4 ms·
I don't understand why you don't have banners, on stories that have had editorial changes, to say what the editorial changes are. For example (not suggestions f
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
I don't understand why you don't have banners, on stories that have had editorial changes, to say what the editorial changes are. For example (not suggestions for text) "story reposted with different timestamps", "title changed from 'X is the best thing eva'", "link changed from 'www.superspammy.co.net'", or whatever.
Is transparency of editorial actions bad somehow?
- tptacek 7y agoThe more directly you surface moderator action, the more people want to discuss moderator actions (you can see a miniature version of this phenomenon in any comment about downvoting). Keeping this kind of metacommentary out of threads is a site goal.
- dang 7y agotptacek's reply is correct. The other thing is that we try to be careful about not compromising HN's minimalism, which would be so easy to do.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago"no discussion of moderation" (like the rule on not discussing downvotes) seems to handle the first part. Often, but not consistently AFAICT, a moderator (such as yourself Dang) will add a comment to the effect that a title was changed or a link was rewritten, it's just hidden in the comments; that's a strange thing to do if you fear discussions devolving towards meta topics. Problems arise when people comment on a story when the substantive parts of the story then have been changed. As for the second part, surely optional features (as there are already, eg "display dead") don't _compromise_ minimalism.