5 ms·
I'll be brutal here: Robert's Rules of Order are a severely outdated method that creates divisiveness and polarization through majoritarian voting -- the same t
by crazygringo 7y ago
I'll be brutal here: Robert's Rules of Order are a severely outdated method that creates divisiveness and polarization through majoritarian voting -- the same types of problems we see in politics today. It made sense as a big improvement in the 1800's -- it doesn't in 2019. Key quote:
"Its arcane rituals of parliamentary procedure and majority rule usually produce a victorious majority and a very dissatisfied minority that expects to raise its concerns, again, at the next possible meeting."
Anyone considering Robert's Rules should read this first: "Breaking Robert's Rules: The New Way to Run Your Meeting, Build Consensus, and Get Results" [1] by Lawrence Susskind -- an MIT and Harvard professor. [2]
That book is a "popular" condensed version of the ideas behind practical consensus-building. If you want to implement it in your organization, see his full-length "The Consensus Building Handbook". [3] It's textbook-priced unfortunately (for organizations to purchase, not curious individuals), but many academic institutions will have direct access to it online. [4]
[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0195308360 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0195308360
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Susskind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Susskind
[3] https://www.amazon.com/Consensus-Building-Handbook-Comprehensive-Agreement-dp-0761908447/dp/0761908447 https://www.amazon.com/Consensus-Building-Handbook-Comprehen...
[4] http://sk.sagepub.com/reference/the-consensus-building-handbook http://sk.sagepub.com/reference/the-consensus-building-handb...
- tehjoker 7y agoI've used Robert's rules in a political context. Since we believe in rule by the majority (democracy) majoritarian rule is fine. Consensus cannot always be built and some people will lose a given fight. However, Robert's rules are so easy to game that it's easy for people skilled at them to use procedural tactics to gum up the works or blindside less skilled participants.
- jhbadger 7y agoIn many cases, "consensus" is just rubbing salt in the wounds of the losers -- not only do they not get their way, they have to pretend that they agree with the outcome that is decided on. As David Mitchell once said in one of his monologues, the idea of consensus robs people of the ability to say "I told you so!" when the bad idea that the majority favored fails, because with consensus you have to share responsibility with those who favored the idea.
- journalctl 7y agoAgreed about the arcana of RR being used against people, but then again, isn’t that how democracy works anyway? Come prepared and do your homework or else you might miss out. It should never be a barrier to participation, but if everyone knows the rules except you, don’t expect to have an easy time.
- codemac 7y agoWhy was it a big improvement in the 1800's but not now? I don't understand this sentiment -- passing laws looks almost identical today, and I think congress was even more divided (e.g. just post civil war?). I've seen RR used extremely effectively in contentious meetings to get to resolution -- because action is more important to the group than the individual's inclusion. Susskind's methods always seemed like the work you should do outside of the actual meetings. Look at the steps around "fact finding", "assigning responsibilities", etc -- that's exactly what congress does today! (and what you should be doing outside your meetings) Are there any videos of how a meeting would be run with these rules? If I fly across the country to meet with a board and we need to make decisions that day, how do I accomplish that with consensus building?
- bluGill 7y agoThe improvement wasn't in congress, parliament, or other government bodies. The improvement was tiny small gatherings where previously there were no rules and so people would shout each other down. By having a set of rules meetings could assure order, and have a previously agreed on process to ensure not just the loudest voices were heard - without spending far too much time on debate as everybody says the same things in different words. There are many possible rules. Roberts is better than most because most people are used to them (because they have been around so long). Even if you have never read the book, you probably have been in a meeting where someone says "I move..." responded by "second", a debate, and then a vote. Just knowing this order exists keeps things moving.
- brandmeyer 7y agoThe article points this out explicitly. > The groups who find Robert’s Rules most helpful are those who know who they are and generally where they want to go but disagree about how to get there. For these groups, the process of making motions keeps the body in motion but does not fracture it. > Groups that are deeply divided may find that Robert’s Rules exacerbates differences, giving power to the side that knows the rules best. We’ve all been here too. [examples follow]
- PacificKoolaid 7y agoRoberta's Rules of Order [5] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0787964239 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0787964239
- dev_tty01 7y agoI don't disagree that many groups could get closer to consensus with better meeting management, but in practice building consensus is often an illusion. I've been in organizations where building consensus meant continuing to meet and rehash until the minority group got sick of meeting and stopped arguing. Then we voted and the majority ruled, but there was still no consensus. Massive waste of time. Make your case succinctly, vote, and move on. You win some and you lose some. Problems arise when the minority opinion members can't recognize the possibility that they were perhaps wrong or perhaps not seeing the complete picture. No truly productive debate can ever occur unless both sides are willing to recognize the very real possibility that they are wrong or at least that there are often multiple reasonable ways to solve a problem.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 7y agoWhy is it only the minority that needs to recognize they might be wrong? Sometimes the majority is wrong.
