3 ms·
i think a mistake netflix has made is to encourage exclusives. When netflix had marketshare and somewhat a monopoly, they should've pushed for laws to prevent
by chii 7y ago
i think a mistake netflix has made is to encourage exclusives.
When netflix had marketshare and somewhat a monopoly, they should've pushed for laws to prevent monopolies/exclusive content (or create deals/made agreements for such). Instead, they leaned in to making content the main attraction of their service.
I want streaming service to be content agnostic, and that studios making the content are mandated to allow all streaming services to serve their content. Streaming services should compete on speed, convenience and other non-content related features. Imagine if DVD/tape players were content exclusive - you'd have to buy a differently branded DVD player different shows from different studios!
- paulryanrogers 7y agoSo streaming as a commodity? Perhaps if Internet service were regulated like a utility then paying for fragmented streaming wouldn't be so bad. As it is just a few hundred megabits per second rivals the cost of television cable in my parent's time.
- kemitche 7y ago> you'd have to buy a differently branded DVD player different shows from different studios! You mean like having to go Blu-Ray for shows/movies from some studios, and HD-DVD for shows from others? https://www.engadget.com/2008/02/20/two-years-of-battle-between-hd-dvd-and-blu-ray-a-retrospective/ https://www.engadget.com/2008/02/20/two-years-of-battle-betw...
- scarface74 7y agoDo you want to force Disney to allow streaming its own content to rivals? Who should decide a fair licensing cost? Commodity products don’t make money when they can’t differentiate - see Spotify, Android manufacturers, and PC manufacturers.
- kuschku 7y agoThat's great though. Everything should be a commodity, easily available and with profit margins nearing zero.
- scarface74 7y agoSo should your labor also be a commodity?
- kuschku 7y agoIt has already been for centuries, that's why unions even ever became necessary.
- scarface74 7y agoDo you want your labor to be a commodity where you are told by government edict that you can only make 10% above poverty level?
- chii 7y ago> 10% above poverty level that is not what the comment is about - you added the above poverty bit yourself. The idea that labour is a commodity is something _companies_ created when industrialization occured, and even though it sucked for artisans who previously commanded high wages, commodity workers were the reason products became cheaper (as well as machines & industrialization). Just because you're a commodity worker, doesn't mean you have to be poor. If your skill is in demand, you can still command high prices for it (which is what programmers of today are). I don't doubt that one day, the needs of skills of programming are going to fall off a cliff (i.e., due to AI). But programming as a skill today is still a commodity, and that is a good outcome.
- scarface74 7y agoNo what I’m asking is that if you want all products - including your labor operating like the “radio model”, that means you want the government deciding what a fair wage should be and deciding that everyone should get that wage. He thinks that 10% is a fair profit. Who should decide?
- 7y ago
- chii 7y agoYes. > Who should decide a fair licensing cost? the cost is the same - the studio decides it, and any streaming services gets to use the IP if they pay the studio. > Commodity products don’t make money when they can’t differentiate that's absolutely not true. They can just charge X% above operating costs (where X is usually 10%). It is true that they cannot make exorbitant amounts of high margin profit. But that's a good outcome.
- scarface74 7y agoSo now the government gets decide where you sell your products and how much you should make? Would you be okay if the government forced software producers to sell their software anywhere. And when you have s commodity product - you must compete on price. That brings profits to mostly zero.
- chii 7y ago> Would you be okay if the government forced software producers to sell their software anywhere. yes - i hate that there are platform exclusives (and not just on PC, but on phones). Things being a commodity is how competition occurs, and how the average consumer reaps the benefits of improvement. Imagine if computer CPUs were not commoditized, and you had to buy into a particular instruction-set. It would cost so much more to do any computing than today, that i think we won't see the explosion of internet till another decade. Companies that want monopolies know this, and want to delay it as much as possible to maximize a product's profitability without adding extra work. Gov't should try to combat that, while keeping the playing field fair for all.
- scarface74 7y agoyes - i hate that there are platform exclusives (and not just on PC, but on phones). Now you want the government to force software developers to pour resources into supporting all platforms? Should Sony be forced to develop for the Xbox and the Switch? Things being a commodity is how competition occurs, and how the average consumer reaps the benefits of improvement. That’s completely backwards. When everyone is forced to compete on price, no one is going to spend money on improving their product. Imagine if computer CPUs were not commoditized, and you had to buy into a particular instruction-set. CPUs aren’t commoditized. Intel has had a monopoly on the x86 instruction set for decades and licenses it to one minor competitor. You do have to buy into a particular instruction set to have any hope of having a viable product - x86 for desktop and ARM for mobile. Gov't should try to combat that, while keeping the playing field fair for all. And now you are suggesting that the government gives power to middle men - you are already see that in alcohol distribution in some states. How is it giving producers more freedom by introducing a middle man that will raise prices? Are you also against people selling software on their own website? Authors selling books on their own site? Musicians selling music on their own website?
- fhennig 7y agoYes, I want this as well. In the beginning I liked netflix because it felt as if everything was there, like on spotify. I always saw netflix just as a distributor of content produced by others. Then they started to make all their own shows, and I found less and less of the stuff that I wanted to watch. It's as if my ISP would stop to serve me google and facebook, and instead made their own homemade replacements and served me those instead.