4 ms·
For me, as long as it doesn’t happen too often, that referees do not see everything that happens on the field is a feature because it increases spectator engage
by Someone 7y ago
For me, as long as it doesn’t happen too often, that referees do not see everything that happens on the field is a feature because it increases spectator engagement (classical example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_goal#1966_World_Cup_Final https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_goal#1966_World_Cup_Fina...)
That’s especially true when it leads to an underdog winning a game.
Yes, on the day, that’s unfair to the better team, but in the long term, it makes the sport more popular relative to sports with ‘duller’ refereeing, leading to a net benefit even for that better team. (Edit: one should realize that incentives aren’t perfectly aligned in sports. Clubs compete with other clubs, so they want to win games, but sports leagues such as the NBA and the NFL compete with each other and Netflix, so they want interesting games)
Open problem is to define “doesn’t happen too often”. American football, IMO, needs video review; soccer doesn’t.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoSoccer needs video reviews for dives, however. I like that the MLS (USA association football league) fines players after the fact by reviewing later. The viewers get the suspense now, but later the players can be suspended for a game or fined for taking a fake dive.
- teddyh 7y ago> is a feature because it increases spectator engagement That sound like the kind of optimization (aiming for audience “engagement”) which gave the media its current culture of clickbait and striving for maximum enragement and polarization. I.e. even though the audience could be said to (in some sense) prefer it, this is not necessarily a direction which you want to allow.
- scarejunba 7y agoIf Arsenal had lost on that atrocious offside call against United on Monday I would have slit the linesman's tyres. Thank god for VAR.