- tengbretson 7y agoBecause the majority opinion is set to actually be implemented, so it will be obvious to everyone whether or not it is wrong.
- jeegsy 7y agoQuite right. As the article notes, a key part of Robert was that everyone agreed to the rules. This says nothing about whether or not there will be total agreement with outcomes. To pretend that so called "consensus" building will be the magic pill for disagreement is foolhardy.
- lazzlazzlazz 7y agoI haven't read the Consensus Building Handbook, but it seems like a handbook for building consensus, and not a handbook for maintaining order in a parliamentary setting. They don't seem like substitutes for one another - maybe complements.
- garmaine 7y agoRobert’s rules of order are used EVERYWHERE, not just in parliament. You’re local school’s PTA probably follows RRO for its meetings, but in a context where unanimity probably matters more. That’s the subtext of the comment you are replying to.
- hinkley 7y ago> a very dissatisfied minority that expects to raise its concerns, again, at the next possible meeting. This blew up pretty badly for me on one job. Among the people who would be materially responsible for a decision, there was unanimous agreement on which solution was right for the job. There were pretty senior folk. Half of them were the people you go to when you can't get anything to work. The majority of the team did not agree with them. So the people who had no skin in the game were getting to set the agenda. Pretty big morale drop in that subgroup. I left while they were still trying to sort this problem out, but the feeling was somewhere between insubordination and strike, if we couldn't get the rules of engagement adjusted to weigh the opinions of directly affected individuals more highly.
- firepoet 7y agoThis is why our development team operates using unanimous consent. We have gotten really good at it in fact! It just takes practice and trust. Robert’s rules definitely takes practice, but not trust.
- jakeogh 7y ago"Its arcane rituals of parliamentary procedure and majority rule usually produce a victorious majority and a very dissatisfied minority that expects to raise its concerns, again, at the next possible meeting." so may extra words. "Its procedure produce a majority and a minority that expects to raise its concerns, again, at the next meeting." if that's not desired, use > than a majority.
- firepoet 7y agoDefinitely going to check this out. I’ve studied consent decision making through Sociocracy which was based on the Quaker approach to consensus building. It will be nice to see another take.
- specialist 7y agoThanks for the links; great study material. "creates divisiveness and polarization through majoritarian voting" FWIW, we use Approval Voting for our most contentious decisions (endorsements, resolutions). It's been super effective and we now have fewer friendship ending arguments. Alas, we still have to suspend the rules each time. I'm hopeful that eventually we'll amend our bylaws to make Approval Voting more the norm. Change is hard and bringing everyone along takes. so. much. effort.
- lazulicurio 7y agoWhen you say "approval voting" do you mean unanimous consent? Approval voting is a method for elections, and off the top of my head I can't think of any way it could be applied to a yes/no motion.
- specialist 7y agoSorry for being vague. With our bylaws and RRO, the order endorsements are considered is critical, and arbitrary. Lots of hurt feelings. Now we suspend the rules, consider all endorsements en masse (voice vote, tabulated if needed), which stack ranks the order, then resume RRO. Resulting in the endorsements with the greatest support being considered first. FWIW, I proposed this change based on my workplace voting experiments. Such as using approval voting for triage to expedite determining priority. I'm very excited to read crazygringo's links above, gleen other useful ideas. Governance is just another technology. Ripe for innovation.
- lazulicurio 7y agoThanks for taking the time to explain. Hearing about regular use of unusual motions (e.g. suspend the rules) tends to pique my skepticism. From the way you described it, having a special method for deciding the order of voting on endorsements does sound reasonable. Just so many times when I see people complaining about Robert's Rules it's not about the rules themselves but about organization-specific issues or about people being dicks (which can happen regardless of the parliamentary authority used).