6 ms·
Toasters do not all "work well enough". Shout if you have a toaster that you bought less than 5 years ago, that is still working. I think they're supposed to st
by denton-scratch 7y ago
Toasters do not all "work well enough". Shout if you have a toaster that you bought less than 5 years ago, that is still working. I think they're supposed to start failing after a year or two.
[Edit: if it's older than ten years, say how old - they made them better back in the olden daze]
These devices are sold for ten euros/dollars, or so. You really can't do good product design to that sort of price point. People expect to have to "recycle" them.
I bought a toaster for which you can order replacement heater elements, or a new timer. You can dismantle it and reassemble it with a normal electrician's screwdriver. The timer is clockwork. The whole thing's very steampunk.
It cost about 8 times as much as a "disposable" toaster. I don't know if it was a good deal; I'll tell you in a few decades. But if I don't have to bother with replacing it, from my POV that will be money well-spent; I'm sick of replacing stuff that should still be working. I'm sick of "hardware" that's really made of tissue-paper. And I'm sick of furniture that's made of wood-chips.
</rant>
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI agree with every point you made, especially the wood chips. however I am still peeved at you because you did not include a link to this toaster you bought. How do I get one?
- denton-scratch 7y agoThis toaster is a Dualit. I cannot recommend it as a consumer product; the company is quite nasty to deal with, I think. Also, my Dualit toaster is only two years old; for the price I paid, I'd need something more like 10 years service to be able to recommend. HTH.
- cdubzzz 7y agoWe bought the cheapest toaster we could find at a Target probably 5 - 6 years ago. Still works fine.
- nextos 7y agoWhat you are saying is sadly the reality today within most product categories. For example, go to a totally different category: clothing. In the great age of US sports clothing, tees were slowly knitted by machines called loopwheelers. E.g. tees from Champion. These days, they are crap. If you want a nice tee that will age well and last really long, you need to buy from some Japanese brands that try to imitate old Champion tees. The price is really high, and you'd most likely need to import or buy from a high end shop. I try to buy good stuff that lasts ages. I don't care paying a big premium. I try to live with around 100 items. But its really hard.
- shantly 7y agoI'm pretty sure a lot of the "improvements" in price attributed to international trade over the last ~4 decades have more to do with the lowest end of the current product range simply not existing before, i.e. the worst versions of a product are worse (and cheaper) than the worst version that was available decades ago. Those products take over—for reasons that may include consumers legitimately preferring them but also probably includes difficulty consumers have finding reliable information about products other than price—and the nicer version that used to be the norm might actually get more expensive as new market segments develop and production scale drops.
- insulanus 7y agoThis is a good point - some of what we are calling cheap crap just wasn't being made before. Besides there being more stuff of every type of buy, the purchasing power of the dollar has declined, so maybe people can't afford a toaster that's as good any more? https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SA0R https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SA0R I guess you'd have to multiply this by whatever the average wage was for each year.
- denton-scratch 7y ago"can't afford" I don't think that's right. I think it's less expensive to make stuff that doesn't need to be replaced.
- cglace 7y agoI received a toaster as a wedding present 7 years and about a week ago. We’ve used it almost everyday since then(when we are home). It’s a breville, we have a lot of their products and they all seem to hold up really well. I bought a breville coffee grinder 10 years ago that I still use every morning.
- rzzzt 7y agoHappy Anniversary! :)
- burmer 7y agoMy toaster growing up was a wedding present, for my grandparents. It still works.
- PaulHoule 7y agoMy mother-in-law bought Her first toaster made in China from Wal Mart circa 2000, it burned up in about a week. Since then the toasters i have seen don't burn up but they are incredibly slow and try to make up for it by having more slots. It doesn't help much because usually i want one slice or at most two. Did old toasters have asbestos in them?
- userbinator 7y agoDid old toasters have asbestos in them? Yes. Asbestos was everywhere at least in the first half of the 20th century. The type, amount used, and typical exposure is not really a concern, however. I'm not aware of any problems caused by using asbestos-containing toasters daily --- on the assumption that if there were, it would've been all over the news.
- aeternum 7y agoI had that same sunbeam toaster shown in the video. It worked great for the first year, then we had to throw the bread in with increasing amounts of force to get it to start. Eventually we were dropping bread from high above the toaster to get just the right amount of force. It often took many attempts, would not recommend.
- pix64 7y agoHe has a second video showing how to adjust the toaster. There is a screw at the bottom under the crumb tray which adjusts the tension.
- ImprovedSilence 7y agoRight. It’s unreal how hard it is to find decent shit built to last, and don’t tell me I’m not willing to pay a premium for it, because I am willing. What I don’t like buying is shit branded as upscale high quality that is really the same garbage underneath. I’m sure there a number of different elements at play here, but one aspect I’ve seen happen time and again is private equity buying out a company and using that strong brand to make progressively shittier and shittier goods, for the same or higher price, while still retaining enough critical mass mindshare that the brand is still “quality”.
- rabidrat 7y ago> shit branded as upscale high quality that is really the same garbage underneath. and this is how bad money drives good money out of the market. What is the general solution for this, assuming the quality level isn't illegal?
- mrami 7y agoI imagine the solution is going to be some sort of parallel to open source, that I can't quite visualize atm. Maybe the next generation beyond 3D printing will be able to do multi-component assembly tasks, and you can get/print your own high quality components, and assemble your own high quality toaster... Maybe
- ImprovedSilence 7y agoThe open source angle is an interesting concept. The raspberry pi seems to be doing quite alright, despite its design being completely open sourced. Can that model be tweaked a little to apply to all sorts of manufactured goods...? I’m mean, a brand name can have value.
