6 ms·
The article says he found all these kids through Ancestry.com. Surely there must be many, many more whose DNA isn't in that database, no?
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
The article says he found all these kids through Ancestry.com. Surely there must be many, many more whose DNA isn't in that database, no?
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoIt also highlights (once more) how scary Ancestry.com is.
- inetknght 7y agoIn what way is this scary?
- uptown 7y agoMaybe you think it'd be fun to plug your info into Ancestry.com and see what they've got. You've got a decent life, you're living on a fixed income, but you're able to manage just fine. But you ping Ancestry, and they find you've got a gigantic family tree of relatives who you never knew about. Maybe you don't have any interest in meeting these people, but Ancestry.com sure sees some value in those connections. Maybe they strike a deal with an insurance data broker, and now this broker knows about your relatives as-well. Maybe you've got a genetic history of heart disease, a rare form of cancer, or some other medical condition which leaves you predisposed to being a high-risk candidate for some expensive medical bills in the next few years. So your insurance carrier drops you, or raises those rates to an exorbitant rate that you, on your fixed income, can no longer support. So you drop your coverage, but you get sick. Now you've got some enormous medical bills you can no longer pay for, and a rent bill you're delinquent on as-well. You're unable to get new medical coverage, because the pre-existing conditions laws have since lapsed, and all the major insurance carriers subscribe to the same data that that data-broker provided anyway, so you're likely to find similar insurance prices no matter where you go. So now you've got a medical condition you can't pay for, an apartment that's about to kick you to the curb, and few options to pay for either health or home. But hey -- cool family tree!
- streb-lo 7y agoSounds like an American problem rather than a DNA problem.
- aidenn0 7y agoIt's the dark side of "Information wants to be free." It means that as soon as any information is theoretically public, it becomes practically public.
- georgeecollins 7y agoIn China they use DNA as a way to screen if someone is Uighurs. I think this is a concern for everyone. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/21/business/china-xinjiang-uighur-dna-thermo-fisher.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/21/business/china-xinjiang-u...
- magduf 7y agoNo, that's a problem for minorities in China. Sucks to be them, sure, but that doesn't mean it's a problem for everyone on the planet, just like problems affecting Americans are also not problems for everyone on the planet. Everyone has problems. But everyone's problems are not everyone else's problems.
- magduf 7y agoIt's not really a problem right now, because the ACA prevents insurance companies from denying coverage based on pre-existing conditions. However, it could certainly become a problem in the future, because half the American population really wants the ACA to be rescinded so that insurance companies can go back to that, and they keep voting for candidates who push this.
- LinuxBender 7y agoThis scenario already happened multiple times in the 1990's. That is why I refused to give the military my DNA. I went through proper channels, submitted the FOIA requests, got tons of paperwork which amounted to "The chief medical officer may decide what is done with your genetic information". I stalled them long enough that I was still able to get out with an honorable discharge. Several marines were not as lucky as I was. It was funny though... the commander said, "Are you afraid we will clone you?" to which I replied, "No sir, you should be afraid you will clone me" and we both laughed because I was right. I explained everything you described and he helped me through the process.
- gojomo 7y agoIsn't this a non-scary consequence of Ancestry.com-like registries? It's delivering a value people want – relative discovery – and uncovering malfeasance, and further may be helping to prevent undesirable incest. That offsets these registries' other scary potential uses, like the risk of them being used to disadvantage certain genetic subgroups, or find wrongly-persecuted individuals. I would agree that this highlights how scary gamete donation is, when handlers/recipients may not be trustworthy.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> Isn't this a non-scary consequence of Ancestry.com-like registries? It's gonna be non-scary to some, scary to others. Plenty of people donated sperm thinking they'd stay anonymous forever, back before the Human Genome Project was a $1B undertaking.
- umeshunni 7y agoIf you want to stay anonymous, perhaps they should not send their DNA to an Ancestry service?
- jasonjayr 7y agoSure, but if a sibling or another direct parent does, your DNA can be inferred, or close enough to pinpoint you.
- paulddraper 7y agoNot really. If a sibling or parent sends DNA sample X, they do not know what your DNA is. If someone also provides DNA sample Y, they can know that it is the DNA of a relative of X. But...is that really worse than normal life? That's approximate not admissible in court. And DNA or not you can already figure out someone's associates a hundred different ways.
- ceejayoz 7y ago
- umeshunni 7y agoYes, that's why the article and the title say "at least"
- metamet 7y agoMorbidly fascinating, I would encourage everyone to check out this episode of the podcast Behind the Bastards: https://www.behindthebastards.com/podcasts/all-fertility-doctors-are-bastards.htm https://www.behindthebastards.com/podcasts/all-fertility-doc... There are multiple fertility doctors who have used their own sperm to impregnate their patients. Sources are listed (in plain text--looks like they need to fix the HTML), but it was shocking to learn about. Here are a few of the references: * https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/30/us/fertility-doctor-pregnant-women.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/30/us/fertility-doctor-pregn... * https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2019/08/26/fertility-fraud https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2019/08/26/fertility... * https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/9193014/British-man-fathered-600-children-at-own-fertility-clinic.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/9193014/British-man-fathere...
- aidenn0 7y agoPrior to the ability to freeze sperm, the donor needed to be on-site at the time of fertilization. On top of that, the cultural shame around infertility issues meant that the mother didn't want too many details of the donor anyways. It's super-creepy through the lens of today, but only IMO less so (but still creepy) for the time in which it happens.
- fencepost 7y agoSurely there must be many, many more whose DNA isn't in that database, no? Likely some, but I suspect the set of "sperm donor kids" has a pretty big overlap with "people interested in DNA relative matching."
- robhunter 7y agoMost (80%, nobody knows how many) "sperm donor kids" don't know they were conceived that way. It's often a family secret and many parents were advised by doctors never to tell.
- reificator 7y ago> many parents were advised by doctors never to tell. It's a good thing we've cured all genetic diseases then.
- bradlys 7y agoI was one of them for 24+ years. At least, for my experience, if you look significantly different from your family then you start to really question things and want to do DNA testing ASAP.
- valarauko 7y agoHonest Q: How does DNA testing tell you anything meaningful if you suspect a sperm donor conception? Presumably the donor was of the same race as your father.
- bradlys 7y agoCan't be guaranteed that the race is the same. I know that seems like some kind of "given" but it's clearly not in my case. I was born with brown eyes but both my parents had blue eyes. I looked nothing like them or the extended family. While that happens for non-sperm donor kids - it's exceptionally rare that they look nothing like anyone from the extended family on both sides. In my case - I probably look a lot like my biological father's side. In terms of what it tells you - it tells you what your potential ancestry could be. If you have parents who have no idea what they're ancestry is (mine don't) then you might have interest. Of course - once you do it... you're gonna find out you're a sperm donor child pretty fast.
- buboard 7y agoif these kids know how they were conceived, they d be more likely to use one of the DNA services