3 ms·
Reason #37 that I am no longer a scientist: most of my time as a scientist was spent attempting to replicate the positive results of other scientists and failin
by dekhn 7y ago
Reason #37 that I am no longer a scientist: most of my time as a scientist was spent attempting to replicate the positive results of other scientists and failing, because the work was not replicable.
I actually trust negative results way more than positive results now- it's a proxy that you can trust the investigator. I wish we had a Journal of Negative Results.
- cheez 7y agoDon't let your dreams be dreams. Everyone would like this.
- rjyoungling 7y agoSuch a fascinating take. When I was young I used to think that scientists and the scientific process were perfectly objective. As you get older you learn that human beings have human being problems. Those don't magically disappear once you become a scientist. You see this even in highly objective fields such as physics, where much progress comes from the previous generation simply dying. Our own ego's, as well as the factors mentioned in the article, create problems much more than you might expect when you're young and naive.
- dekhn 7y agoIs physics truly objective? I see people still arguing about quantum mechanics, and it looks like the safest conclusion is that we don't actually live in a straightforward, temporally causal world (prediction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheeler%27s_delayed-choice_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheeler%27s_delayed-choice_exp..., experimental support: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser) Nobody's making progress because people are dying (we still see many vestiges of the Cophenhagen interpretation!)
- rjyoungling 7y agoYeah, I see your POV. Think it depends where you're coming from. Physics is objective if by objective you mean we can predict how the wavefunction will evolve according to the Schrodinger equation. (Depending on who you ask) it might be less objective if you ask: ''But what's REALLY going on?'' Then you start getting into the interpretations of qm and different scientists will have different views. I think it's at least likely that we'll be able to answer that question in a few decades (or at least move the ball forward). The view of Everettians, for example, is falsifiable and there are experiments going on as we speak trying to achieve that.
- denzil_correa 7y agoThere are a few journals of negative results. For example, https://jnrbm.biomedcentral.com/ https://jnrbm.biomedcentral.com/
- dekhn 7y ago"Journal of Negative Results in Biomedicine (JNRBM) ceased to be published by BioMed Central as of 1st September 2017"
- zachguo 7y agoThat's also why I gave up pursuing a Ph.D. in psychology and shifted my focus from experiment design to computational analysis & modeling. I failed to replicate a few cornerstone experiments with modern equipment and a more diverse subject group, no matter how hard I tried. https://slate.com/technology/2013/05/weird-psychology-social-science-researchers-rely-too-much-on-western-college-students.html https://slate.com/technology/2013/05/weird-psychology-social...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hannob 7y agoThere are Journals of Negative Results. This isn't really a fix, because people will still not publish negative results unless there's an incentive to do so. And there rarely is, because most negative results will be considered as boring (unless they disprove an existing, popular result). What we really need is to decouple the publishing decision from the outcome. A way to do this is to use registered reports.
- ablekh 7y agoI'm not sure about journals of negative results (though I ran across this effort: https://www.negative-results.org https://www.negative-results.org). However, I'm aware of, at least, one workshop on negative results. That was the 2015 ERROR workshop in e-science domain. Please see https://press3.mcs.anl.gov/errorworkshop https://press3.mcs.anl.gov/errorworkshop for details.