- detaro 7y agoThe Raspberry Pi isn't a great example: You can't make a clone of it, because Broadcom will not sell you the SoC for it. The parent mentioned 3D printing: I think that's the space were right now this plays out the most. Many designs are open or at least have open components, and people build and sell variations, but brands and brand loyalty are very much a thing.
- multjoy 7y agoMy Kenwood thing off Amazon is still working fine after over 10 years. Wasn’t expensive, certainly isn’t artisanal.
- undersuit 7y agoI bought an $8 toaster from Walmart some years ago when I consider the economy better(cause I was also able to buy a $20 microwave). It has a plastic exterior, and a metal interior. The thermal regulator was luckily designed for this, if you start more bread immediately after the first pair it will finish faster and with less cooking. It's a very reliable toaster for $8 , and if it breaks I'm going to feel like an asshole when I throw it in the garbage. I used it in January when I toasted some banana bread.
- cameronh90 7y agoI have a toaster just about 6 years old now. It wasn't a spectacular one, just not the cheapest one from Walmart. It cost £50, still works as well as when I got it. The toaster in my rental property is now 10 years old and still going strong too. Fridges on the other hand... I've had 3 die over the same period.
- vageli 7y ago> Toasters do not all "work well enough". Shout if you have a toaster that you bought less than 5 years ago, that is still working. I think they're supposed to start failing after a year or two. > [Edit: if it's older than ten years, say how old - they made them better back in the olden daze] > These devices are sold for ten euros/dollars, or so. You really can't do good product design to that sort of price point. People expect to have to "recycle" them. > I bought a toaster for which you can order replacement heater elements, or a new timer. You can dismantle it and reassemble it with a normal electrician's screwdriver. The timer is clockwork. The whole thing's very steampunk. > It cost about 8 times as much as a "disposable" toaster. I don't know if it was a good deal; I'll tell you in a few decades. But if I don't have to bother with replacing it, from my POV that will be money well-spent; I'm sick of replacing stuff that should still be working. I'm sick of "hardware" that's really made of tissue-paper. And I'm sick of furniture that's made of wood-chips. > </rant> Might I ask what brand of toaster is it?
- eldenbishop 7y agoSounds suspiciously like a Dualit... https://www.dualit.com/products/classic-toasters https://www.dualit.com/products/classic-toasters
- denton-scratch 7y agoOh, you got me. I was trying to avoid mentioning brands.
- jdnenej 7y agoI have never seen a toaster just randomly break. I have had 2 toasters in my life. The first one broke because someone attempted to clean it and after that it would trip the ground power breaker on use. The second one has been working for about 5 years now.
- organsnyder 7y agoWe have the same toaster we got for a wedding present 13 years ago. It was not an expensive model (probably $30). I didn't realize that this was an appliance category that was prone to failures.
- copperx 7y agoThey aren't. The last $5 toaster I bought has been working for 12+ years. There aren't many points of failure in a cheap toaster. Add fancy features and the story changes.
- bcrosby95 7y ago> And I'm sick of furniture that's made of wood-chips. Yeah, I learned woodworking partially because I wanted furniture I knew wasn't made from crap. It's a fun hobby that lets me step away from the computer. Nevermind all the chemicals they use in some of this stuff. We bought a dresser and it smelled so bad we had to leave it in the garage for half a year before we used it indoors.
- ryacko 7y agoThe Dualit toaster in my household was recommended by an appliance repairman. It is reliable so far, but it wasn't until the past year that the medium setting on the timer actually resulted in medium toasting.
- carlmr 7y ago>Shout if you have a toaster that you bought less than 5 years ago, that is still working. I think they're supposed to start failing after a year or two. I bought mine in 2015 and it works. I've never had a toaster fail either. I'm not sure what you're doing with your toasters. One of my water boilers failed (lid hinge broke). My oven recently broke after 12 years. All in all I don't have many problems with appliances breaking. I think it's more survivorship bias to think that old appliances were better. The ones you see surviving are the ones that didn't break a long time ago.
- denton-scratch 7y agoI assume you're not trolling; people don't troll on HN, right? "2015" Cool. That's four years ago. I use toasters to toast stuff. Mainly pre-sliced bread, sometimes bread I sliced by hand. Occasionally bread I baked myself. Srsly - I'm not trying to toast building materials, or bathroom tiles, or garden waste. And I don't know why four years is supposed to be a good lifespan for a device that has no parts that have any kind of failure-plan. I mean, a toaster should last forever. "Survivorship bias": The "ones I see surviving" have all failed, in point of fact. They've all broken down. The only "machines" I own that are older than five years are [1] a ROTEL audio amplifier (cheap == < £120, works well), and [2] Monitor Audio bookshelf speakers (about £400 for the pair, they look nice too). Both of these are more than 20 years old. But my beef isn't about toasters; a cheap toaster costs about EU20, who gives a shit. It's about washing machines and dishwashers. These things cost from EU300 to EU700; and as far as I can tell, it doesn't matter how much you are prepared to spend, it's going to fail within five years (and you're going to have to call out a mechanic several times during that interval). There's no "survivorship bias" going on here; the stuff I've referred to that survived belonged to my parents. Dude, they've both died.
- carlmr 7y agoNo, I wasn't trolling. Maybe I'm just extremely lucky but my current oven is 7 years old and works very well. I'm even an avid baker and cook, so it's not like I underutilize my appliances. My washing machine is currently only 4 years old.
- phyllostachys 7y agoI think my wife and I have a toaster from when we first got married. It'll be 13 years this month. It's probably a 2009 or 2010 model, so really only about a decade or a little less old.