4 ms·
we've cured cancer in mice more times than people can count. It doesn't really represent forward progress in human cancer research.
by dekhn 7y ago
we've cured cancer in mice more times than people can count. It doesn't really represent forward progress in human cancer research.
- yread 7y agoGreat idea! Let's lock people in those cages instead, transplant a prostate tumor in them and feed them human chow with 1 mg/ml Amphotericin B (with 0.5mg/ml on the side to drink). Do you volunteer?
- Retric 7y agoWe have made truly incredible process in cancer treatment. From 1990 to 2010 the number of cases breast cancer stayed about the same, but the number of deaths dropped by about 1/3. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2213538315000065 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221353831... It’s hard to say what current rates are as treatment lasts so long. However, approximately 99% of people with localized breast cancer, which is ~62% of diagnoses, survive 5 years. 85% with regional cancer, spread to nearby lymph nodes or other tissue, survive 5 years. Even metastatic breast cancer has which is 6% of diagnoses has a 27% chance of surviving 5 years. Now various other types have had more or less success, but amazing work has been done.
- jessriedel 7y agoYour comment is almost completely orthogonal to dekhn's. The point is that, regardless of progress/stagnation in cancer research, success in mouse models is not a strong indicator of eventual success in humans.
- Retric 7y agoMouse models are almost the only indicator for future success. So while many fail, most progress comes through research just like this. Just remember, successful means lower the rates of deaths they don’t generally eliminate it. So, yay study 1357 got the survival rate from 5% to 10% that’s real progress. (Reported as curing cancer). Study 2217 got the survival rate from 10% or 15% wow progress. (Reported as curing cancer). Study 3... I mean grated they did help some specific individual within that study so it’s not meaningless, but come on.
- jessriedel 7y ago> Mouse models are almost the only indicator for future success. What do you mean by this? The vast, vast majority of things that work in mice do not work in humans. Even if effectiveness in mice is (approximately) necessary for eventual effectiveness in humans (say, because of our research methods), this does not make it a good indicator. "Drug doesn't immediately melt your brain" is also a necessary property, but it doesn't do a good job of predicting effectiveness.
- Retric 7y agoIf you only look at everything that has already passed the test then sure the test does not seem important. The set of all possible cancer treatments however are not just the set of treatments that pass animal models. Drugs etc need to go though several hoops before they are even tested in mice, and even more fail in mice. Everything that’s made it to this stage is extremely promising relative to the baseline.
- jessriedel 7y ago