6 ms·
This kind of thing makes me glad not to be an American consumer. The article cites the example of CenturyLink's "Internet Cost Recovery Fee", which is a $4/mo
by Macha 7y ago
This kind of thing makes me glad not to be an American consumer.
The article cites the example of CenturyLink's "Internet Cost Recovery Fee", which is a $4/mo fee not listed in your price that is supposed to cover CenturyLink's costs of network expansion. I don't know how you can argue this is not part of the rate which CenturyLink themselves are charging for the service. Some of the other examples, like Comcast's passing on of government fees outside of the headline price I could understand as political differences, the same way you do not include sales tax in advertised prices (which annoys me every time I'm in the US), but I don't see how the "Internet Cost Recovery Fee" is not actionable fraudulent advertising.
In comparison, my ISP's advertised price is €80/mo. I pay €80/mo. In exchange, I get 400mbit/s broadband with no extra fees. This is technically a business plan, but the only extra price weirdness for consumer plans is the 6 month introductory rate.
- weberc2 7y agoFor what it’s worth, cable companies are the rare exception in American consumerism in that there is very little competition. I wouldn’t regard this as emblematic. EDIT: I’d really like to know why folks are downvoting this.
- Causality1 7y agoBecause it's absolutely emblematic. Hidden fees riddle American life. "convenience fees" and "processing fees" for everything from movie and concert tickets to hotel rooms.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoTipping is another big one. Americans love price obfuscation.
- Pfhreak 7y agoCable, airlines, internet, insurance, food, cellular service, social networks, medical supplies, mattresses, search engines, and many more industries have very little competition. It's absolutely emblematic.
- barry-cotter 7y agoCable is by all accounts perfectly fine in areas with multiple providers and real competition. Airlines were for the rich in the 70’s. Now they’re flying buses. Unpleasant and cheap. Competition in airlines is so brutal that it’s uncertain whether the US airline industry as a whole has ever turned a profit or if on net it's just burned investor money. In social networks I remember Friendster, Bebo, Google+, MySpace and many others. Snapchat still exists. This is a contestable market and it’s absolutely contested. Search engines likewise. Bing and DuckDuckGo are perfectly serviceable for most purposes, if not academic search, and the switching costs are non-existent. In industries with little relevant competition it’s either because the government gave one company a monopoly, the Comcast effect, or because they’re just crushingly better than the competition, Alcoa or Google. The dangers of monopoly are in oversold to a completely ludicrous degree compared to the historical record. Look at Standard Oil, the poster child for the trusts. It drove competitors out of business through expertise and economies of scale while increasing quality and decreasing prices. Then the government broke it up after it had started to lose market share anyway. Monopoly gets an insane amount of coverage in economics compared to how often it arises in the real world outside of government mandates[1]. [1]http://png.cdn.mises.org.468elmp01.blackmesh.com/sites/default/files/rae9_2_3_3.pdf http://png.cdn.mises.org.468elmp01.blackmesh.com/sites/defau... The Myth of Natural Monopoly It is a myth that natural monopoly theory was developed first by economists, and then used by legislators to "justify" franchise monopolies. The truth is that the monopolies were created decades before the theory was formalized by intervention-minded economists, who then used the theory as an ex post rationale for government intervention. At the time when the first government franchise monopolies were being granted, the large majority of economists understood that large-scale, capital intensive production did not lead to monopoly, but was an absolutely desirable aspect of the competitive process.
- Pfhreak 7y agoParent poster said, "Very little competition" not "no competition". I'm not arguing these industries are monopolies, but they have very few players and very large conglomerates that own most of the market share -- often between 1-3 players.
- 7y ago
- barney54 7y agoThere is very little competition because the cable companies worked with cities to limit competition by convincing cities that the only way they would build out a cable network is if the cable companies were given a monopoly. It’s ugly. Competition is critical.
- weberc2 7y agoI don’t doubt this. Regulatory corruption is a real issue. Fortunately this isn’t an issue for most consumer-facing industries in the US.
- wil421 7y agoI have Comcast in 2 states and the bills are very simple they charge me X amount for both, the same rate I agreed to when the plan started, and 0 extra fees. Here's where things get complicated. The city I used to live in charged AT&T a municipal telecom tax of $1.25 when I moved the fee went away and I've since changed to Comcast. If I look at my cellphone bill I see a $0.11 tax for the state, and $0.06 for the county. Remember you can tax at the federal/state/county/city level in the US. I used to work at a restaurant in the city limits that had a small percentage tax on alcohol, if you walk across the street its no longer in the city limits thus no excise tax. I don't envy the programmer who has to make all this happen.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s just it. Most of the fees that Comcast charge aren’t government taxes but are made to look like them.
- sowbug 7y agoApparently you can tax at the corporate level as well.
- chongli 7y agodo not include sales tax in advertised prices I live in Canada and we do the same thing here. I think it’s a good thing to remind everyone of sales taxes at checkout time. Sales taxes are regressive taxes. We should get rid of them in favour of a more progressive tax, such as land value tax. Laws that mandate hiding sales tax by including it in the advertised price only serve to entrench a tax that should be repealed. Edit: I just wanted to note that the vast majority of people I see defending sales taxes (i.e. VAT) are Europeans and the people opposed are North Americans. Putting aside the argument over whether it’s a good idea or not, I think this is good (albeit anecdotal) evidence that hiding/showing the tax in the purchase price at checkout affects people’s opinion of the tax.
- this_was_posted 7y agoI'd be interested to hear your reasoning for why you think sales tax is so bad. Personally I see it as one of the more reasonable ways of taxing people, as for every product sold the government/society had a part in making the sale of the product possible.
- mikepurvis 7y agoIt's regressive because poor people spend a greater proportion of their income (like, all of it) on retail purchases, so they pay the rate (13% currently) on all their income. Where middle and upper class people who sit on money, invest it, whatever pay a much lower effective rate.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoIt is called opportunity. Poor people in America are not forced to remain poor. They can (and do) improve their lot in life, and take advantage of being not poor like the other not poor people.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- unreal37 7y agoReminds me of the fees airlines charge. So you think you're paying $400 for that flight? It's $512. Because there are things like "fuel surcharges". The cost of fuel should be built into the price. It's core to what I am buying, not a tax and not an optional add-on.
- kevindong 7y agoAre you an American? In the US, airlines/travel agencies/literally everyone selling airline tickets has to disclose the final price on the initial search screen (rounded up). It's actually mildly difficult to get the airlines/agents to break the final price down into its components. I've taken dozens of flights in the US and I've never been charged a surprise fee.