density suburbs definitely provide more comfort for their inhabitants much like cars provide comfort for their drivers, it's a very inefficient use of that land to everyone else's disadvantage and guarantees those people have to drive to the city. Public transport wouldn't be anywhere near as efficient when you start spreading tens of Km from the city in every direction. And there are far bigger offenders out there like in this random pic. [2] > they never have to water the lawn That sounds like an anecdote but I drove through plenty of suburbs (Paris or otherwise) and most lawns were green even after heatwaves and droughts. I'm pretty sure so many still generously water their lawns. Pools just add to that. [0] https://l7.alamy.com/zooms/cc7447863ce84406b71d51be29c7b830/france-seine-saint-denis-tremblay-en-france-residential-area-in-the-cpydm5.jpg https://l7.alamy.com/zooms/cc7447863ce84406b71d51be29c7b830/... [1] https://www.google.com/maps/place/Maffliers,+France/@49.0754888,2.3034475,1837a,35y,5.44t/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x47e6433f72df61e3:0x8c8dc94c3c52b3e4!8m2!3d49.0773518!4d2.3069572 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Maffliers,+France/@49.0754... [2] http://i.huffpost.com/gen/1291806/images/o-SUBURBS-facebook.jpg http://i.huffpost.com/gen/1291806/images/o-SUBURBS-facebook....
- j-pb 7y agoThe trees are not there to prevent climate change by absorbing CO2, but to mitigate the effects of climate change by providing a cooling effect through shade and water evaporation. Reducing car traffic also helps to improve the "climate" of the city on a hot day.
- throwaway2048 7y agoParis is one of the densest city in the whole world.