3 ms·
So, even if he published a replicable study that was convincing, you'd toss it merely because of his affiliations? That seems like... a poor way to do science.
by dekhn 7y ago
So, even if he published a replicable study that was convincing, you'd toss it merely because of his affiliations?
That seems like... a poor way to do science.
Personally (I'm a PhD scientist in biology) I think a lot of the claims about sugar aren't actually supported by the evidence and are in fact just driven by super-egotist scientists who want peoeple to believe what they believe (lookin' at you, Lustig).
- ssijak 7y agoSugar is missused word in the diet world. Some groups of people (mostly keto and carnivore group, but others too) use sugar for every type of carbohydrate, lumping simple sugars, fibers and starches together. Lusting from what I remember does make distinction from the different types of carbs. And yes, not all carbs are the same. Some ARE bad, like simple sugars and processed fructose (unless eaten rarely and very moderately) but some are not, like starches from whole foods and fiber!
- belltaco 7y agoHe didn't publish a replicable study, he just said the risk is acceptable.
- dekhn 7y agometastudies are trivial to replicate because there is no additional data collection, etc. most metastudies are implemented as simple scripts that can be run by somebody else.